Comments by "ADAPTATOR" (@FUTURAPTER) on "Sabbatical" channel.

I came from Ukraine, I look 100% Irish, so I am Irish? So appearance determines who is who or what?
2
@ak-77 haha
2
Any genes change over time and pass into others. Why don't you consider an African to be Irish if the Irish also appeared from Africans? The first people appeared in Africa, at what stage did those Africans turn into Irish? In general, you can't stop natural processes in nature.
1
@InteN66 so tell me how it works
1
@InteN66 I understand all this. But I don't understand why people are surprised that an African answers the question "Where are you from?", "I'm from here" "I'm Irish", in this context he answered the question where he was born. He was not asked his nationality or ethnic group, then the answer would have been different.
1
@InteN66 This is firstly, and secondly, in Ireland there has been migration throughout its history, there has been no isolation. There is always a continuous process of optimizing genes to bring out better and more viable ones, mixing with the Americans does not harm anyone, it is a natural process of transition to stronger and more stable genes. It is the same as with languages, there is no point in preserving something that has outlived its usefulness.
1
@InteN66 But if the mixture of different ethnic groups gives birth to a new one, then what's wrong with Gaeilgi mixing with Africans and other ethnic groups? Then something new and interesting will come out. What's wrong with that?
1
@InteN66 Yeah, everyone can have their own opinion, but usually it doesn't affect what happens. I mean, if the Irish genes degenerated, then no matter what you do, other stronger genes will take their place, even if you don't like them. So trying to preserve identity is a waste of time, that's my opinion.
1
@InteN66 And as for immigrants, why does the government do this? Well, I have an answer to this question. Young Irish people without education have nothing to keep in Ireland, and they leave en masse to work without education in other countries. Only educated Irish people remain who hold on to their good jobs in Ireland. This creates a shortage of workers for vacancies without education, so as not to raise the salaries of cleaners to the level of programmers, it is much more profitable for the government to take migrants without education and they will be happy to work at any job for the minimum wage. And this is so profitable for the government that the benefit more than covers the costs of integrating these migrants (hotels, food, English courses, etc.). This is my opinion. And what do you think about this, why is all this being done?
1
@rih2370 If it is not a passport or appearance that determines who is who, then what is? Is there a specific definition? For example, why are you Irish?
1
@rih2370 So, ancestors determine? But then there is a paradox: Where did the first Irishman come from and who were his ancestors? If his ancestors were not Irish, then by your logic he is not Irish, and therefore all his descendants are not Irish either. So the Irish do not exist?
1
@rih2370 I gave you an example. A Viking or a Spaniard came to Ireland 20 thousand years ago, there was no one there yet, he gave birth to children there and called them Irish? But his genes are Spanish or from the Vikings, how did they become Irish, can you tell me?
1
@rih2370 That is, if the descendants of Mohammed from Somalia in a couple of generations will already be white and their children will have Irish surnames, will they already be Irish? How many generations exactly must pass for a person from Mohammed to become Irish? This is the first question. And the second question. What will happen if the children of Mohammed are 99% of population of Ireland? Will they be Irish or still not? In this case, it turns out that the inhabitants of Australia are not Australians? Who are they?
1
@ak-77 Yes, people have different blood, the question is where is the standard of Irish blood? And who told you that Africans do not have Irish blood? Who measured it?
1
Lol Russian and Ukrainian girls everywhere in the world 😂
1
You are not Irish either, the first people appeared in Africa, so see who you are!
1
 @ak-77 Why is it bad? If the first people who appeared in Africa had not decided to become migrants, you would not exist! So realize that you are a descendant of African migrants!
1
Why do you consider yourself Irish? Because of the blood? And who told you that your blood is more Irish than that African's? @Dignity4allhumanity
1
No, people appeared in Africa, which means the whole world belongs to Africans, and you are also an African, a white African, but you are no different from a black African.
1
@Clive-321 I agree with you, I also want to add that you can also be Irish by appearance and Irish by language, but most people in Ireland are no longer Irish by language))
1
@ak-77 You can also say that a person cannot be Irish by genes, he is not Irish - he is a person who has Irish genes, but this does not make him Irish! Lol
1
@Clive-321 You have sound, logical and objective thoughts. Most people just pull the blanket in their direction trying to justify it somehow, but it always collapses with logic.
1
@ak-77 You don't understand that he tells you not how he would like, but how it will be, while you in turn tell your desires and think that they will be fulfilled in reality. Life doesn't work that way. The fact that you don't want something to change doesn't mean that it won't change. The maximum you can influence in this world is your personal life. And your influence on evolution and global processes on the planet is 0.00001%, so try to think about what will happen in the future, and not what you would like.
1
@ak-77 If you don't want to answer and read my comments, it proves that my comments have entered into maximum dissonance with your brain, it maximally resists new information and beliefs that you have already well-deposited, but at the same time, because of my logical arguments, you feel a subconscious fear of starting to doubt the correctness of your own beliefs, in order to deprive yourself of this fear and at the same time remain with your beliefs, the simplest solution is to emotionally distance yourself and find an easier interlocutor)
1
@ak-77 You can't give me a single example or analogy that would show that my logic is wrong. I can write them to you endlessly.
1
@ak-77 You look more Ukrainian than me, lol
1
@zer0byte101 You are wrong, there are no more than 3 million Irish genes in Ireland, and soon there will be even less. This does not mean that half the country is not Irish. Almost everyone in Australia does not have the genes of the Australian Aborigines, now go tell people that they are not Australians. You confuse genes with human rights, your genes are no better than the genes of other people, no matter who they belong to. But you are trying to prove the opposite by negating the laws and rights of your country. He is Irish by law, and there is no law stating that an Irishman is a person with special genes. So think whatever you want. But people will call themselves Irish regardless of their origin and genes.
1
@zer0byte101 The law doesn't say anything like that, which means your words are empty words.
1
You too not Irish
1
@ak-77 Just as they know that an African is not Irish, so I know that they are not Irish. It's that simple.
1
So the ancestors of all people were Africans, didn't you know that?By your logic, then all people are Africans.
1
Humans appeared in Africa, so we are all Africans. Moreover, we used to be monkeys. Does that mean we are still monkeys?
1
@Clan501-Scotland By your logic there are no Australians in Australia?
1
@Clan501-Scotland Yes, I think there should be no borders. Borders are against freedom. And I am for freedom. And regarding races, this should only concern the discussion of people's appearance and genes, and should not in any way affect borders, rights and people and show who is who!
1
@Clan501-Scotland Fighting for borders is stupid, because the land does not belong to people but to millionaires. And secondly, no matter how much you fight for borders, sooner or later they will be lost or changed, look at history, borders have always changed in any country. It is a waste of your life for borders.
1
@Clan501-Scotland Who told you that there are no women and children? I see women and children on the street as well. It's just that often only men come first to earn money for the whole family to move. Women and children come later.
1
@Clan501-Scotland Nobody will fight in Britain now, if a war starts here I am sure more than half of the people will leave for other countries, now is not the time to fight, now is a civilized world and it is much easier to leave for another country. There is no need to fight anymore, it is stupid.
1
Your distant ancestors are the same as his, why do you consider yourself Irish?
1
@ak-77 why not?
1
@cmd7930 My point of view is that genes cannot determine who is who in relation to a country. Because this is Nazism and people are trying to promote it only for their selfish ambitions. This is equivalent to what Hitler did. That is, I believe that a person can say that he is Irish if he either received an Irish passport or was born in Ireland, or both together, but his genes are not the main thing. Because this is absurd and a Nazi slogan to promote hatred and take away rights from other nations. This is the same as calling the author of a channel not an American but an Irishman and in the future deporting him from the United States to Ireland and saying that this is right and fair because his ancestors were Irish. People do not like migrants but at the same time they do not like that migrants can become them and do become them, so they came up with the manipulation "An Irishman is only someone who has Irish genes", in the future if this stupidity is not stopped it will develop into "rights only for those who have Irish genes". That's why that African said everything right! He's Irish! His nationality is Somali! That's it! Anyone who doesn't agree with that is a Nazi!
1
@cmd7930 I am against the idea that genes decide who is who, because those who claim this are trying to prove that people should not have equal rights if they have different genes.
1