Comments by "Ggoddkkiller" (@ggoddkkiller1342) on "The Dumbest Battle In Middle Earth - An Analysis" video.

  1. Orc trebuchets can't destroy stone walls but they can destroy solid bedrock!! These writers don't even know what mountains are, just wow..
    2400
  2.  @derekp.683  It also convinces Faramir that trusting the ring is a big mistake so he decides against taking it. Boromir might died relatively quick but it affects the entire story.
    5
  3.  @jacqirius  I'm really amazed of some messages and even if you yell at people's face they still claim ridiculous and extremely ignorant things without doing any research. Mountains are BEDROCK which either pushed into surface by tectonic movements or everything around them eroded in millions of years. Yep, most mountains are millions of years old, there are even some billions of years old ones, almost as old as Earth itself. They could withstand erosion, earthquakes etc for so long simply because they are BEDROCK consisting extremely resilient rock formations. There are younger mountains which are sandstone etc formations and much weaker and unstable but i'm certain Elves aren't stupid enough to build a large city under such a mountain. In fact the mountain they used looks exactly same as Guiana highlands which is TWO BILLON years old and it could last that long simply because it is GRANITE BEDROCK formation. Such a granite mountain can withstand even nuclear strikes while there are people claiming few dozen kg boulders can collapse it. Or 'few loose rocks were just standing' i'm pretty sure if there were few loose rocks in formation they would collapse millions or even billions years ago with earthquakes which are millions of times stronger than trebuchets. Mountains are the oldest, strongest and most resilient thing you can see on Earth's surface and it is alarming how so many people have no idea..
    3
  4. I really hope they sold TV rights for this show alone not a general deal to amazon..
    3
  5.  @FilmscoreMetaler  I see no difference between male or female woke writers, they are equally stupid. And we see their work, absolutely nothing makes sense in the episode. For example mountains are solid bedrock, if something can't destroy man-made walls can't even scratch mountains..
    1