Comments by "Regis" (@Timbo5000) on "AJ+"
channel.
-
6
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
@williamcondon7729 Ethnicity is a factual, observable thing. You can not "identify" as an ethnicity. You either have that DNA or you don't. You also act like ethnicity is meaningless just because it changes over time, but that's nonsense. The point of ethnicity is that you have shared ancestry, wherever that ancestry may come from. And shared ancestry means shared culture and history. Ethnicity can point you directly to which culture you originated from. Every culture has their own unique mix of DNA, roughly speaking.
There is no such thing as a "pure" ethnicity, nor does any ethnicity stay the same over time. Ethnicity is just a mix of DNA of many past ethnicities that have come together. There is no continuous line of one ethnicity existing unscathed forever, perhaps with the very very rare exception of some. But ethnicity is still an accurate way to denote a particular group at a particular time. Italy has several ethnicities within its borders that are considered "Italian".
If you are one of those ethnicities, which is not a matter of identifying but a matter of which DNA you have, you can say you're of Italian descent.
What really matters, though, is being culturally part of that identity. Only then are you a "true" Italian. To be part of a group, you have to be accepted by that group. This also is not a matter of identifying. You're Italian when the Italians accept you as such. In most of Europe the rule is to acquire citizenship and then integrate into society. Or to grow up in a country and be part of that culture.
To take the example of the Jezidis in Iraq, they have stricter rules as to who is part of their society. They are more ethnicity minded people and only ethnic Jezidis are accepted to be Jezidis. They take this as far as shunning IS children that are the result of IS raping Jezidi women. In this case it is obvious that identifying as Jezidi does not make you a Jezidi. You can't enter into a cultural group without the consent of that group. Being part of a cultural identity is entirely dependent on who the culture accepts.
But you're right about one thing; that culture can tell the person falsely identifying as them that that person is wrong, but they can never stop that person form being deluded... You're just missing the fact that it is a delusion.
1