Comments by "Titanium Rain" (@ChucksSEADnDEAD) on "The Failed Logistics of Russia's Invasion of Ukraine" video.

  1. A lot of territory is flat land that is mostly indefensible against a superior foe. Defenses purposefully gave up that ground to get a better position and thin out the enemy and force it to stretch past its logistical capabilities. You're looking at the red color on a map while not thinking about the context. The US in similar situations has delivered an absolute curbstomping (situations such as the kickoff of 73 Easting where infantry fighting vehicles came across a superior number of main battle tanks with the defensive advantage, and still the lesser vehicles took out several tanks on their own before help arrived) while Russia seems to be dragged into ambush after ambush as their enemy recognizes that they can't trade blows and expect to survive.
    2
  2. Apparently you can't read? The logistics failure happened. Winning a war doesn't erase mistakes. We can analyze them as we please.
    1
  3.  @TheRacy  Reaching an arbitrary line doesn't undo the equipment that was left stranded due to breakdowns and fuel shortages. If you're securing a country, but have to steal food, you didn't bring supplies. Now stop wasting everyone's time.
    1
  4. Which is something that was predicted to happen 96 hours after they crossed the border. It's been ten days. Yeah you finished the marathon, but everyone saw you eat dirt when you tripped in the first ten yards.
    1
  5.  @spideylover4105  It does. If you have poor logistics you have poor logistics.
    1
  6. This is cope. Doesn't matter what kind of doctrine one has, convoys should not be breaking down and running out of fuel like this.
    1
  7. Not really. The main Coalition force entered through Basra province. 280 miles to Bagdad. Belarus border is 140 miles to Kiev. 21 days / 2 = 10.5 days. Behind schedule.
    1
  8. Not really. Failures already happened. Even if you get back on track, the failure happened, we've all seen it, and we can analyze it.
    1
  9. Doesn't matter how it ends, we've already seen enough to take conclusions.
    1
  10.  @leftenanalim  It is possible. You ran out of fuel? You ran out of food? Your tires blew out? We've all seen it.
    1
  11. If the halt is caused by blown tires and fuel shortages, that's not doctrine.
    1
  12.  @mididoctors  It took from March 20 to April 9 to capture Bagdad, and they entered from Basra province - Basra is 280 miles from Bagdad. The Ukraine/Belarus border to Kiev is 140 miles. Not to mention the US was conducting the operation from halfway across the globe, while Russia is doing it from their own doorstep.
    1
  13. Cope. It was meant to have ended within 96 hours.
    1
  14. Vehicles break down, run out of fuel, soldiers steal food, and you claim there's no logistics issue.
    1
  15. Pretty much all countries have it written into law that the state can call on all able bodied men to serve in case of invasion, thus ban them from leaving.
    1