Comments by "Ggoddkkiller" (@ggoddkkiller1342) on "Fierce battles in Hama | SDF captures the 7 villages from Assad forces [3 December 2024]" video.

I wonder why nobody talks about populations, there are over 5 million Syrians in Turkish back rebel territories and further 4 million Syrian refugees in Turkey. While in government territories there are only 6 million Syrians left and in SDF territory there aren't even 2 million people. So Turkish side hosts literally 50% of Syria's population if not more and enough is enough. Clearly this offensive happens with Turkish permission and perhaps was even planned by Turkey. Nobody can displace entire population of a country and declare themselves as new rulers, they will either start accepting Syrians back into their homes or face the consequences..
23
There are 3 main sides, the government, Syrian people and the west. When civil war first began the west supported rebels unconditionally, even allowed thousands of Iraqis etc joining them. Spoiler alert those Iraqis etc foreigners later established isis along with other radicals in the rebels. Then the west began supporting YPG, Kurdish rebels who are always allying themselves to the government and almost never fought against them. The government was really weak but with Russian and Iranian support they gained upper hand began defeating now divided and infighting rebels. All Syrian groups fought against isis and they were eliminated but after years long fighting and the west abandoning them rebels were really weak. At this point Turkey joined in and stopped government attacks against them so more Syrians can't be displaced into Turkey. Most sources miserably fail to mention there are over 5 million displaced Syrians in rebel territories protected by Turkey who are against the government. Plus 4 million Syrian refugees inside Turkey so Turkey takes care of literally half of Syrian population. For years the government refused to make reforms and convince those people to return even if they promised Turkish side they would do them. YPG also refuses to allow Syrians to return so Turkey targeted them as well for both this and their connection to PKK. After hezbollah and iran weakened in recent events it was allowed rebels to launch a large scale offensive to capture as much land as possible. Turkish plan is now establishing a country for them almost certainly then they will send refugees to there..
19
@Cikeb You searched as 'Syrian refugees in Turkey', quoted first article shows up and became 'an expert' now?? If you read more articles you would see estimations change from source to source while they all are around 3.5-4 million Syrian refugees in Turkey. You are again clueless about how much Turkey has to spend for displaced Syrians in territories it controls. Because the government was often blocking UN led aid vast majority of their needs have to travel trough Turkey. UN efforts aren't nowhere enough anyway, many Syrians are still living in tents years after being displaced. Turkey had to build residential areas, hospitals, schools so they wouldn't decide to travel into Turkey and become refugees as well. (Some of them got targeted by russian strikes yesterday) But still they can't be count as taken care by Turkey! Care to explain why exactly only 2 million people are living in massive SDF territory and they aren't allowing Syrians to return into their homes especially to Raqqa? Even in government territory there are around 6 million Syrians living, why exactly the government isn't doing anything for those people to return their homes?? (Now even less ofc with Aleppo etc fallen) Some groups of people literally displacing entire Syrian population and declaring themselves as new rulers while you are clapping..
4
@mappsmappings4025 By a quick research you can confirm they are accurate, but it is too much trouble for you to do that, right? Then why bother writing a comment anyway?..
4
@Red-Check-Mark Ikr, there are so many ignorant people acting like some kind of foreign force is defeating them! While in reality they deserted simply because everybody is against them not just rebels so they had no chance of defending the city without significantly larger forces..
3
Fake news, there is no fighting between YPG and assadists.
2
It seems like you misunderstood what that means, erdogan simply asks assad to make serious compromises lol..
2
@mappsmappings4025 Are you adding up pedia population numbers which don't account for the war properly? For example it shows Aleppo still having 2 million population same as pre-war but in reality the city got severe damage during the war and most estimates are around a million today. I have absolutely no idea where you could find 'before surprise attack 15 million' nonsense. In entire Aleppo governorate there were around 4 million living according to reliable estimates like UN. This includes rebel held territories like Afrin, Al-bab and they were estimated as 1.5-2 million people. So in entire government section of Aleppo governorate including Aleppo city itself there were around 2 million people living. Use reliable sources like UN etc not some randoms you find..
2
@foakjljrwajkltawtrawtwa441 You are so clueless what you are talking about lmao! They left thousands of arms behind including T-90s, Pantsirs, S-300 and even a fighter plane. That's deserting without any doubt, in fact rebels didn't only capture Aleppo rather over 200 residential areas including towns and villages. And currently they are encirling Hama which is another large city..
1
@foakjljrwajkltawtrawtwa441 Uhm, you kept saying relatively close but are you aware it took years of fighting to push rebels out of those places that they recaptured within days??
1
@erios5057 If i summarize Kurdish side, after rebels split in 2014 as isis (mostly foreigners), FSA (moderate Syrian rebels), al nusra (radical mostly Syrian rebels) they all began fighting each others. The government used this opportunity to recover and slowly gained power. Ofc isis came out victorious in this infighting and began spreading its territories. In 2015 they began attacking northern Syria where both Kurds and Turkmens living while the west ditched rebels and began supporting Kurds at this point. Back then there was peace talks ongoing with PKK and Turkey so Turkey gave them green light and even allowed thousands of Peshmerga forces and PKK members traveling into Syria through Turkey. After isis was repelled Peshmerga forces returned to Iraq but PKK never left, even today there are 2-4 thousand PKK members in YPG ranks. Unfortunately peace talks collapsed in late 2015 and PKK and Turkey began fighting again. While instead of forcing PKK to leave Syria the west began acting like they didn't exist after a simple merge and name change to SDF. Ofc Turkey didn't accept this and began heavily arming Turkmen groups, kinda forming its own milita force inside Syria. Russia didn't like this and began bombing this force and this is why Turkey shot down a Russian fighter in late 2015 that they could not target Turkmen groups. In 2016 Turkey launched its own offensive against isis and pushed them away from Turkish border with Turkmen groups. From this point Turkey adopted FSA and began training and arming them, they were in a bad shape almost eliminated entirely, later on formed SNA from them. On the other hand the government was heavily fighting against isis too especially around Palmyra which changed hands many times and perhaps had the highest casualties in the war. So when SDF launched its great offensive against isis in east Syria, they were engaged from north to south and fighting against everybody. It is just a western propaganda US with SDF defeated isis, they helped for sure but even if they remained in the north and did nothing isis was still going to be defeated. Turkey continued trying to force YPG to expel PKK members but it didn't work, even the commander of SDF, Mazloum Abdi is a 'former' PKK member. So it launched an operation against YPG in 2018, shortly after US announcing they would form an army from SDF, ofc after Turkish operation US ditched those plans. Later on Turkey demanded SDF to allow Syrians to return Raqqa which was refused for 'security risks' and Turkey launched its second offensive against YPG in 2020. Even if the west protested a lot they couldn't do anything to stop Turkey so YPG began allying themselves to Russia and the government instead. There are Russian bases all over their territory including even some areas there are US bases. This led to Trump annoucing they would leave Syria but later on he ditched this plan when YPG threatened to release isis members They are shown like 'democratic' but in reality they are allying themselves to everybody nor they ever held an election in their entire history. You can also find UN resolutions accusing them for recruiting children, they promised to stop but as far as i know it still continues today. To be honest they are just a proxy against iran for US that US acts like supporting democratic people for legitimacy and political support..
1
@erios5057 If i summarize Kurdish side, in 2015 isis began attacking northern Syria where both Kurds and Turkmens living while the west ditched rebels and began supporting Kurds at this point. Back then there was peace talks ongoing with PKK so Turkey gave them green light and even allowed thousands of Peshmerga forces and PKK members traveling into Syria through Turkey. After isis was repelled Peshmerga forces returned to Iraq but PKK never left, even today there are 2-4 thousand PKK members in YPG ranks. Unfortunately peace talks collapsed in late 2015 and PKK and Turkey began fighting again. While instead of forcing PKK to leave Syria the west began acting like they didn't exist after a simple merge and name change. Ofc Turkey didn't accept this and began heavily arming Turkmen groups, forming its own proxy inside Syria. Russia didn't like this and began bombing this force and this is why Turkey shot down a Russian fighter in late 2015 that they could not target Turkmen groups. In 2016 Turkey launched its own offensive against isis and pushed them away from Turkish border with Turkmen groups. From this point Turkey adopted FSA and began training and arming them, later on formed SNA from them. On the other hand the government was heavily fighting against isis too especially around Palmyra which changed hands many times. So when SDF launched its great offensive against isis in east Syria, they were engaged from north to south and fighting against everybody. It is just false US with SDF defeated isis, they helped for sure but even if they remained in the north and did nothing isis was still going to be defeated. Turkey continued trying to force YPG to expel PKK members but it didn't work, perhaps because even the commander of SDF, Mazloum Abdi is a 'former' PKK member. So it launched an operation against YPG in 2018, shortly after US announcing they would form an army from SDF and those plans were ditched. Later on Turkey demanded SDF to allow Syrians to return into Raqqa which was refused for 'security risks' and Turkey launched its second offensive against YPG in 2020. Even if the west protested a lot they couldn't do anything to stop the operation so YPG began allying themselves to Russia and the government instead. There are Russian bases all over their territory including even some areas there are US bases. This led to Trump annoucing they would leave Syria but later on he ditched this plan when YPG threatened to release prisoners. They are shown like 'democratic' but in reality they are allying themselves to everybody nor they ever held an election in their entire history. You can also find UN accusing them for recruiting children, they promised to stop but as far as i know it still continues today. To be honest they are just a proxy against iran that US acts like supporting democratic people for legitimacy and political support..
1
@erios5057 If i summarize Kurdish side, in 2015 isis began attacking northern Syria where both Kurds and Turkmens living while the west ditched rebels and began supporting Kurds at this point. Back then there was peace talks ongoing with PKK so Turkey gave them green light and even allowed thousands of Peshmerga forces and PKK members traveling into Syria through Turkey. After isis was repelled Peshmerga forces returned to Iraq but PKK never left, even today there are 2-4 thousand PKK members in YPG ranks. Unfortunately peace talks collapsed in late 2015 and PKK and Turkey began fighting again. While instead of forcing PKK to leave Syria the west began acting like they didn't exist after a simple merge and name change. Ofc Turkey didn't accept this and began heavily arming Turkmen groups, forming its own proxy inside Syria. Russia didn't like this and began bombing this force and this is why Turkey shot down a Russian fighter in late 2015 that they could not target Turkmen groups. In 2016 Turkey launched its own offensive against isis and pushed them away from Turkish border with Turkmen groups. From this point Turkey adopted FSA and began training and arming them, later on formed SNA from them. On the other hand the government was heavily fighting against isis too especially around Palmyra which changed hands many times. So when SDF launched its great offensive against isis in east Syria, they were engaged from north to south and fighting against everybody. It is just false US with SDF defeated them, they helped for sure but even if they remained in the north and not much was going to change. Turkey continued trying to force YPG to expel PKK members but it didn't work, perhaps because even the commander of SDF, Mazloum Abdi is a 'former' PKK member. So it launched an operation against YPG in 2018, shortly after US announcing they would form an army from SDF and those plans were ditched. Later on Turkey demanded SDF to allow Syrians to return into Raqqa which was refused for 'security risks' and Turkey launched its second offensive against YPG in 2020. Even if the west protested a lot they couldn't do anything to stop the operation so YPG began allying themselves to Russia and the government instead. There are Russian bases all over their territory including even some areas there are US bases. This led to Trump annoucing they would leave Syria but later on he ditched this plan when YPG threatened to release prisoners. They are shown like 'democratic' but in reality they are allying themselves to everybody nor they ever held an election in their entire history. How a group of people can become democratic without holding any elections i really don't know..
1
@Cikeb You are acting a fool or something? You are literally quoting first article you see and acting like an expert who can decide 'who is taking cared'! And the worst part you can't even read a single article properly otherwise you would had seen UNHCR article says 'this is REGISTERED number of Syrian refugees in Turkey' so it isn't estimation including unregistered refugees. You are such a joke to be honest..
1
@Cikeb You are literally quoting first source you see and acting like an expert who can decide 'who is taking cared'! While in reality you can't even read a single source properly otherwise you would had seen UNHCR says 'this is REGISTERED number of Syrian refugees in Turkey' so it isn't an estimation including unregistered refugees. You are such a joke to be honest..
1
@Cikeb You can find many estimation from different organizations by a quick search, they all are between 3.5 and 4 million so i don't need to show you a source at all. But ofc because you read literally first article showing up you are clueless about that too, right?..
1