Comments by "DeoMachina" (@DeoMachina) on "Mhairi Black: SNP MP's maiden speech in full" video.

  1. Robert Campbell You have never gone without food for 5 days, and do not know the effects of going without food for five days. Your speculation on the effects of starvation on the human body has been dismissed. You also know nothing about life in Africa, so don't bother repeating that. The assumption that a person living in poverty must be an alchoholic who chooses beer over food is the fallacy here, there are many causes of poverty and they are not all related to substance abuse. This is common knowledge for anybody who has not led a sheltered life, so for you to be ignorant implies that you are indeed sheltered, naive and lacking in empathy as a result. And that's why you sound like a Tory.
    15
  2. Robert Campbell Your inability to comprehend basic economics is not an argument against the accuracy of this anecdote.  Just because you don't know where his dole money went (and you didn't stop to consider bills, debts etc) doesn't mean he "blew" it on anything. There are families of employed people who struggle to make ends meet in this country, yet you find the concept of a single unemployed man too far-fetched? Maybe if you went around the world asking questions instead of filling in the gaps in your knowledge with your own delusions, things would make more sense to you.
    11
  3. Robert Campbell Did you just seriously suggest using tealights as a replacement for heating and light?  In Glasgow?  Did you buy your degree or something?  I didn't know it was possible to be this ignorant. Your comprehension of human physiology has been refuted, your comprehension of life in poverty has been refuted, you've discredited yourself utterly.  And that's why you feel insulted, because you're slowly coming to terms with just how wrong you are regarding everything in life.
    11
  4. Robert Campbell What did you score in Geography by the way?  Because now you're apparently ignorant of the fact that countries of different latitudes have different climates. I'll spell it out for you: This man lives in a colder country. Blaming poor people for simply "choosing not to eat" is now beyond ignorance, it's pure contempt.  You've made it obvious now, you despise people poorer than yourself.  Well done, you're a sociopath.  See a doctor.
    10
  5. Robert Campbell I can't make this any more simple for you I'm afraid, I'm trying to explain that heating is a necessity in some parts of the world but you apparently know better. And yes, he did choose not to eat so that he had some money to go into the city for his appointment.  You walk three miles?  How olympian.  But you don't know how many miles he was expected to travel, so your speculation has again been dismissed.  You can assume that he was within walking distance, and that he was in a fit condition to walk that distance, but you would be making that up, since you have no evidence to support that claim. You're going above and beyond here, trying to work out as many ways as possible to make this man the bad guy in this scenario.  Why is that?  Why are you so invested in claiming something you cannot prove?  Is it to fit your preconcieved notions of what other people experience?  Is it because you cannot accept that our current government is purposely pushing citizens into starvation? If you don't believe this story, would you like me to give you some alternatives?  I can prove that the situation is getting worse, would that change your mind?
    10
  6. Robert Campbell The negative effects of welfare cuts are objective, and beyond question.  Not even the Conservaties are going to deny that cutting welfare has consequences. But the truth is, Black could have picked from a dozen stories that were much worse.  Do you really think anybody needs to invent a story to make the Tories look bad?  They're like something out of satire even when using their own words to describe themselves!
    10
  7. William Hancox We're trying to convince the North to become South Scotland, any help is welcomed :D
    9
  8. Robert Campbell What you said is no longer relevant, the story is not demonstratably false, or even suspicious.  Your attempts to show otherwise were nonsensical, and only showed us that you harbour a strange kind of bigotry against the less fortunate.
    7
  9. Robert Campbell"Facts" If they were facts, you would have something indicating they are facts.  You do not, so they are not.
    5
  10. Environmental Health Hazard There is no shame in speaking publicly using your natural accent, not everybody needs to learn Recieved Pronounciation to do their job. That you unfairly stereotype Glaswegians is a problem on your end, not hers.
    3
  11. Robert Campbell 6 weeks is less than a couple of months..did I really need to explain that too?
    3
  12. Yoda on DMT Conservatives scored a little over 30% of the vote, not a majority.  FPTP is a system that allows minorities to rule, so long as they have more than anybody else.
    2
  13. newgamer85 The SNP and UKIP have next to nothing in common, and disagree on just about everything. Especially immigration.
    2
  14. Robert Campbell See if you can go a couple of months using only that money, then we'll talk.
    2
  15. Brian Fullerton The same way Finland, Denmark, Sweden and Norway do I imagine. (Hint: The secret is to stop wasting money and to spend it on better things)
    2
  16. Angus MacLellan I don't know why you make this a leftist issue, when the party currently attacking higher education is the Conservatives. One of the first things they did last term was artificially inflate the cost of higher education in England. They wanted to do away with free higher education in Scotland too, the only reason they couldn't was because of the SNP and the Scottish Parliment. Why blame leftists anyway? When was the last time leftists were in charge of UK education? (I'm not sure Labour count as leftist in the 21st century)
    2
  17. Yoda on DMT I don't think anybody speaking at Westminster has ever said "We hate England", the SNP have been pretty pro-english recently too (they even have offices in London)
    1
  18. Yoda on DMT Not at all, a nationalist party for Scotland is obviously chiefly concerned with Scottish interests, but since England is our only neighbour it would be irrational to be anti-English.  To put it simply, SNP policy would improve both England and Scotland, to the benefit of both countries.
    1
  19. Yoda on DMT "Relevance" isn't something you should be concerned about, what matters is the wellbeing of the people who live here. A competent government that pooled resources effectively would be an optimal solution, however the current ruling class has shown that is is neither able to create those conditions, nor willing to step aside and let anybody else attempt it.  It's not worth discussing anymore. Ireland was part of the UK once, it didn't go particuarly well for the Irish people and they're still very aware of this. The unwillingness of one country to implement political reform does not obligate any other country to be as equally apathetic, regardless of political union.
    1
  20. Ayrshore I looked it up and it says "Renfewshire", so..
    1
  21. ***** If nationality is set in stone, English people and Scottish people wouldn't even exist, we'd still be Saxons/Romans/Celts etc.  To refer to somebody as English is an implicit acknowledgement that nations and nationalities are somewhat fluid.
    1
  22. ***** The "first born" were the Picts and Gaels you mentioned, 'Scots' did not exist until much later.  We have next to nothing in common with the native peoples of this island that we live on.
    1
  23. ***** The Gaels had their own nations, they certainly didn't have one big country they called "Scotland", that happened much later. Think about it, the name for this country is based on the Latin name for the Gaels.  If we really were Gaels, we'd be using their language.  And we'd be using their culture and faith too. Your hertitage doesn't make much difference to it, I mean both of us have African ancestors, but you don't claim to be Kenyan right?
    1
  24. ***** You are human right?  The human species (there is only one) originates from Africa.  If you are a human, you have African ancestry. Perhaps the true origins of the word "Scot" are unknown, because after looking it up I got something very different: http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=Scot
    1
  25. ***** I sort of expected a Christian to know this already, but Noah wasn't the first man.  Adam was.  The Bible doesn't give an exact location for where Eden was, so there is no religious reason to dispute historical fact.
    1
  26. ***** I don't see how this has any bearing on your African ancestry.  If you are a descendant of Noah's son, then you are a descendant of Noah, who was a descendant of Adam. That makes you a descendant of Adam too. These fables were never written to be taken as anything other than metaphor however, the current trend of interpreting the Bible literally is very recent, people have only been doing that for a century or so.
    1
  27. ***** Actually, it IS true.  Even way back in the 4th century, Augustine of Hippo wrote about taking parts of the Bible as allegory or metaphor.  The vast majority of Christians agree with this, and always have. There are no scriptures that contradict our African origins, there is no religious reason for you to dispute that.
    1
  28. ***** But I've already gone over the fact that Genesis is allegorical, so your personal interpretation isn't really changing anything.  The KJV that you use was written by people who understood the Bible as allegorical.  So whether you admit it or not, your faith IS based on metaphor.  There is no room for dispute in this. Refusing an idea just because a Jesuit believed it is spiteful and runs counter to the spirit of Christianity, there are plenty of Protestants who do not argue against historical facts.
    1
  29. ***** I haven't watched the video you mentioned, and I'm unlikely to watch it any time soon.  If you have specific claims that are true, you'll have another way of showing them to me. Lots of people have made prophecies, but the Bible does not predict the French Revolution.  Haven't you read it?  It's not there. The Roman Empire does not exist, and has not existed for over a thousand years.  I will not be arguing on this. You're doing an incredible job of deviating from the book you claim to follow, I think some time flicking through the pages or going to Sunday school might help you understand what Christianity is.
    1
  30. ***** Continue to spam me with unsourced claims that you do not comprehend, I'll continue to dismiss you.
    1
  31. ***** This is the very height of arrogance, to pretend that the Bible supports your crazy historical delusions.  I think you're done.
    1
  32. ***** That's a disgustingly arrogant position to assume, pretending that the creator of the entire universe chose you over everybody else to be the recipient of special knowledge.  Take your hate speech back to your obviously unchristian cult, please.
    1
  33. ***** Even if I was wholly ignorant of Christianity (I'm not), I could quickly look up everything you've said and find out.  Your bizarre misinterpretation wasn't practiced in history, it's not practiced by more than a few thousand people today, I think it's safe to say that if anybody got Christianity right, they're pretty far removed from yourself.
    1
  34. ***** So everybody except you and yours is wrong, now where have I heard that before? Oh, I remember now!  I heard it from every other two-bit attention-starved cult.
    1
  35. Environmental Health Hazard Eh, it's close enough.  It's not like outsiders could differentiate the accent. Besides, if you believe that accent dictates merit, then you're in no position to remark on any small errors I might make.  I made a minor factual error, while you are massively delusional.
    1
  36. Environmental Health Hazard Sure, and I suppose all the criticism on how she sounds was purely tangential.  I don't buy that, if you had a real criticism of her you would have posted it by now.
    1
  37. Environmental Health Hazard "She sounds like a street corner hairy" doesn't sound like real criticism to me.  So far all you can manage is "Awful representative" and "we deserve better" without giving any reasons why that might be true. Your faux-outrage at being called out for such insipid insights is particuarly telling, you're just another pseudo-intellectual who has no substance.
    1
  38. Environmental Health Hazard If you really find it's so boring to be contradicted, maybe this explains why you're so detached from reality.
    1
  39. newgamer85 So they disagreed on the issue of Scottish independence and EU membership.  I still can't see any similarity here. In regards to "making the majority suffer", are you suggestion that minorities should have to put up with whatever abuse they recieve, just because they are minorities?
    1
  40. newgamer85 The opinion of the SNP is that Scotland has been segregated and made to suffer and pay, so that other people can be rich and maintain their way of living.  The independence movement was to remedy that immoral situation.
    1
  41. newgamer85 It's not the bottom that did it?  They're the ones voting in these governments.  They're doing it even after seeing just how bad the parties are.  The poor over there are knowingly acting against everybody's interests, so why aren't they just as immoral?
    1
  42. newgamer85 So far the SNP have done a good enough job protecting things like education and wellbeing, where other parties wanted to take those things away.  I think that's a big difference.
    1
  43. 4.35 Tories are gettin BTFO right now
    1
  44. Brian Fullerton If you spend money on their education, they stop being uneducated.  It's not a difficult concept.
    1
  45. wonderboy021082 All politicians love spending other people's money, that's part of their job. The Chancellor does it every year. The major difference is that left-wingers typically spend it on people, and right-wingers save it for businesses.
    1
  46. vordman And with wealth creators we end up like the USA.
    1
  47. 20sbc07 You could just email her and ask I suppose :D
    1