Comments by "Screen Apple" (@screenapple1660) on "Close call for Chinese, US warships l WNT" video.

  1. Why USA have to protect Taiwan? It's this famous part On September 21, 1950, Secretary of State Dean Acheson addressed a letter to the Secretary General of the United Nations explaining the US government's policy toward Taiwan and certain offshore islands, like the Penghus. He began by citing the December 1, 1943, Cairo declaration stating Formosa would be returned to “Republic of China.” Thereafter, the July 1945 Potsdam declaration confirmed Cairo's terms and in General Order No. 1 the Japanese forces in Formosa were ordered to surrender to “Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek.” From 1945 onward, the Republic of China retained administrative control over Formosa, the Penghus, plus a number of other offshore islands. On April 28, 1952, Japan signed a peace treaty renouncing its claim to Formosa and the Penghus, although “in whose favor Japan was renouncing was not stipulated.” Thereafter, Japan and the ROC signed their own peace treaty, effective August 5, 1952, where Japan repeated this renunciation, but again without saying which state it was ceding its rights to. While title over Formosa and the Penghus might be vague, the ROC had occupied these areas continuously since 1945: “There is no question that the Republic of China is today and at all times since the effective date of the Japanese Peace Treaty, has been in effective possession of and exercising administrative control over Formosa and the Pescadores.”
    3
  2. It's not possible for China to get back taiwan. They did not attend U.S meeting and officials long long time ago. Remember there was Korean War. North and South Korea. South Korea, Japan really need Taiwan. Without Taiwan. South Korea would not feel safe .
    1
  3. This dude doesn't feel intimidated by Chinese forces. Why? He read American war manual. Maybe, he was very experienced drill sgt long time ago.
    1
  4. Why U.S navy goes to Taiwan..... Because U.S president long time ago support Taiwan's independence. In 1950, after the outbreak of the Korean War, United States President Harry S. Truman said that it would be a direct threat to the United States' security in the western Pacific area if the Communist forces occupied Taiwan and that "the determination of the future status of Formosa must await the restoration of security in the Pacific, a peace settlement with Japan, or consideration by the United Nations."[1] This statement of Truman is generally regarded as the origin of the Theory of the Undetermined Status of Taiwan.
    1