Comments by "Z P" (@zachman5150) on "A Trans EMT Challenges Matt Walsh To A Debate On Biology" video.

  1. There is only 1 kind of woman, and they're ALL born female-- making the use of 'Cis' entirely useless and irrelevant. A dude identifying as a woman doesn't make him a woman. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, a sexual preference, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female.
    3
  2.  @thekickanoragm8559  Sex/Gender= 2 (Male, Female) Personality traits and temperament = Many (None are gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch females, tomboys) Gender Roles (Vary from culture to culture, and country to country) ALL based around the various social aspects of being male or female, respectively in those various cultures, societies and countries
    3
  3.  @th3comb1ne13  Your DNA literally organizes your physical body. DNA dictates the production of objective biological differences between males and females. 100% of the population is either male or female, even intersex people. If they have a Y chromosome, they are heterogametic and male. If not, they are homogametic and female. But you knew that because you've actually educated yourself on these conditions, right? Personality traits and temperament (Neither of which is gender exclusive -- hence effeminate males, butch females and tomboys), aren't synonymous with gender or gender roles. There is no internal feeling that is exclusive to men or women (or boys/girls), what makes anyone a man or a woman is being either male or female and reaching adulthood. Their sex and stage of physical maturity makes them men or women, not some "feeling" they have. Believing there is some "essence" specific to males or female as far as feelings go, that can manifest "in the wrong body", is akin to a religious belief, having faith in something that is impossible to prove or disprove. The thing is though, that no one on the "trans" side can actually even explain what this "essence" is, they can't even explain it to themselves yet have convinced themselves that the feeling they have means they "are in the wrong body" - without realizing that their discomfort simply stems from not realizing that they view conforming to sexist stereotypes as legitimate measures of manhood or womanhood. That is why every explanation given of WHY a male "can't be a man, but is instead woman" etc. relies upon listing stereotypical stuff, or, in some cases is completely abstract and refuses to actually provide any explanation of what they mean, simply stating they "know" that what they feel means what they say it does, even though they can't actually provide a definition of it. "It's hard to explain but I know I'm right" is an attitude one constantly comes up against - a religious faith in something they can't define. This idea that the terms "man" and "woman" carry all this baggage, sexist stereotypes, that people need to live up to or feel comfortable with is a complete fabrication coming from the "trans" side. You lot want a term to reflect aspects of your personality as well, you want to create more boxes to put people in, as you won't accept simply just being a man or a woman based on being born male or female (and reaching adulthood, obviously people are boys and girls before becoming men or women), but believe you need this "freedom of expression" to broadcast what sexist stereotypes you feel more comfortable with - thinking the world needs to adopt the sexist view you lot have (you fail to see just how much you have in common with Conservatives). Replacing objective definitions which are based in physical reality, with entirely subjective metaphysical claims, is not logical in any way, is not morally superior, and is demonstrably harmful, not least to female rights and protections, but also to practically anyone that buys into it as it warps people's perception of the underlying issues. It hinders people in their quest for individuation, creating this false narrative of them becoming more "authentic" when the total opposite is true, they believe they need validation from others in order to be happy etc. instead of being encouraged to find more inner strength and resilience with less reliance on how people see them. Demanding to be legally recognised as the opposite sex of what one is, is in no way shape or form more authentic than accepting the physical reality one is born into. To believe we as individuals can have 100% control over our identity in society, what we are seen as by others, in interaction with, and in relation to, society/the world/physical existence is a fool's errand, it is a delusional understanding of reality and existence.
    2
  4. Someone with XX chromosomes. If the chromosomes have a Y-- you're a guy
    2
  5. BECAUSE, they're men, not women. Women (ALL of them) are born female. Trans women is a term used to describe males who wish they were females-- Still males. A woman isn't a social construct, a feeling, s3xu@l preference, or a costume that a man can put on or take off.
    2
  6. ALL women are born female. It is a biological category that is fixed and permanent. A woman isn't a feeling, a s3xu@l preference, or a costume that a man can put on or take off. Quit conflating gender with personality traits and temperament (Neither of which is gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch females and tomboys) with gender. They're not synonymous.
    2
  7. There is only 1 kind of woman, and they're ALL born female. Now you know better. Cope and seethe if you must. Men cannot become women and women cannot become men.
    2
  8. I call them, gender pretenders
    2
  9. You can't change your gender. You can only reject traditional gender roles by engaging in various levels of cosplay and LARPing, or not. You could have a surgeon alter your appearance to look like a Klingon, and it wouldn't make you a Klingon either. A dude with top and bottom surgery and wearing a dress is still a dude, regardless of his desire to be a woman-- he's not and can't ever be, is the point they can't escape
    2
  10. Neither are true or correct
    2
  11.  @LightningStrikes2345  Your DNA literally organizes your physical body. DNA dictates the production of objective biological differences between males and females. 100% of the population is either male or female, even intersex people. If they have a Y chromosome, they are heterogametic and male. If not, they are homogametic and female. But you knew that because you've actually educated yourself on these conditions, right? Personality traits and temperament (Neither of which is gender exclusive -- hence effeminate males, butch females and tomboys), aren't synonymous with gender or gender roles. There is no internal feeling that is exclusive to men or women (or boys/girls), what makes anyone a man or a woman is being either male or female and reaching adulthood. Their sex and stage of physical maturity makes them men or women, not some "feeling" they have. Believing there is some "essence" specific to males or female as far as feelings go, that can manifest "in the wrong body", is akin to a religious belief, having faith in something that is impossible to prove or disprove. The thing is though, that no one on the "trans" side can actually even explain what this "essence" is, they can't even explain it to themselves yet have convinced themselves that the feeling they have means they "are in the wrong body" - without realizing that their discomfort simply stems from not realizing that they view conforming to sexist stereotypes as legitimate measures of manhood or womanhood. That is why every explanation given of WHY a male "can't be a man, but is instead woman" etc. relies upon listing stereotypical stuff, or, in some cases is completely abstract and refuses to actually provide any explanation of what they mean, simply stating they "know" that what they feel means what they say it does, even though they can't actually provide a definition of it. "It's hard to explain but I know I'm right" is an attitude one constantly comes up against - a religious faith in something they can't define. This idea that the terms "man" and "woman" carry all this baggage, sexist stereotypes, that people need to live up to or feel comfortable with is a complete fabrication coming from the "trans" side. You lot want a term to reflect aspects of your personality as well, you want to create more boxes to put people in, as you won't accept simply just being a man or a woman based on being born male or female (and reaching adulthood, obviously people are boys and girls before becoming men or women), but believe you need this "freedom of expression" to broadcast what sexist stereotypes you feel more comfortable with - thinking the world needs to adopt the sexist view you lot have (you fail to see just how much you have in common with Conservatives). Replacing objective definitions which are based in physical reality, with entirely subjective metaphysical claims, is not logical in any way, is not morally superior, and is demonstrably harmful, not least to female rights and protections, but also to practically anyone that buys into it as it warps people's perception of the underlying issues. It hinders people in their quest for individuation, creating this false narrative of them becoming more "authentic" when the total opposite is true, they believe they need validation from others in order to be happy etc. instead of being encouraged to find more inner strength and resilience with less reliance on how people see them. Demanding to be legally recognised as the opposite sex of what one is, is in no way shape or form more authentic than accepting the physical reality one is born into. To believe we as individuals can have 100% control over our identity in society, what we are seen as by others, in interaction with, and in relation to, society/the world/physical existence is a fool's errand, it is a delusional understanding of reality and existence.
    1
  12. That's totally naive
    1
  13. LOL!!! Trans women are men with issues, pretending to be women without issues.
    1
  14. The incoherent arguments made by these trans activist f00ls doesn't withstand the scrutiny of those who call out their idi0cy for what it is
    1
  15. There is only 1 kind of woman, and they're ALL born female-- making the use of 'Cis' entirely useless and irrelevant. A dude identifying as a woman doesn't make him a woman. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, a sexual preference, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female.
    1
  16. Cope Harder, and seethe if you must, but ALL women are born female.
    1
  17. No, that's wrong. LOL!!! Trans women are men with issues, pretending to be women without issues.
    1
  18. No. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female. For some reason, they seem unable to process that. Now you know better
    1
  19. Not when they're indoctrinating kids
    1
  20. Well, in mammals for sure
    1
  21. Sounds like BS. Let Reggie know that men are by far the victims of violent assault.
    1
  22. It seems obvious,But part of the job involves being able to decipher objective biology, does it not?
    1
  23. The incoherent arguments made by these trans activist f00ls doesn't withstand the scrutiny of those who call out their idi0cy for what it is
    1
  24. ALL women are born female. Now you know
    1
  25. I believe respect is earned, and is reserved for that which is actually respectable. Too many conflate respect with civility
    1
  26. Nope... Not even close. Trans women are MEN with issues, pretending to be women without issues.
    1
  27.  @bradenhendrickson3412  A gaping wound is not a vagina. Cope Harder
    1
  28. Trans is the new trendy goth 2.0
    1
  29. Need to bring back shame. Sex/Gender= 2 (Male, Female) Personality traits and temperament = Many (None are gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch females, tomboys) Gender Roles (Vary from culture to culture, and country to country) ALL based around the various social aspects of being male or female, respectively in those various cultures, societies and countries
    1
  30. There's no hate involved in recognizing that a man in a dress is still a man. That's just being observant. Get Real
    1
  31.  @Chudi2000  Yes, he did. Sex/Gender= 2 (Male, Female) There is only 1 kind of woman, and they're ALL born female. Personality traits and temperament = Many (None are gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch females, tomboys) Gender Roles (Vary from culture to culture, and country to country) ALL based around the various social aspects of being male or female, respectively in those various cultures, societies and countries.
    1
  32. No, it really is not. Cis is a term used by trans activists, to pretend that there's another kind of woman, other than those born female, and that there's another kind of man, other than those born male BUT-- there isn't. Transphobia is nothing but an attempt by trans activists, to use a toothless slur to smear those who challenge the incoherent claims of the trans-activist ideological narrative.
    1
  33.  @Chudi2000  A woman is an adult, human, female. Women (ALL of them) are born female. That status is fixed and permanent. Sex/Gender= 2 (Male, Female) Personality traits and temperament = Many (None are gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch/masculine females, tomboys, masculine males, Straight males and straight females, gay males, gay females, bi males and bi females) Gender Roles (Vary from culture to culture, and country to country) ALL based around the various social aspects of being male or female, respectively in those various cultures, societies and countries. Cope Harder! The vast majority of people in the world reject the incoherent trans-activist, cult narrative. Don't believe me-- consult Budweiser, Target, Disney and Mulvaney for verification
    1
  34. The T has successfully attached themselves to the LGB, so they now see it as one issue. That's it. That's the crux of the problem right there. Detach the "T". It does not gel with the rest. It does not belong with the rest and is actually in direct opposition to the rest of the group. LGB is based on sexuality and biology. "T" is mostly ideology and rhetoric that tries to erase biological truths (the minority who actually have gender dysphoria typically aren't part of the activist cult, they just want to pass as the gender they wish to outwardly present). Without those biological truths the LGB is rendered meaningless and non-existent. That's why lesbians are now under fire for not wanting to be with men identifying as women. Also, this has not been a "struggle" going back to the dawn of humanity. This is a new issue, and has been an issue for all of three minutes comparatively. it's also a very western and first world issue. The vast majority of the human race has no confusion about what a woman is or what a man is.
    1
  35. That there is barely a 2-digit IQ summary analysis. There's a prerequisite to being a woman, as it turns out-- they're ALL born female. Trans women are MEN with issues, pretending they're women without issues.-- Still Men
    1
  36. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, a sexual preference, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female, making the use of 'Cis' entirely irrelevant and useless.
    1
  37. Not all trans people suffer with dysphoria (OR, are trans-activists saying that they all do?), but they all do have a way higher risk of self deleting than the rest of the of the general population, so I see it as a more pressing underlying issue to address, than a mere matter of cosmetics. The argument in favor of affirmative care is, if you don't let them transition that they'll self-delete. Well, they seem to do that even if you do let them transition, so as far as I'm concerned it's an invalid argument. Not having coping mechanisms to deal with the adversity one faces in life is a psych issue, that surgery doesn't alleviate-- which begs the questioning of affirmation-based treatment protocols, along with the ethics of those who do
    1
  38.  @Chudi2000  Cope and seethe Harder... There is only 1 kind of woman, and they're ALL born female. Sex/Gender= 2 (Male, Female) Personality traits and temperament = Many (None are gender exclusive-- hence effeminate males, butch females, tomboys, Straight males, Gay males, Bi males and females, lesbian females, masculine females, feminine males, masculine males, feminine females) Gender Roles (Vary from culture to culture, and country to country) ALL based around the various social aspects of being male or female, respectively in those various cultures, societies and countries. Take your time to process reality
    1
  39. Should've kicked him in his mangina, and told him to wise up
    1
  40. You can't unscramble an egg
    1
  41. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female. For some reason, they seem unable to process that
    1
  42. Affirmative action strikes again
    1
  43. Trans women are men with issues, pretending to be women without issues. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, a sexual preference, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female, making the use of 'Cis' entirely irrelevant and useless.
    1
  44. One can be as articulate as humanly possible, but the explanation given to someone who's shoe size dwarf's their IQ, will fall on deaf ears
    1
  45. LOL!!! Trans women are men with issues, pretending to be women without issues. Regardless of the facts, an irrational thought process lacks the capacity to come to intelligent conclusions. They've gotten it totally wrong on gender. Gender, (there are 2 male, and female) that's it, refers to the sex assigned at birth and the social aspects of being male or female, respectively. Male and female are biological categories which are fixed and permanent. Then, they conflate gender and personality. Then, they conflate gender and gender roles. Then they conflate gender with sexual preference. Then, they conflate males with females, fact with fiction and men with women. A woman isn't a personality, a social construct, a feeling, a sexual preference, or a costume that a man can just put on or take off-- She's an adult, human, female. As it turns out, there's a prerequisite to being a woman-- and that's being born female, making the use of 'Cis' entirely irrelevant and useless.
    1