Comments by "Adam Redwine" (@adamredwine774) on "Intelligence Squared" channel.

  1.  @Michaelfrikkie  I never understood the apartheid state criticism. To make such a claim requires either that a person is ignorant of what apartheid was, ignorant of what is happening in Israel/Palestine, or they affirm that the West Bank and Gaza rightfully belong to Israel.
    3
  2. It is truly absurd to analogize Israel-Palestine with South Africa irrespective of the leftist narrative.
    2
  3. He clearly knows vastly more about the subject than the raving hordes of fools on college campuses throughout the West.
    2
  4. To say that there should not be a Palestinian state is not the same as to say that Palestinians do not deserve a state.
    2
  5. It's not supposed to be. That's not what an interview is.
    2
  6. Hahahahahaha... slow down on the koolaide before you choke.
    1
  7. I love how all of the people who down Palestinian propaganda with breakfast screech about Israeli propaganda. At least you lot are always good for a laugh.
    1
  8. He seems pretty well-informed to me.
    1
  9. There is a reason that presidents of both parties for decades all turned to Kissinger. You don't have to like the facts to understand the facts.
    1
  10. He didn't forget, he understands the actual facts, unlike you apparently.
    1
  11. No, that's the lefties on college campuses all over the West.
    1
  12. Except, there is no "massacre of Palestinian civilians by the IDF."
    1
  13. Your ignorance is profound though I wish it were more suprising.
    1
  14.  @seanomaille8157  Do you believe that the West Bank and Gaza are a part of Israel?
    1
  15.  @seanomaille8157  What do you believe are the boundaries of Israel? Do you believe that the West Bank and Gaza are properly Israel?
    1
  16.  @seanomaille8157  So rather than answer the question to move the conversation forward, you dodge it and throw more anger at Israel. It's a bummer, I had hoped we could actually have a real conversation.
    1
  17. I'd take that bet. Climate change is a very real threat, but 10-25 years from now isn't going to look a whole lot different than now.
    1
  18. I wish more people actually knew. Unfortunately, the lefties have swallowed whole the fecal propaganda that Palestinians pump out even faster than they pump out suicide bombers.
    1
  19. He has proven capable of providing well-informed analysis. You... are a random commenter on the internet.
    1
  20.  @harryteo7801  I do understand it in fact.
    1
  21. The crowds of useful idiots on college campuses are, yes.
    1
  22. What about them.
    1
  23. Free them from Hamas.
    1
  24. Your ignorance does not change reality. The civilian to fighter death rate in Gaza is substantially less than just about any other modern urban conflict.
    1
  25. This leftist narrative is absolutely delusional.
    1
  26. And what, exactly, do you think that America should do to force a change of a democratically elected leader in a close ally nation?
    1
  27.  @SeanPan-it3jm  your response makes no sense.
    1
  28.  @SeanPan-it3jm  that statement also makes no sense perhaps it would be better if you tried to use complete sentences.
    1
  29. He's better on Israel-Palestine than on other topics.
    1
  30. Quite the opposite. It is all of the peaceniks who push us closer to that fate.
    1
  31. Wow that is some absurd ignorance. Jerusalem was never "handed over" to Israel.
    1
  32. I'd love to see those two and Haviv Retig Gurr have a conversation about the future of the Middle East.
    1
  33. Even if you accept that it is a state, it is a failed state.
    1
  34. Perhaps your bias is blinding you.
    1
  35. You lot will cheer on the radical Islamists right up to the point that they put you against the wall. Not everyone is as naive as you.
    1
  36. He didn't say that. You should pay more attention.
    1
  37. He lives in the real world.
    1
  38. Israel did not occupy any of Gaza on October 6. Gazans had nearly two decades to build a prosperous state and they chose instead to prop up terrorists.
    1
  39. Illan Pape is a fool.
    1
  40. - Hamas is an elected representative of the Palestinian people. So democracy isn't refuted if Israel doesn't agree with the outcome? Hamas prevented any elections after they came to power in 2006 and they did not actually win the legal authority; they seized it in a civil war against Fatah. - Israel is in violation of many UN resolutions. The antisemitism of the UN is extremely well documented. They have zero credibility on questions regarding Israel. - There is no question that Israel itself is a terrorising and occupying state. Nonsense. This is an absurd claim. - The Palestinian cause will always be popular in the Gulf, Ferguson has been spending too much time with bureaucrats Your speculation is clearly not shared by all. - Israeli casualties since Oct 7 are significant, around 700 IDF dead marking an all time record. Most of the Israeli casualties from the current conflict occurred on the 7th. - Since 1973, Israel is still despised in the population of the Arab world. That's a strategic failure. Genocidal antisemitism has been baked into the education and religious structures throughout the Arab world. That does not mean that Arabs are congenitally a violent people. They need not always support genocide even if they do now. - Drone attack by Iran on Israel was a retaliation for an Israeli attack on an Iranian diplomatic outpost in Lebanon. Wow... you don't even get the false narrative correct. No, Israel struck a building across the street from the Iranian embassy in Syria. - Iran cheats on sanctions? Whose sanctions? Sanctions are as valid as Chinese sanctions on the US. Yes. All sanctions.
    1
  41. No, it's the lefties on college campuses who are apologists for gen0cide.
    1
  42. Good for him.
    1
  43. Douglas Murray also.
    1
  44. Go move to Iran.
    1
  45. The basis for the state of Israel is not a religious text, it is a UN resolution.
    1
  46.  @rayspencer5025  The UN did not give away land that other people owned and were living on. The UN approved a plan of the British empire to divide its territory into two new states.
    1
  47. The fools screaming about gen0cide are the ones most actively supporting one.
    1
  48. This is a completely ridiculous take. Israel elected Netanyahu, but he is not the only politician ever elected in Israel. Israelis have twice voted for political leaders who openly called for concessions to get peace.
    1
  49. Palestinians have lost every one of the many wars that they have launched in an effort at gen0cide. Their failed attempts at gen0cide should not be seen as "pronounced suffering" for which they bear no responsibility.
    1
  50. Your ignorance is showing. Slow down on that koolaide buddy.
    1