Comments by "bruzote" (@bruzote) on "driving 4 answers"
channel.
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Well, I can sympathize with both you and the professor. Regarding the professor, physicists often love their field for its elegance. The ideal concept of human-defined "Laws of Physics" is that they should be able to explain the infinite number of situation-specific laws and rules-of-thumb that people use for deciding things like which kind of tires to use. In a default approach through that idealism, a physics instructor (not so much an experimenter or applied physicist) might assume then that the laws of friction should explain decisions about tire friction. Unfortunately, among the laws of physics, about the worst laws you could depend on as approaching the ideal would be the Laws of Friction. One law, as you may know, states that the area of a frictional surface does not matter when it comes to how much friction is generated by a load. In the physics students' world, this law is "proven" in lab experiments they personally conduct. the problem is those very experiments - and the text books - fail to mention that the experiments use materials that follow the ideal the laws. The experiments should use sticky tape and rubber. Even if they did, physicists would at first argue that you are not measuring friction, you are measuring adhesion. Well, at that point you're almost defining things to get the outcome you want. Adhesion or friction, the goal is to determine the resistance to sliding, and the laws of friction in physics as taught to non-specialists are poorly advertised as being highly dependent on materials. Physicists know this, but they get so used to working with special cases of ideals, they quickly grow comfortable and forget the assumptions.
There is also the other way to explain this. The physics instructor deals in the world where cows are spherical. He even MUST deal in the world. Have you tried to explain the infinite complexity of the real world to a typical student. More so, have you ever tried to write an equation for students that is even solvable without using idealized assumptions? The professors get locked into that world. It might even be worth it for the professor to be wrong just so twenty other students don't hear of your conversation and end up losing their understanding of the laws of physics that DO apply to many materials.
1
-
1
-
1