Comments by "Arun Sar" (@arunsar7893) on "Indonesia: Diversity under threat | DW Documentary" video.

That's the most intellectually dishonest position ever and part of the problem. The fact is: "It IS the religion that is the problem, not the people".
109
@finzz7330 We can offcourse disagree. But I have seen what the religion of Islam does to even the educated people. And it's the same. There are people with Oxford degrees who are exactly like the Abi Wahid guy. They want Sharia law in UK. Education can't solve an ideological problem. The sooner people realise that the better.
61
@finzz7330 "theres old law in islam that doesnt fit the modern society" - Exactly. But those laws are there in Islam, which is why I say Islam is the problem. What you are saying is reformation of Islam. Then it changes into something else but with the same name.
31
@carlosminjarez9050 "the problem are the people" - That's what Hilter said before he gased 6 million people. Learn to differentiate ideas from people. Ideology are the problem. People are behaving the way they are bcs of the ideology, not independent of them. And saying it's not Islam, it's the people is a clever way of hiding what Islam really is.
22
@gustafdn Islam has created the same problems be it India, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, UK, Europe or Africa. The same problems exist irrespective of whether the community is educated or uneducated, irrespective of gender, financial condition, democracy or dictatorship. You can vary every other condition and keep one thing constant, i.e. Islam and you get the same result. I don't think living in Indonesia would tell me any different.
15
@carlosminjarez9050 False equivalence. Situations are not the same. You aren't even comparing apples with oranges, you are comparing apples with horses. These are desperate attempts to shield a religious ideology from criticism. It's pretty clear you don't know what you are talking about.
13
@iskandar2712 So, I am "misguiding" people because I don't share the same views are you?? Islam is not a peaceful religion. And the argument that Islam is perfect but people are not, is a very bad argument forwarded by apologists all the time. Can you give me a straight forward answer to these questions? 1. What is the punishment for leaving Islam? 2. Do you think Islam and it's followers want to establish an Islamic Caliphate which rules over the world with Sharia being implemented everywhere?
11
@iskandar2712 "Bro give me a reason why u think Islam isnt a peaceful religion and to awnser ur questions" - You have answered your own question. Your answer to the second question is one of the many answers. How do you think the caliphate will be established if not by war and conquering?? .. That is what the Islamic history has been throughout the establishment of all four caliphates. "2.I think they want because the world will be a more peaceful world with sharia law" - Go to 15:00 to see what Sharia looks like. It looks the same everywhere it's practised be it Indonesia or Afghanistan. Someone really has to be brain dead to believe this is what "peace" looks like or to believe that people from around the world will readily accept this. "1.There is no punishment if u leave Islam if u wanna leave thats ur decision" - You need to read the Qur'an again brother. The punishment for leaving Islam or apostasy is death.And that is why it's put into law in 13 Islamic countries. Apart from this, Islam is homophobic, misogynistic and anti-scientific as well (please don't tell me Qur'an has science in it. I have read the Qur'an and there is nothing scientific in it.) Brother, people have written books on the question you have asked. Maybe you should try reading them.
9
@iskandar2712 Bro, First stop thinking that only you understand Islam and everyone else is misguided. And second, stop thinking that people need to do a PhD in Islam before speaking about it.
8
@haziqehsan I don't. I suggest you stop worshipping the r*pey arab warlord who you think was the perfect man. That, i am sure, has far more dangerous consequences.
7
SMM Productions Could you say what is it that can also be said about Christian and Hindu nations? .. There are too many comments. I don't know what is it that you are referring to.
6
Brittany James By that logic Nazi ideology had nothing to do with Holocaust since Nazism was also an ideology created by people. So, it's ok if someone follows Nazi ideology and wants to propagate it, since the ideology isn't the problem, people are. Right?
3
one for all What does that sentence even mean ??
2
@speemus6223 Actually, I had to shift to UK to realise what Islam really is. All the time I was in India, I didn't feel the need to read the Qur'an. All my negativity stems purely from reading the 'holy' text, exactly like all the ex-muslims.
2
@speemus6223 This documentary like many others, exposes the true face of Islam. It's the same, whether it be in Indonesia, European countries, Middle Eastern countries or Afghanistan. The geo-politics, politics, culture, economy are all irrelevant.
2
34:58 That for certain is NOT the islamic god. She needs to revist Qur'an & Hadith.
1
@bigmanharold1443 I agree. It's not about education.
1