Comments by "Titanium Rain" (@ChucksSEADnDEAD) on "Mark Takacs" channel.

  1. ​ @gbabayan  Every Ukrainian soldier interviewed who described meatwaves explained exactly what they meant. It's the pro-Russia crowd who intentionally confused meat wave with HUMAN wave (Korean War style) so they can say "there are no videos of Russian meat waves".
    14
  2. ​ @asavelakuse6865  A meat wave isn't a banzai charge. A meat wave is part of a creeping advance that is known to fail but expected to facilitate a future wave.
    10
  3. ​ @Conserpov  Wrong. Recon by fire aka "speculative fire" is firing on positions to measure the response. Recon in force aka probing attacks is an attack that is meant to gauge the defender. Recon by fire will not risk an assault element as you don't send men, just shells.
    8
  4. There's several Bakhmut videos showing it.
    8
  5. That was human wave. Human waves are just not possible today. Armies have reduced in size and demographics to not allow it. Plus technology would spoil the incoming attack.
    5
  6. Minsk was broken by Russia. Who initiated the attack on Debaltseve immediately after one of the Minsk treaties was signed?
    5
  7. ​ @CyrilSneer123  There's already pictures of 170mm North Korean artillery, when the Russian army doesn't use 170mm.
    5
  8. There's absolutely footage of a "mule" assault phase in Bakhmut. Men not carrying rifles holding ammo cases and wearing vests with their pouches full.
    4
  9. How do you know the objective is manned? You'll hit empty positions and get counter-battery to work on you.
    2
  10. Which peasant farmers defeated Western forces? The PAVN (the VC were effectively destroyed in the Tet Offensive and replced by North Vietnamese) defeated the ARVN two years after the US left. The Taliban defeated the ANA in about two weeks after the US left. At no point did they achieve victory over the US. They signed peace deals and broke them.
    2
  11. That's a human wave, not meat wave.
    2
  12. Preemptive against what?
    2
  13. ​ @Casisking639  Thousands charging at MGs = HUMAN WAVE (a sea of people crashing like waves against the coast) Small groups in a creeping advance = MEAT wave (a wave of zombies you have to clear like in videogames, knowing you're playing to see how many waves you can clear and you eventually lose)
    2
  14. By visual confirmed losses alone, Vuhledar cost a force larger than some European armies.
    1
  15. There's meat waves caught on video. Squads with very few weapons, no mechanization to avoid drawing drones. Creeping advances to fighting positions and to dig further up.
    1
  16. ​ @arsic094  It was unprovoked. 2014 there was no conflict, then Russia moved a force covertly into Sevastopol naval base to take the peninsula of Crimea while sending Russian nationals like Igor Girkin and "Motorola" to start a faux separatist movement. Russia was the instigator from the start.
    1
  17. ​@kindlingking It wasn't a civil war. Men like Igor Girkin and Arsen Pavlov ("Motorola") were sent by Russia to fake an uprising. Russian troops were fighting under the banner of "separatists" and when captured, the Russian government said they had gotten lost or were off-duty on vacations.
    1
  18. Nonsense. Human wave attacks are imposible. Meat waves are precisely a way to exploit the existence of drones and artillery, by creating small groupings that won't draw the big guns.
    1
  19. Not really. There was a clear divide between success and failure. The meat wave is supposed to "fail" and then a future wave will succeed.
    1
  20. ​ @Kansika  What? Not only did Putin not fix anything, he also allowed the West to profit immensely.
    1
  21. ​ @Rick8191-tv8pg  It wasn't a meat wave attack as the advance wasn't slow and creeping. A meat wave on D-day would have looked like row boats delivering a few squads per day over months.
    1
  22. Those weren't meat waves. Meat waves only make sense in the modern world where technology like drones prevents bunching forces together.
    1
  23. ​ @qwertyui-EFRB  It was never about mass. Nearly every interview with Ukrainians on defense say they same. The waves are small. They just get tired of fighting and run out of ammo. The "mass" is a red herring by the pro-Russia crowd misusing meat wave as the old "human wave".
    1