General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Stephen Hill
Pyotr Kurzin | Geopolitics
comments
Comments by "Stephen Hill" (@stephenhill545) on "Why Putin is So Obsessed With Ukraine | @VladVexler" video.
@VadimBolshakov or Tim Snyder's excellently reearched book, Bloodlands, which will blow your mind if you dare to read it.
2
@SKWVDSCB quite incorrect. It only hit Ukraine and the area to the south east of it, which also contained many Ukranian speakers. Belorus had a potato surplus thst year. Stalin refused to send it to the famine areas, prefering to sell it abroad. He also refused aid offers from the USA.
2
@SKWVDSCB a conspiracy theorist btw.
2
@VadimBolshakov It's not so. There wasn't a food shortage at all. The Belorussian SSR offered to send their surplus potatoes to Ukraine, but Stalin refused this. He also refused to adjust the grain quota when he knew the 32-33 grain harvest was lower. His solution was to arrest the people who pointed this out, block the Ukranian borders to stop people escaping the famine, Jan 33 order, and to blame Polish spies. All the while he was exporting grain from Odessa. American charities also offered to ship grain in, but Stalin refused the aid. The famine was so devastating, that the number of Ukranian speakers fell from 90 to 70 percent. The areas outside Ukraine where famine confitions existed were Rostov, Krasnodar, and Stavropol, where Ukranian was also widely spoken at that time. There was no famine in Moscow etc.
1
@VadimBolshakov it wasn't. Belorus had a potato surplus thst year. The famine hit Ukraine and the collective farms of Rostov, Stavropol etc.
1