Comments by "Stephanie" (@Stephanie-zd5im) on "NBC News" channel.

  1. When she was released she said that when they were hostages a doctor would visit them every couple of days to check up on their medical conditions and Hamas did their best to provide all of their medications everyday. She said that they could not always get the same brands but they provided substitutes where needed. I don't think you understand that Israel cut off all medical aid going into Gaza on the first day of the war which was over 2 months ago and no one in Gaza can get the medicines and medical care they need. The hospitals have run out of medications weeks ago. Even bandages and disinfectants! Many seriously injured patients including little children have had to have amputations without anaesthetic or pain relief. Can you even begin to imagine such a thing? No of course we can't imagine that! What Israel has done in Gaza is completely inhumane!
    63
  2. I didn't think they would come out alive from the moment Netanyahu said the IDF would be searching for the hostages. Hannibal Directive.
    10
  3. As a Christian you should ask yourself what would Jesus say about the wanton slaughter of 13,000 plus Palestinian children. And still mercilessly ongoing.
    10
  4. A war is fought between two militaries. This is not a war.
    7
  5. ​ @Mina-ok5qm The IDF haven't freed any hostages.
    5
  6. ​​ @traviselrod7803 A 2 State Solution Complete freedom and self determination for the Palestinians with the same Human Rights that we all take for granted.
    5
  7. USS Liberty.
    4
  8. ​ @dianeglover479 They do evacuate. They have moved many ma y times in the last 7 months But guess what? They are attacked everywhere they go. There is nowhere safe in Gaza Gaza is 25 miles long and 6-12 Miles wide. 2.5 million people kettled into this tiny area. There is nowhere for them to escape!
    4
  9. Netanyahu was furious after her first interview where she was very positive about Hamas and he forbid any other hostages from speaking to the media after that. I think she has been warned.
    4
  10.  @trident6547  I agree the hostages should not have been there. I am not trying to whitewash anything. I am only repeating what the lady herself said about her experience.
    4
  11. Why is every rightful criticism of Israel called anti semetism? You do realise that the Palestinians are Semetic?
    3
  12. No. It is completely accurate! The monopoly on tragedy does not belong to the Jews and has been shamelessly used for decades to shut down criticism of Israel. Even Jewish scholars and Rabbis have said that what is happening in Gaza is an unprecedented brutality in modern history!
    3
  13. ​​​​ @Chen-xs9js  When she was first released she said that Hamas had treated the hostages very well and provided for all of their needs, including medications as best they could. But importantly, the hospital in Israel where she was taken after her release along with a couple of others also said that the hostages had been well cared for based on their own Medical Assessments.
    3
  14. This started in 1948.
    3
  15. ​ @Corey_Otis You don't pay for them to be taken care of. But you do pay for them to be slaughtered through providing billions of dollars of military aid to Israel.
    3
  16. Watch Tantura Watch Dier Yassin.
    2
  17. Very accurate comparison!
    2
  18. Exactly. Just a shame Netanyahu stood Security down from the wall a few hours before the attack. Especially having been given Intelligence by Egypt for several days before that the attack was imminent.
    2
  19. ​​ @AvrahamZahav3758  The worst tragedy in modern history is unfolding in Gaza!
    2
  20.  @TheEnglishOne  I don't ask anything from anyone. So not sure what you mean by that. But you are certainly judgemental. However I will assume you are in England based on your user name. I am in a different Country so perhaps we have a different experience.
    2
  21. She didn't say the crowds were beating her up. She said it felt like crowds beating her up, referring to riding on the bike!
    2
  22. ​ @marccepeci2980 Oh no they were not.
    2
  23. @janetannerevans2320 No Hamas does not. The first hostages who were released who said they were treated well by Hamas said they are exactly the same food as Hamas.
    2
  24. ​​ @victormorgado5318  How dare you. What an evil comment!
    2
  25. Yes the period in the Middle East before the State of Israel is known as the Golden Era!
    2
  26. I presume you are talking about Netanyahu?
    2
  27. The Palestinian children in Gaza are shell shell shocked after having bombs raining down on them for 7 weeks. There is something grotesque about people who cannot have sympathy for the suffering of the most traumatised children on the planet. The children of Gaza!
    1
  28. ​​ @AvrahamZahav3758  Palestinians have been on that land for many centuries. The are descendants of the Canaanites. They belong in that Land. The European Ashkenazi Jews who Occupy Israel are converts to Judaism in the 8th Century. They are from the Caucasus Region near Russia. They have no ancient ancestral connection to the Middle East and are usurpers who should not be there.
    1
  29. You actually believe that? I guess you didn't notice the bright smiles and shiny hair and glowing skin of the other hostages who were released!
    1
  30.  @animemaster4861  The Palestinians are also descendents of Abraham. That land also belongs to them. The land that Israel now occupies was called Palestine on the map before 1948. Israel removed the name Palestine from the map. But it was there and the Arabs who had lived there for thousands of years.
    1
  31.  @animemaster4861  I do not seek to justify terrorism. Palestinians are not Hamas. The current occupiers of Israel are not the Jews of Moses. They are European Ashkenazi Jews who converted to Judaism in the 8th Century. They do not have an ancient ancestral lineage connected to Israel . They are usurpers.
    1
  32. Just FYI,. It is Western Christian Countries that have started all of the Major World Wars! So peace loving.
    1
  33.  @curtisdalrymple42  6,000 Palestinian children have been killed by Israeli bombs. Babies, toddlers, little children.
    1
  34.  @Anivrap5000  Yes indeed.
    1
  35. ​​ @sunnymitra6372 No that is not true! Israel has scuppered every attempt at a 2 State Solution for decades. You need to research. Israel created and financed Hamas and Netanyahu had continued financing Hamas for years through Qatar. All documented. Read Netanyahu Hamas Stronghold. In 2019 Netanyahu told his Liduk Party that whoever opposes a 2 State Solution must continue to bolster and finance Hamas. The Palestinians have lived under a brutal Apartheid Regime of Oppression for 75 years. Research the Nakba. Watch ex IDF videos "Breaking the Silence"!
    1
  36. Israel told them to move to the South. Over a million people moved to the South. Now Israel is bombing the South. Israel is bombing the entire Gaza strip.
    1
  37. They did. Over a million people evacuated from the North to the South. This is the South. Israel is bombing the South. There is nowhere safe in Gaza.
    1
  38.  @saran19471  You are so grossly misinformed it is beyond contempt.
    1
  39.  @saran19471  You are grotesquely misinformed. The Palestinian people love their children. They are not asking to die. If you want to know where all of this started: Watch Tantura Watch Dier Yassin Research the Nakba Without that you have not researched!
    1
  40. Imagine being gullible enough to believe these Israeli lies.
    1
  41. It is grotesque!
    1
  42.  @paulamato7880  The IDF killed a lot of the hostages at the Kibbutz according to Israeli eyewitness Yasmin Porat. Apparently they stormed in firing everywhere indiscriminately. Not only that she witnessed an Israeli tank shell a house full of civilians and Hamas. Everyone died except one old lady. This was the Israeli Hannibal Directive in action. Read the Hannibal Directive.
    1
  43. Who exactly are you referring too? These people?
    1
  44. Isrsel has created it's enemies.
    1
  45. Kissinger was responsible for the deaths of 3 million people wasn't it?
    1
  46.  @Ges687  The entire area that Israel claimed was once called Palestine on the map.
    1
  47. Mossad I expect. Say what we tell you or else.
    1
  48.  @ronnycee7649  There are a lot of children in Israeli jails. The IDF regularly detain 8 yr olds. I recently watched a video of the IDF detaining a 5 year old. You have no idea what monsters they are It is time you and other people watch videos of ex IDF men and women speaking out against the abuses being carried out on Palestinian men, women and children everyday for decades. Videos - Breaking the Silence
    1
  49. I believe you just described the IDF.
    1
  50. Me either!
    1
  51. You can't fake body language! Stop believing Israeli lies and propaganda. The hostages look healthy as well.
    1
  52.  @Ges687  What Israel has done is against International Law according to the Geneva Convention.
    1
  53.  @57andstillkicking  The hostages were well taken care of. You cannot fake body language. The sparkling smiles, healthy skin, handshakes and even hugs. The first 4 hostages who were released said they were treated very well by Hamas. The hospital in Israel where the first hostages were taken after there release also said that the hostages had been well cared for based on their own Medical Assessments. Everyone has conveniently forgotten that. There is a reason why Netanyahu put a ban on hostages speaking to the media after that. What you are hearing now is Israeli lies and propaganda otherwise known as Hasbara.
    1
  54.  @kathrynstafford7099  6,000 children have been killed. Over 17,000 innocent Palestinian civilians have been killed. It must be easy to be so heartless to casually toss them aside as casualties of war.
    1
  55. The IDF are committing Genocide. No one can overlook the deaths of over 18 thousand innocent civilians including over 7,000 children. Israel cut off the food, water, fuel and medical aid to Gaza on the first day of this so called war.
    1
  56. ​ @Pagapraver  It is only Israel who hates the Palestinians and have persecuted them for 75 years.
    1
  57. The Gazans have no where to go. And Israel created and financed Hamas.
    1
  58.  @maryellenoneal2416  Israel cut the food and water supply to Gaza. Not Hamas.
    1
  59. Proof? Especially as half of the population are children most of whom were not even born when Hamas was elected 17 years ago. However let's not forget that Israel created and financed Hamas.
    1
  60.  @SweetCatBro  Israel is an Apartheid State according to International Law and the Geneva Convention!
    1
  61.  @SweetCatBro  Gaza is controlled by Israel. They have blockaded Gaza for 17 years. Nothing goes in or out of Gaza without Israel's approval. Gazans have to go through checkpoints everyday. They are hemmed in by a Wall with watchtowers and security cameras that are directed even into their homes. Palestinians who live in Israel do not have the same privileges as the Jews. They have different coloured ID. Registration plates. They are not allowed the same Land Rights. There are areas in Israel set aside only for Jews. Palestinians are not allowed to go into these areas. Israel is most definitely an Apartheid State.
    1
  62.  @bobbi7277  Israel doesn't want a 2 State Solution.
    1
  63.  @dennisferguson9129  This is not Israel defending itself!
    1
  64.  @RepentfollowJesus  Absolute rubbish. Hamas has not prevented anyone from leaving anywhere! Over a million people moved from the North to the South 7 weeks ago when Israel told them too. Then Israel bombed them in the South. Israel is bombing the entire Gaza strip There is nowhere safe in Gaza. By the way if you are supporting Israel in this so called war it is you who needs to repent. I do not know how you can even have the audacity to speak Jesus name! Hamas is not shooting people as they try to leave. The IDF was shooting them. There is also video footage of Israeli tanks opening fire on the civilians as they were moving from the North to the South!
    1
  65. According to Amnesty International who investigated the claim of Human Shields, Hamas does not use Human Shields! It is Israeli Propaganda. However Amnesty International did discover that the IDF used Palestinian children as Human Shields in the second Intifada and after the Israeli Government was issued with a warning apparently the IDF stopped using Human Shields.
    1
  66. Well they all come out smiling, chatting and waving to Hamas. You tell me!
    1
  67. No they aren't killing each other to get food. They take care of each other! But they are indeed desperate!
    1
  68. ​​ @jordanpryor4771 It is a lie. Amnesty International Investigated this year's ago and found that Hamas does not use Human Shields. Their Investigations did however find that the IDF used Palestinian children as Human Shields in the Second Intifada. They still do Read the Amnesty International Report online. By the way IDF Military Installations in Israel are embedded in residential neighbourhoods. Now that is using Human Shields.
    1
  69. The "Dancing Israeli's" in NY. "There to film the "event"! Yes that has been wiped from the net pretty much But many of us remember!
    1
  70.  @savagecub  You need to go further into research to find out!!!
    1
  71. Netanyahu banned the hostages from speaking to the media after the first 4 who were released spoke about how well they were treated by Hamas. People say they had to say nice things because they still had loved ones with Hamas. However the hospital in Israel where these hostages had been taken after their release had confirmed that they had been well taken care of according to their own Medical Assessments of the hostages Now we are hearing Israeli lies and propaganda otherwise known as Hasbara!
    1
  72. Israel created and financed Hamas. Netanyahu financed Hamas for years through Qatar. Read Netanyahu Hamas Stronghold. Netanyahu kept Hamas in Government! In 2019 Netanyahu told his Likud Party that whoever opposes a 2 State Solution must continue to bolster and finance Hamas! Hamas was voted into Government 17 years ago. Half of the population of Gaza are children under 18 who were not born when Hamas was Elected! The Gazans elected Hamas on the understanding that they would maintain peace with Israel and negotiate a peaceful 2 State Solution. The Gazans were duped. Israel had created Hamas to divide Gaza from the West Bank to push against the stronghold of the Fatah who wanted a 2 State Solution. Something Israel has never wanted despite appearances. Research.
    1
  73. ​ @SamuleAdams-br4pr The Palestinians have been on that land since the Bronze Age according to Gene Studies. They were the Cannanites. They are as connected to that land as the ancient Olive Trees.
    1
  74. ​ @DianeMonahan The Palestinians have stronger Hebrew Markers in their DNA than any modern Jews according to Gene Studies at the Jerusalem University. It is believed they were originally Jews who converted to Christianity and then you Islam
    1
  75. 6,000 Palestinian children killed by Israeli bombs in 7 weeks.
    1
  76. Netanyahu banned the hostages from speaking to the media after the first 4 to be released said they had been treated very well by Hamas. Anyone who doubts that should remember that the hospitals in Israel where the first hostages were taken after their release confirmed that they had been well taken care of based on their own Medical Assessments of the hostages. What we are hearing now is Israeli lies and propaganda otherwise known as Hasbara!
    1
  77.  @Lolita9762  No! Israel has been planning to take Gaza for decades! The Hamas attack was planned for 2 years. Israel was told about it 1 year ago and they were told how it would be carried out They were given the blueprint of the Plan a year ago. For several days before the Hamas attack Egyptian Intelligence warned Israel that the attack was imminent! But Netanyahu ignored the warnings. Instead of strengthening security on the Border Wall a few hours before the attack Security on the Wall was stood down. It took the IDF 6 hours to respond to the attack at the Kibbutz! Where were they? It usually takes no longer than 15 minutes to respond! The IDF were responsible for killing many of the hostages by the way. This is according to Israel's Hannibal Directive. You should read it! The attack gave Netanyahu the excuse Israel needed to take Gaza which they had been planning for decades! I do not believe in co-incidence! This war is not about Hamas!
    1
  78.  @brera2434  Israel created and financed Hamas to divide Gaza and the West Bank and push back against the popularity of the PLO who wanted to negotiate a peaceful 2 State Solution. Israel never wanted a 2 State Solution. Former Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segan who was Governor of Gaza in the early 1980s told the New York Times that he had financed Hamas. Israel provided the budget and the money was given to Hamas through the Mosques. If that money was legitimately for Gaza projects it would not have gone through the Mosques! Israeli Religious Affairs Officer Anver Cohen, who worked in Gaza for 2 decades told the Wall Street Journal that Hamas was Israel's creation! In 2019 Netanyahu told his Liduk Party that whoever opposes a 2 State Solution must continue to bolster and finance Hamas. Netanyahu was funneling money to Hamas through Qatar! The money was hand delivered to Hamas by the IDF. Read Netanyahu Hamas Stronghold.
    1
  79. He is repeating a lie. Hamas does not use Human Shields. Amnesty International Investigated this years ago and found that Hamas does not use Human Shields The same Investigation exposed that the IDF used Palestinian children as Human Shields in the Second Intifada. They still do. Read the Report Online Also IDF Military Installations in Israel are embedded in or next to residential neighbourhoods. That is using Human Shields.
    1
  80. She was in the dark because Israel cut off the electricity!
    1
  81. ​​ @PetrBouda-s4x  How do you figure that? These people had nothing whatsoever to do with Oct 7. They are not Hamas! Based on your twisted narrative every person who supports this genocide of innocent Palestinians have renounced their own humanity! Including you!
    1
  82. Rev 2.9 & Rev 3.9
    1
  83. Yes. You cannot fake body language! One was even carrying a little white dog who also looked healthy!
    1
  84. What is shameful about broadcasting the truth of what is happening to the Civilians in Gaza?
    1
  85. It is not collective trauma that drives them. It is Nationalistic Supremacy. Same as Hitler.
    1
  86. Well said and true.
    1
  87. ​ @PapaBless23 Israel has always controlled the food supply into Gaza. Also the water, fuel and medical Supplies!
    1
  88. ​ @ric1895 They are starving. They need food not salt.
    1
  89. ​​ @kevinmiller5467  That is the way Israel has created! Israel has always controlled the food, water, fuel and medical supplies into Gaza!
    1