General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
eDoc2020
Brodie Robertson
comments
Comments by "eDoc2020" (@eDoc2020) on "Wayland DOES Support Network Transparency!!" video.
@dutchangle229 Very few applications really use X, I believe all the common toolkits render locally and send the results as a bitmap to the server.
4
I thought running OpenGL applications using X over the network has been broken for decades.
1
@rallias1 I'll need to investigate this. Also keep in mind that a modern CPU can probably handle software rendering vanilla Minecraft. If you pull the F3 debug screen it wouldn't surprise me if you were actually rendering using llvmpipe.
1
@CoolerQ With modern applications it doesn't make sense to have the GPU running on a separate machine from the application, the final bitmap is much smaller than the intermediate data. The Wayland protocol only supports bitmaps so presumably waypipe must as well.
1
@guss77 When you connect to Windows using RDP app mode there is no need for Explorer to be running, so I wouldn't call it a full desktop. You can also run multiple applications over a single connection. I don't know if the underlying protocol requires a dummy framebuffer or not (it might be an implementation detail) and from a user standpoint it doesn't matter. VNC is definitely a dumb framebuffer and is no fun. For X applications Xpra works pretty well. I imagine it's possible to add support for Wayland applications. If nothing else, a "reverse xwayland" could be used as a shim.
1