Comments by "justgivemethetruth" (@justgivemethetruth) on "Ukrainian MP: Why victory is the only option" video.

I gotta admit, I really enjoy listening to Freddie's interviews. He has really good interviews, and very good interviewees, and it seems like the more skeptical or resistant he is to the answers he gets, the more polite and soft his tone gets ... very excellent!
60
A brilliant condensed and efficient version of the Ukraine war is done on the latest RFK Jr. Podcast with ( weirdly ) former Reagan era Budget Direct, David Stockman. The clarity that Stockman brings to understanding the Ukraine situation is undeniable and really needed. Stockman points out that Ukraine is many times more divided than the US Red-Blue divide, to the point of an 8 year shooting war, and how in all other cases with the exception of Ukraine the answer to ethnic divisions in the US/UN/NATO has been to partition countries and place UN peacekeepers inside, but in Ukraine the US has leveraged the anti-Russian nature of these divisions to foment a war that is killing Ukrainians on both sides and destroying their country - and costing us Americans boatloads of cash at a time when we are supposedly worried about overspending. I'm happy to listen to this lady, but I expect more anti-Russian BS. Let's see.
35
Yeah, I found most of what this woman said to be weasel words that were almost all dishonest in multiple ways. Like she said she had to work really hard to find ways for people in Donbas to go to University ... when another of her peers was talking about how Ukrainian children would be out and about in the sunlight going to school while Russian children would be cowering bunkers being shelled. The complicitness of the US government in his makes me feel terrible to be an American. Even if all Americans were somehow to benefit from weakening Russia through unilateral war, this is not right, it is not global leadership, and it is destroying America's economy, making life very difficult and unequal for Americans, and destroying the world's environment. It needs to stop and everyone needs to chart a new course without war.
12
35:40 - I'd have to disagree that she is fighting for the survival of her country day by day. She is fighting to expand undemocratic rule which all Ukrainians voted against, or thought they were voting against when they voted for Zelensky for President ... and got a big destructive surprise that I bet if you asked all Ukrainians 90+% of them would not want to have gone to war and would have agreed to Minsk, or dividing the country or anything except what their nationalist military forced on them. Really great job though Freddie did in getting this phrased in as dressed up was as possible.
12
32:08 - She doesn't understand what Freddie means by the ultra-nationalist groups? Is that possible?
9
First thing I notice is this lady's young age, and probable inexperience, which points to a political appointment or someone that higher powers are manipulating - much like Zelensky. Dishonesty #1 - Maybe this lady wants to try to imagine what life was like for ethnic Russians in the Donbas getting shelled for 8 years solid by Ukrainian nationalist forces which to get elected that Zelensky pledged he would end. She is completely dodging the question about censorship. Like anyone who spoke for peace or against Zelensky would be shut down in the least or disappeared. What nonsense. The solid answer to national divisions of this kind - basically war - has been from the US/UN/NATO - to divide countries. Yet for some reason Ukraine on Russia's border does not invoke that solution. I think this lady is an opportunist, or perhaps cannot get out of the country and is being threatened or cannot find any other way to survive this situation. This lady seems to be hear to put a pretty Ivanka Trump looking voice to the conflict. As I see it, the answer is to partition Ukraine as the UN would have partitioned any other violented divided country in the world down the line where the demographics change between East//Russian and West/Ukrainian ... there really is no other way - because if Ukraine "wins" for example, there are still all those people in Eastern Ukraine that presumably the Ukrainian military will feel they have to run out of the country or kill. If Russia wins it is slightly easier - Ukraine will turn into a small landlocked rump state - but the war and violence will end.
8
@lauriealach1072 It doesn't matter if he is biased - everyone is, every interviewer, every interviewee. I appreciate his civility, and you even agreed with me. You're just mad because you disagree with him politically.
7
Then Zelensky is the current worst leader in the world. ;-)
7
This lady is a pretty face on a very ugly groups of bad dudes ... and equally bad are the neocons in America who have been working with them. The internationally recognized borders of Ukraine contained about half and half Russians ... and the minority Nationalist militant have been genociding them and ethnically cleansing them for years now, and have American dupes to put a pretty face on it, as well as a BS narrative that Russia attacked unprovokedly. The story is getting out and all this death and destruction will have been for nothing - except for the people who have gotten rich on it. One global solution to this BS would to be to confiscate of claw back all profit and monies made on war - everywhere. Human society, the planet and the climate cannot take this anymore and it needs to stop. Down with the Ukrainian nationalists - partition the damn country if you want Russia to give back territory, but they will never give back Crimea because it is about 100% Russian, important for Russian martime activity and security.
2
BUT, the real question about Crimea is -- WHY? Why would Ukraine ( the so-called democracy ) want to hold on to a place by force that voted to leave Ukraine, whose people Ukraine hates, and who Ukraine would have to find some way to deal with after they supposedly recpatured Ukraine? This makes Ukraine the side that is expansionist and empire building doesn't it? Please ask her ( I guess it's too late now ) but what would her government do with all the Russians who live in Eastern Ukraine and who vote the exact opposite on almost every issue? Why do you want to make 1/2 the country miserable under a repressive military violent terrorist regime? Why lady?
2
I think Russia sound like it will nuke Ukraine before it gives up Crimea, but this girl has to say what she has to say. Is she willing to die and have her family and city incinerated for a possible future where Ukraine keeps Crimea .... BUT, the real question about Crimea is -- WHY? Why would Ukraine ( the democracy ) want to hold on to a place that voted to leave Ukraine, whose people Ukraine hates, and who Ukraine would have to find some way to deal with after they supposedly recpatured Ukraine? Please ask her ( I guess it's too late now ) but what would her government do with all the Russians who live in Eastern Ukraine and who vote the exact opposite on almost every issue? Why do you want to make 1/2 the country miserable under a repressive military violent terrorist regime? Why lady?
1
@dixonpinfold2582 Yeah, well people agree with me, so go pound sand you whiner.
1
Isn't the bottom line of this really that the Ukrainian Ukrainians live under no threat of military action from the Eastern Russian Ukrainians and that the Russian Ukrainians in the East of Ukraine have had to undergo all kinds of hate and violence and legislation against them, their language and their culture. So the plain truth is that this is a war of genocide and expansion by the Western Ukrainian Ukranians against the Russian Ukrainians in the East who just wanted to live in peace without being under a government that when controlled by the Nationalists and the US CIA hates them and takes military action against them?? Rebut that please someone?
1
@dixonpinfold2582 > I'd like to see your face, standing in front of your house, if gangsters were barricaded inside holding your family, and the police told you to get on the phone and negotiate. You're so simple, that is exactly what Western Ukraine did to Eastern Ukrainian ethnic Russians since 2014. Open your eyes and you mind. In the cases of other countries that are so divided they break them up - partition them, but in the case of Ukraine, since it was on Russia's border, the CIA saw a tool to get at Russia.
1
It's not Russia that has been launching military attacks ... until forced to by geometrically increasing shelling from the Urkainian side of the Donbas border. She is just lying. It was her nationalist side that went to war and discriminated legally against the Russian citizens of Ukraine .... for 8 years. A lie with a soft voice and pretty face on it is still a lie.
1
The real reason this conflict is frozen is that the US is still fighting the Cold War against Russia - without the knowing support of Americans - with a huge budget deficit that we cannot afford, for reasons that don't make sense, and because they see they can create a wedged situation based on lies and propaganda. The real permanent solution is for Americans to be told the truth, and for the US to realize it loses nothing if NATO doesn't expand to completely surround Russia, that the world cannot stand any more war, and that Ukraine should be divided like any other country undergoing such internal strife and division. It is easy except for the military industrial complex in the US and those industries that make money off the death and destruction of people all over the world - and that these policies are not stable for the US, or anyone else.
1
@pfacka Russia is not at war with itself. You travelled the country and faied to see a war going on, and I bet totally missed the most corrupt country in Europe that it is called. You make your fake "guess" because you have no real argument and need to make your speculation sound authoritative because you travelled to Ukraine as a tourist once. Whoopee.
1