Comments by "whyamimrpink78" (@whyamimrpink78) on "Senate Dems Propose Medicare Buy In At 55" video.
-
" How about you subsidize education so people can actually become
doctors, nurses, and reserachers without having to pay $200,000 for an
education? "
People who enter those professions do so knowing it will cost a lot but they will earn a lot in the end. Money is not an issue. People do not go into those fields because the standards are high and so is the work. Almost every med school has a less then 50% acceptance rate.
"The US needs free healthcare, subsidized trade schools and post secondary education, and invest in infrastructure"
Nothing is free.
"Take the money from the bloated military, the rich, close tax loopholes,
and stop giving corporate welfare to the most profitable industries in
the US."
Defense spending is 4% of our GDP. Healthcare is 1/6 of our GDP. The rich simply do not have enough money. I agree, close loopholes and simplify our tax code. And I agree, stop corporate welfare.
"The middle class would swell,"
How?
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
kokofan50, during the debate with Ted Cruz Bernie berated that hair salon owner. She asked him how she is supposed pay for her employers healthcare under Obamacare if she expanded her business. Bernie simply said "I don't know how business works, but you have to pay". That is not connecting to her. That is not trying to understand her situation and finding a common ground. That is berating her. That is no different then someone on the ultra right going up to someone who is poor and saying "pull yourself up by your boot straps".
Compare that to Bill Clinton, one of our best presidents ever. Herman Cain posed him the same question. Clinton ran through numbers showing he understands, to some degree how business works. And gave Cain a suggestion. Cain countered back with his numbers. In the end, though, Clinton was showing he understood Cain's issue and was willing to work with him. Clinton was able to understand other people's issues. Bernie doesn't. He does not understand what it is like to struggle as a business owner. He does not understand how there are many people who worked hard and struggle to become successful and do not want to see their hard work being taken away. Bernie just on his typical rant of "There are poor people, thus we need to give away free shit, because rich people have too much money." Well, what about that small business owner? What about that middle class family who wants to buy a new home but saw their healthcare prices go up? What about college student who is looking for a job? Bernie never connected with those individuals.
"and what Bernie said was a gaffe."
So he gets a pass but not Trump?
"Trump was a minor celebrity before becoming president, "
That rallied in areas to connect with the common individual.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
"People should get into the medical field based on interest and skill,
not on their economic position. As it stands, its mostly people of upper
middle class or upper class income who get viably get into the
profession"
People of upper and middle class income also commit less crime, have less risk of disease, have lower obesity rate, and less rates of unwanted pregnancies. There is a lot to it. When you go to medical school you have expanded loan options and you end up earning more. From the University of Minnesota's website
"All US citizens and permanent residents qualify for federally sponsored
financial aid that covers the cost of attendance. While PharmD students
graduating in 2014 had a average of about $140,000 in combined
undergraduate and PharmD student loans, their median starting salary was
$120,000."
https://www.pharmacy.umn.edu/degrees-programs/doctor-pharmacy/admissions/costs-financial-aid-scholarships
" Thus, the pool to draw people into the medical profession is smaller than it should be."
The acceptance rate is less than 50%, the pool is fine. People just refuse to do the work.
"Nothing is free, true. Thats why government pays for it. "
A government with $20 trillion in debt.
" Perhaps tax money should be used for programs and services that benefit the majority of americans and not just the 1%. "
The top 1% pay a disproportional amount of federal income taxes.
"The US is the wealthiest nation to have ever exist in the history of
mankind. Im 99% positive the money is there for socialist programs that
would benefit the US as a whole."
It isn't.
"How come whenever the wealthy need tax cut, money is suddenly not an issue?"
They earned that money.
"Yes healthcare is expensive, subsidized education is expensive,
infrastructure is expensive; but better to spend it on things that will
actually benefit Americans than waste it abroad and on the rich."
We still can't afford it.
"Middle class would swell because more money would stay in the hands of citizens."
More money with, at best, similar production. Prices go up.
"And when the middle class has money, they spend a higher percentage of it than the rich "
Not true. Rich people invest it to produce better cars and electronics.
"This allows a larger percentage of total money to stay circulated within the economy and not just horded in banks"
Banks loan out that money to people to buy homes and start businesses. It just doesn't sit there.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
"People in the upper class commit less crime, have lower obesity rates,
blah blah blah....yes because they aren't in poverty and are given
advantages in life that poor people don't get."
Or maybe they work hard and are more responsible. Just because you are poor does not give you an excuse to commit crime.
" There are many bright poor people who would make much better doctors
than someone whose parents bought their way into a ivy league school."
You can't buy your way into med school.
"If you have the skills, you should have the same opportunity as someone of wealth."
For the most part you do. There are also several programs that offer a college education to poor people. For example, one of my students, who was poor, only paid $400 a semester for 15 credits.
"Government is in debt thanks to policies that created the 2008 recession "
It has been in debt since the days of Thomas Jefferson at least.
"The rich pay more in taxes, as they should. They can still afford their 6 supercars, 3 mansions, a beach house, and 2 yachts"
Your hatred towards the rich knows no bounds.
". Poor people are working two jobs"
Only around 5% of the country works multiple jobs.
"because wages have been stagnant for 30years."
Because of our massive immigration and our payroll tax.
"Rich people invest in research and development. Great! And their motivation to do that is to make more money. "
So? Do you not make investment to profit?
"Think of how much 150million middle class families contributes to the
economy: 150 millions homes bought, 150millions cars bought, 150million
dishwashers bought, 150million new tvs bought,"
Those are one time purchases. Also, that is a minute portion of the economy. And if they are willing to spend their new money that quickly they are poor for a reason as they have poor money management skills.
1