Comments by "Kameraden" (@Alte.Kameraden) on "Wilhelm Hoffman’s Stalingrad diary is a FAKE" video.

  1. It why I like TIK he doesn't just vomit out what he's read ie verbally copy/paste his content from cited sources. As his phrase goes "But is that really the case?" He gives people a reason to think. Which is a skill that is necessary to comprehend history. It's far superior to just blatant recitation.
    19
  2. To be frank, even earlier in the stalingrad series it's evident that Chuikov intentionally lies. Though he isn't the only General to do this, many on all sides have done this, during and post war. Chief among them, TIK's favorite scapegoat Halder, among also Generals like Montgomery, Manstein etc.
    5
  3. Question is, why wasn't this questioned earlier, when it seems so blatant now. Surely more Historians digging into this would of noticed, and it would of been caught far earlier. Yet it still used. Are specific people just sweeping it under the rug because it makes their stereotypical version of Stalingrad make sense?
    3
  4.  @TheImperatorKnight  Make sense. It's like fast forwarding through a movie, or skipping pages in a book then expecting to know the whole story.
    2