Comments by "M Simon" (@msimon6808) on "Sabine Hossenfelder" channel.

  1. Without the "source data and the code used" it is not science. Let alone settled.
    10
  2. OK. Tell me the accuracy of this. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? According to the theory water vapor's lack of persistence in the atmosphere (rain) means WV only counts for heating, not for evaporating more water vapor. Which is absurd because heating causes evaporation. The theory is bunk.
    5
  3. Based on accepted theory...... Water Vapor (WV) is a greenhouse gas as potent as CO2 according to theory. On average there is 50 times as much WV in the atmosphere as CO2. The fact that it is non -persistent is often mentioned. It doesn't have to be. You can AVERAGE (integrate) the effect. There is on AVERAGE 50 times as much.
    4
  4. The science is settled. There is only one model. Model(s) implies the science is not settled. Are we being lied to?
    4
  5. You think so? Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? According to the theory water vapor's lack of persistence in the atmosphere (rain) means WV only counts for heating, not for evaporating more water vapor. Which is absurd because heating causes evaporation. The theory is bunk.
    3
  6.  @jitteryjet7525  I looked at the "old hoax" at the time it was new. Look at Steve Mosher's report. I believe I'm in there. It wasn't a hoax. BTW since the science is settled where are the equations and the values used for the parameters? Has the sign of the water vapor parameter been declared yet? WV is a GHG = CO2. There is 50 times as much in the atmosphere. Getting the sign (and value) correct could be important.
    3
  7.  @friedmule5403  "Will that demand a newer, bigger hair-collider? " Super hare collider. Dinner post collision.
    3
  8.  @billmcleangunsmith  Lots of money riding on global warming. IS THE REASON.
    2
  9. H2O is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. Still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? Average results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    2
  10.  @gearoiddom  Irrelevant isn't the half of it. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    2
  11. It has to be very complicated to use water vapor and then make it disappear. Magic. Magic is not science. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    2
  12. According to GHG theory water vapor is equal to CO2 when it comes to GHG heating. Sabine never mentions that. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much. Last I looked the sign of the water vapor parameter in the equations had not been determined - let alone the value. Has that changed? And BTW what are the equations and parameter values and initialization constants? For replication. Since the science is settled we ought to know those things. Where can I find them?
    2
  13. Water Vapor (WV) is a greenhouse gas as potent as CO2 according to theory. On average there is 50 times as much WV in the atmosphere as CO2. The fact that it is non -persistent is often mentioned. It doesn't have to be. You can AVERAGE (integrate) the effect. There is on AVERAGE 50 times as much.
    1
  14. Global warming by CO2 has never been scientifically proved. The computer codes are not open source and have never been verified. On top of that the coefficients are parameterized. There was an argument about water vapor. Is its parameter positive or negative. Has that been settled? If computers are needed to settle the issue and the codes are not open - it isn't scientific. Science is not done in secret. We save that for engineering.
    1
  15. There are always losses. Superconductors radiate when the current flow changes.
    1
  16. If only climate science.... Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  17. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much. ==> She still believes in GHG Theory
    1
  18.  @CharveL88  Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much. ==> She still believes in GHG Theory
    1
  19.  @mpmpm  Your evaluation is not useful to answer the question. Atmospheric absorption of light is calculated per molecule not per ton. When you count molecules there is 50 times as much Water vapor vs CO2.
    1
  20. It is very unpopular. You can make the truth obvious and people will tell you it is a lie. Addiction is a symptom of PTSD says Nobel Prize Winner in Medicine Eric Kandel in his book, "The Disordered Mind." Receptor science (100+ years old) says there are NO addictive drugs. Drugs fill receptors. What empties receptors (injury, PTSD) causes a desire for pain relieving drugs. Drugs CAN'T cause addiction. People take pain relievers to relieve pain. So, the Master Strategy is to make war on people in pain to make them give up pain relief. Is that gonna work? For over 100 years - it hasn't. Try entering - drugs don't cause addiction - into a Google search .
    1
  21. Global warming by GHGs is a fact. We will need to drain the oceans. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    1
  22. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  23. Lose faith in science? It is only natural. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  24. Who doesn't write climate change propaganda? Water Vapor (WV) is a greenhouse gas as potent as CO2 according to theory. On average there is 50 times as much WV in the atmosphere as CO2. The fact that it is non-persistent is often mentioned. It doesn't have to be. You can AVERAGE (integrate) the effect. There is on AVERAGE 50 times as much. Non-persistent ==> Definition - only heat trapped by CO2 molecules can evaporate water vapor molecules. The heat water vapor traps doesn't cause water evaporation. Did I mention that quite a majority claims to believe this swill?
    1
  25. Drugs can't cause addiction. Who in the medical field stands up and opposes Government? Addiction is a symptom of PTSD says Nobel Prize Winner in Medicine Eric Kandel in his book, "The Disordered Mind." Receptor science (100+ years old) says there are NO addictive drugs. Drugs fill receptors. What empties receptors (injury, PTSD) causes a desire for pain relieving drugs. Drugs CAN'T cause addiction. People take pain relievers to relieve pain. So, the Master Strategy is to make war on people in pain to make them give up pain relief. Is that gonna work? For over 100 years - it hasn't.
    1
  26.  @jitteryjet7525  I have my own suspicions. Water vapor is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    1
  27. Good job but, I can give a much shorter explanation based on GHG physics. H2O is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    1
  28. Here is some biological convincing: ==> Drugs fill receptors. Pain empties receptors. PTSD empties receptors. Filling empty receptors makes you feel good. Empty receptors create a desire for drugs. Drugs do not create a desire for drugs.
    1
  29. The invention of GHGs was the start of climate rot.
    1
  30.  @stuartdparnell  "Sounds like a wild goose chase to me" In a wild goose chase an actual wild goose is possible.
    1
  31. Carnot is unforgiving.
    1
  32. There are the problems of things very well known that absolutely ain't so. A very big problem in biology. Drugs fill receptors. Pain empties receptors. PTSD empties receptors. Filling empty receptors makes you feel good. Empty receptors create a desire for drugs. Drugs do not create a desire for drugs.
    1
  33. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  34. According to GHG Theory water vapor does 3/4s of the heating. You knew that didn't you?
    1
  35. GHG Theory is a case in point. It is self refuting. Water Vapor (WV) is a greenhouse gas as potent as CO2 according to theory. On average there is 50 times as much WV in the atmosphere as CO2. The fact that it is non-persistent is often mentioned. It doesn't have to be. You can AVERAGE (integrate) the effect. There is on AVERAGE 50 times as much. Non-persistent ==> Definition - only heat trapped by CO2 molecules can evaporate water vapor molecules. The heat water vapor traps doesn't cause water evaporation.
    1
  36. Who isn't a believer? The amount of credulity available is incredible.
    1
  37. If only she understood GHG Theory. Water Vapor (WV) is a greenhouse gas as potent as CO2 according to theory. On average there is 50 times as much WV in the atmosphere as CO2. The fact that it is non-persistent is often mentioned. It doesn't have to be. You can AVERAGE (integrate) the effect. There is on AVERAGE 50 times as much. Non-persistent ==> Definition - only heat trapped by CO2 molecules can evaporate water vapor molecules. The heat water vapor traps doesn't cause water evaporation.
    1
  38.  @HealingLifeKwikly  Greenhouses like CO2 above 1%. About those adaptations ..... And of course with CO2 rising "greening" is up. We will get a mass extinction from global warming by CO2? H2O is 50 times worse. H2O is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    1
  39.  @HealingLifeKwikly  Since global warming by CO2 is proved could you show me the equations? And the constants used for calculation? Plus all the initial values of the variables?
    1
  40.  @XavierBetoN  Some realism for you. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  41. Addiction is a myth. People in Chronic Pain Chronically take Pain Relievers.
    1
  42.  @EternalStarVoyager  The minimum is about 100 milliseconds.
    1
  43.  @snowballeffect7812  Water vapor disproves CO2 caused global warming. The discrepancy is glaring. Who notices?
    1
  44. Drug addiction is quite simple when looked at objectively. People in Chronic Pain Chronically take Pain Relievers. Just because the Government doesn't believe in medicating for serious PTSD doesn't mean that they know the truth. People act otherwise.
    1
  45. Have the computer codes 'proving' global warming ever been released? Since the computation is not done on first principles, have the parameters used ever been released? John von Neumann used to say, "with four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk." Currently there is not one global warming program. There are hundreds. This is not science.
    1
  46. All you need to know. ==> Prohibition is Socialism for Criminals. Those paying attention learned that from Alcohol Prohibition.
    1
  47. That scared you? I can show you a problem that is RIGHT NOW 50 times worse. H2O is a greenhouse gas equal to CO2 according to theory. There is on average 50 times as much in the atmosphere as CO2. There are still no proposals for draining the oceans. Water vapor is not persistent? You can average the results. Called integration in calculus. There is 50 times as much.
    1
  48.  @kanguruster  It has to be complicated. To cover this up. Water vapor is the #1 Greenhouse gas. It does 3/4s of the heating according to GHG theory. If you can believe the theory. If the theory is correct water vapor alone will destroy the planet. There is on average 50 times as much water vapor in the atmosphere as CO2.
    1
  49. Belief in GHGs is the start of the rot. It then gets worse . Water vapor = CO2 in effect. Water vapor dwarfs CO2 in the atmosphere.
    1
  50. I like being an engineer.
    1