Comments by "nuqwestr" (@nuqwestr) on "'We danced with joy then hid among the dead' – Nova survivors recall Hamas massacre | BBC News" video.

  1. ? WHAT ? That's all the BBC has been doing for over a year? LOL
    12
  2. No stolen land, false, same old Taqiyya, not aging well.
    8
  3. Zoo created by Hamas 14 JUNE 2007. Egypt controlled Gaza after 1948, what did they do with it? The PA took over in 2005. What did they do with it. "Struggle for necessities?, many Gazans have cars better than yours, I'm sure, and almost 20,000 a day were coming into Israel to work on Oct 6th under ceasefire. Hamas used that ceasefire to gain intel for Oct 7th.
    7
  4. A "concentration camp"? With a border with Egypt? Which controlled Gaza from 1948 to 1967?
    7
  5. ? "At this point"? The propaganda went your way the entire year, mate. So funny.
    5
  6. ? On Oct 6th the border was open and almost 20,000 Gazans a day were coming into Israel. The Hamas attack had been planned for many months before, the Festival was just handy, full of young women to - you know.
    5
  7. Lebanon and Jordan apartheid states, not Israel, with 20% of its population Arab, who serve on the Knesset, the Supreme Court and in the IDF. Show me the comparable in the region. Stop the Taqiyya.
    4
  8. "Peace" with whom?
    4
  9.  @_ArsNova  Gaza was annexed by Egypt in 1948, it was 1967 when Egypt lost Gaza in a war they started. Israel left in 2005, in 2007 Hamas took over in a military coup. Your math is incorrect.
    4
  10.  @LayLoow  Hannibal directive was to prevent Israelis from being taken hostage.
    2
  11. SCOOP! Taqiyya, permission by al-Lah to lie. Allah, the "best deceiver" it is written.
    2
  12.  @_ArsNova  Not comparable based on the timeline of action. Take responsibility.
    1
  13. "grandfathers were placed in"? The majority of Israelis are not from Eastern Europe. Almost 1 million came after 1948 from "ghettos" in Arab and Muslim theocracies. There are 450,000 Yemini Jews in Israel today. Imagine their lives in Yemen today.
    1
  14. Why? Don't ask a rhetorical question like that. Say it out loud, like Apollo 11 didn't really land on the moon, it was fake, or the Bush family planned 9/11. Just say it.
    1
  15. "cages"? 14 June 2007 Hamas takes over Gaza in a bloody coup and starts using UNRWA money to build the strip into a military platform to attack Israel. I do agree, however, no place to take psychedelics and escape from reality, which was tenacious in its return.
    1
  16. ? Gaza was controlled by Egypt from 1948 to 1967 when they lost a war they started. "Stolen"?
    1
  17.  @yuvalevr  The British did not own the land, it was given a temporary mandate by the Allied Powers after WW1 to supervise the creation of modern, nation/states in the region. The UN voted on a partition, part of which became the new nation/state of Israel. Jordan was also created at about the same time. Jews willing to share, Arabs were not.
    1
  18.  @Laythh  FALSE: The region was controlled by the Ottoman/Turk who lost a war to the Allied Powers in WW1. Both Jews and Arabs fought with the British in that war. The Turks ceded the region to the Allied Powers in a peace treaty, all legal. The Allied Powers created temporary mandates in the region until modern, nation/states could be created. One was Jordan, another was Israel. Jews were willing to share, the Arabs were not. Israel did not get "half", Gaza was occupied by Egypt, Jordan annexed the West Bank. It wasn't until both Egypt and Jordan, again, declared war on Israel that the territory came under control by Israel. That wasn't until 1967, What did Egypt and Jordan do for the people in the 20 years between 1947 and 1967? In the 19th Century Jews were the majority in East Jerusalem, perhaps 8-12% of the Ottoman region called Palestine. They fought and died to free the land from the Ottoman/Turk. Are you saying they don't deserve autonomy in a region which is their homeland?
    1
  19. ​ @Laythh  Ah, then by your logic the land should go back to the Turks. And perhaps the Hejaz, which contains both Mecca and Media, should go back to the Hashemites of Jordan, land they lost in the 1930s to Ibn Saud.
    1
  20.  @yuvalevr  I support Israel's autonomy and defense, and consider myself a Zionist. But there were Palestinian leaders prior to 1964, going all the way back to the early 20th Century: "Report on the State of Palestine presented to the Right Honourable Mr. Winston Churchill P.C., M.P. by the Executive Committee of the Third Arab Palestine Congress. Jerusalem, March 28, 1921." - Library of Congress
    1
  21.  @Laythh  I agree, but you left out the British created Palestinian leader, "The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini, friend of both Adolfs, Eichmann and Hitler. al-Husseini is still revered as a great hero by the PA leader, Mahmoud Abbas.
    1
  22.  @Laythh  "Useful"? LOL. The Jews fought with the British in WW1 to free the land from the Ottoman /Turk. There were Jewish battalions before the Arabs joined in the fight. "Land" yes, nation/state, no. As I believe you know, the temporary mandate agreed to at San Remo in 1920 was part of The League of Nations plan to create modern, democratic nation/states in the region. This plan had three levels depending on the current state of development in that region. Palestine was at the bottom of that level. LOL The Arab-Revolts you called "resistance", delayed the creation of these modern, nation/states, which were more delayed and complicated by WW2. Further, the Arab-Revolts were not just against the British and Zionist project, but against each other, like the battle for the Hejaz between the Hashemites and the House of Saud. Too bad, a few year later oil was discovered and the leases went to America and not the British. Brits made so many mistakes. I've studied this for 55 years. I've distilled my thoughts to a concise frame. The Jews and Arabs fought in a war, they both won, the Jews were willing to share, the Arabs were not. Proof? Here it is: "Report on the State of Palestine presented to the Right Honourable Mr. Winston Churchill P.C., M.P. by the Executive Committee of the Third Arab Palestine Congress. Jerusalem, March 28, 1921." - Library of Congress. A quote from the report: "A Jew is a Jew the world over". Pure hate, the blood libel, written in 1921.
    1
  23. ? "do they recall"? The majority of Israeli citizens are not Eastern European, 20% are Arab, another 34% are from the region, with 450,000 from Yemen. Imagine what it would be like to be a Jew in Yemen today?
    1
  24.  @Parjesh888  ? "regular people"? What are you talking about? Our brains have not changed in something like 200,000 years.
    1
  25. IDF had in practice applied the Hannibal Directive from noon of October 7, ordering all combat units to stop "at all costs" any attempt by Hamas terrorists to return to Gaza with hostages, not just soldiers.
    1
  26.  @darrenjamrock2677  ? Jordan kicked the PLO out after they fomented a civil war and assassinated their PM. they fled to Lebanon where they do not have civil rights. Jordan restricts the number of Christians in government and academia and is an Islamic state. When a Christian was elected PM of Lebanon, Islamists assassinated him. 20% of Israeli citizens are Arab; some Christians, some Druze, some Muslim. They serve on the Knesset, the Supreme Court and in the IDF. One of the most popular news readers on Israeli TV is an Arab/Muslim/Palestinian woman. Show me the comparable in Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon or Syria. Syria has killed more Arabs than any IDF soldier. Look in the mirror. In WW1 both the Jews and Arabs fought with the British to free the region of the Ottoman/Turk. The Turks ceded the region in a peace treaty with the Allied Powers who were given a temporary mandate to help create new, modern nation/states. One of those was a Palestinian state called Trans-Jordan, which became Jordan in 1946. The Jews were willing to share, the Arabs were not. No land was stolen, that is false.
    1
  27. "Opinion", there are similar videos that claim the Apollo moon landing was fake. In that case, it's Taqiyya.
    1
  28.  @publics.public  Sure, and Apollo 11 landing on the moon was fake and the Bush family planned 9/11. Mosab Hassan Yousef tells a different story.
    1
  29. 14 June 2007 Hamas turned Gaza into a military platform to attack Israel, even using UNRWA money to do so.
    1