Comments by "m g" (@07Flash11MRC) on ""A MAN!": Lies Spread Over Olympic Fight Between Algerian And Italian" video.

  1. Science isn't based on looks. Kehlif has previously been disqualified because of both high levels of T and XY chromosomes. I have no problem if she identifies as a woman privately, but sports needs to be fair and she has all of the advantages she could have, because she is biologically male.
    6
  2. Thank you, exactly. I'm so sick of all those people defending a guy with XY chromosomes and excessively high levels of T, pretending that he is a woman. He is free to participate with men, so why is he in the woman's category?
    6
  3.  @lvli044  "know better than the Olympics": Science os objective and therefore knows "better than the olympics", because the olympic committee isn't made up of scientists.
    5
  4.  @lvli044  "What facts?": The ones that I posted in my previous comment that has been deleted by YT immediately, lol. Long story short, here are the facts: "high levels of T and XY chromosomes"
    4
  5. Exactly. Thanks you.
    4
  6. That isn't true at all. Kehlif has been disqualified from the world cup for their excessively high levels of T (ones that women could never reach naturally) and their XY chromosomes.
    3
  7. Yes, he does have XY chromosomes and he has been disqualified from other competitions because he is male, not female.
    3
  8. Different competitions with different committees and different rules. Regardless, I do agree with you. Similar things happened to Caster Semanya, Barbra Banda and other athletes who are either intersex or male and want to compete against women.
    3
  9. He also has XY chromosomes and was banned from the world cup.
    3
  10.  @lvli044  "They aren't a transwoman in the sense that you feel.": It's really disingenuous of you to misquote and then strawman me. I never claimed Kehlif was trans. I stated that I don't personally care whether in her private life they identify as a man or a woman. Again: I'm all about facts, whereas you are arguing based on your feelings.
    2
  11.  @greenthumb8266  "nobody plays sports for fun": Playing sport at the level of a world class athlete isn't "fun". It takes a lot of continuous work and determination. Also, if you lose your spot at the next tournament, you are often dropped immediately from your team and you won't be paid.
    2
  12.  @greenthumb8266  No, you're the one missing the point and strawmanning me. I never said the world would come to an end or that we should be worshipping athletes, lmfao. I explained the capitalist system to you, because you are clearly unhappy with it, because you don't understand it. They get the money they deserve. if people weren't paying so much to see them, they wouldn't be paid as much.
    2
  13. Not excessively high amounts, though, and XY chromosomes like him.
    2
  14. Agreed. I can't believe we've come to the point where men just call themselves "women" and then make a career outta stealing women's spot and dominating women's sports. Idc what people do in their private lives, but this is about professional sports.
    2
  15.  @thirstaefortae5057  "and they are firmly behind allowing Imane to compete": Kehlif was disqualified from the 2023 world cup, because he is biologically male.
    2
  16. Yes.
    2
  17. (S)he also has the XY chromosomes, the ingrown testes and testosterone levels of men.
    2
  18. "it turns out she has XY genes, which are male only genes and therefore gave her a male body": Exactly. Thank you!
    2
  19. *he . He is biologiaclly male.
    2
  20.  @lvli044  "The people who set the guidelines are actually": Guidelines mean nothing when a person with XY chromosomes and overwhelming amounts of testosterone still get to compete against women, whereas women with XX chromosomes and just a slightly higher testosterone level are disqualified immediately. "this person has an intersex condition": I'm so glad you agree that she's not a woman then, because women (incl girls) aren't intersex and neither are men (incl boys).
    1
  21.  @evangeloevoxi  "if she was born with female reproductive organs": Reproductive organs don't matter, if his hormone levels and his chromosomes are those of a man.
    1
  22.  @lvli044  "What about them? Did she fail the test to legally compete in Paris or not?": She failed previous tests for other competitions such as the 2023 world cup.
    1
  23.  @jayhollows5729  "when YouTube glitches out for everyone": And you think it's funny that we are being censored by the elite..
    1
  24.  @lvli044  "You aren't being censored by feminists or whoever you think is hurting you lol.": More strawmen from you. Besides, feminists will soon be complaining that women's sports is being taken over by men, because all of them are physically stronger by default. Random dudes are showing up, claiming they are women and breaking women's records by either multiple miles, minutes and kilograms, lol.
    1
  25.  @jlighter1  "high T levels Is not a foolproof indicator": Not true. They were excessively high. So high that women can't reach them naturally, not even with pcos. It's really disingenuous of you to disagree with medical doctors who do those tests. "an inactive X chromosome": If you have that, you develop differently. Intersex people aren't women and should not be competing with them.
    1
  26.  @piscinaiv7937  "Females have two of the same kind of sex chromosome (XX), and are called the homogametic sex. Males have two different kinds of sex chromosomes (XY), and are called the heterogametic sex.": Exactly. Isn't it interesting how science is way too hard for most people here, that they are convinced that men can just call themselves women and have no physical advantages at all?
    1
  27.  @lvli044  "that has nothing to do with trans people": Even more strawmen. I have not once talked about trans people and you still keep bringing them up while skipping the science and the facts. He is biologically male with XY chromosomes (aka cis male, not trans). This isn't a "guideline failure".
    1
  28.  @jlighter1  "Your previous comment wasn’t deleted or hidden, it’s plenty visible.": Well, that's great news, because I can't see any of them.
    1
  29. Kennedy has been exposed for working with Trump. If you vote for him, you are voting for Trump.
    1
  30. His chromosomes are XY.
    1
  31. Yes, I feel sick for the Italian woman who lost against the men, too.
    1
  32. I'm a lefty and I'm not defending it. Stop putting us all into the same category. We are clearly not a hive mind.
    1
  33. "people are using the “eye test” to determine her gender": Nah, that's what your side is doing. The facts are that Kehlif is a bio-male and has been disqualified from previous competitions because he keeps failing the gender tests.
    1
  34. That's great. And hey! If teenage boys beat you, you can always compete with women and girls. :-)
    1
  35. "They need to remove all gender barriers in sports.": Then you should be really excited that weak men who can't compete with strong men are now competing with women. "why are there no trans men competing in mens sports": There are and they are doing okay. However, "transwomen" (males claiming they are female) are dominating every sport in the women's categories and are beating all of the decades long records. Trans people aren't exactly comparable in this sense.
    1
  36. Exactly. He is male.
    1
  37. "I think she might have Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS)": Maybe, but she still has unfair advantages simply by having XY chromosomes.
    1
  38. Well, now that we are including men in the women's categories, I think we have taken a few steps too far. Don't you agree?
    1
  39. "competitors are able to take testosterone": That's called doping and is illegal, because many athletes have died from doping incidents. Laws are written in blood.
    1
  40. Exactly. People who want him to compete with women are insane.
    1
  41. "maybe sports shouldn’t be a multibillion dollar industry. Maybe athletes shouldn’t earn more than teachers or farmers": (Male) athletes earn this much money, because people are willing to pay to see them play. Meanwhile no parents have to pay for their kids' school, because school is paid for by childfree people, who get nothing out of it.
    1
  42.  @trailersfromhell2539  Women's sports isn't a spectrum, though. It's for women only! That's why men like Kehlif are not allowed to compete with them. He was already banned from the world championships, because medical record proof that he is male.
    1
  43. There is no such thing as an "XY woman". He is a bio-male.
    1
  44. "while maintains the same chemical balance as a male" + "I cannot call any animal with XY chromosomes a biological female": Exactly. Thank you.
    1
  45. Exactly. he shouldn't be competing with women.
    1
  46. Exactly. Now domestic violence has become legal under the banner of "inclusivity".
    1
  47. Banda is also intersex and has hormonal and genetic advantages that women could never achieve naturally. So is Caster Semanya.
    1
  48. Science isn't bigotry. Your athlete is male by both chromosomes and hormone levels. He's already been disqualified from the world championship for failing his gender test. He should be competing against men.
    1
  49.  @northstar7459  "Boxing is divided by weight": Not true. they are also divided by sex and for good reasons. So are other combat sports. Letting this man compete with women is ludacris and will severely hurt female athletes.
    1
  50.  @notreal-duh  The hormone balance is base on chromosomes, so there is definitely an advantage for males (you know, the people with XY chromosomes) over females (XX).
    1
  51.  @sergioortiz8219  "and it's not gonna be fair for someone either way": Why wouldn't it be fair for him (a bio-male with XY chromosomes) to compete with other men? Have y'all lost your minds?
    1
  52.  @sergioortiz8219  Again: All you got is strawmen. I never claimed he was trans. He has male XY chromosomes and male hormone levels, which is why he is biologically male. He's not trans-anything, but he's not a woman either just because his genitals aren't the normal size and doctors couldn't see the chromosomes. "she's not fully equivalent to a biological man": Again: He's not a woman, either, because science say so and the people in charge of the world championship agree with the science..
    1
  53. Also Barbra Banda and others..
    1
  54. Exactly. Thanks you. The people screaming inclusivity just wanna hurt bio girls and women.
    1
  55. Women don't come with XY chromosomes and ingrown testes.
    1
  56. He is also a bio male competing with other men.
    1
  57.  @paulestrada2770  "U inspected her yourself": They don't have to. Kehlif has been banned from the world championship because he has been determined to be a bio-male, due to his XY chromosomes and excessively high levels of testosterone, that no woman could achieve.
    1
  58. It is now thanks to the "inclusivity" for everyone and everything in the women's category. All the men, who are too weak to compete with other males are now joining the women's categories.
    1
  59. Some athletes are men, who wanna compete in the women's categories.
    1
  60. Agreed. I'm so sick of men competing in women's sports, because they can't beat their male competition.
    1
  61.  @Robert-ms2xs  "There are women with XY chromosomes that have had kids.": Those aren't women, those are men. At best they are intersex and should not be competing with women.
    1
  62. She lost, because she was competing against a bio-male.
    1
  63. His natural advantage is that he is a man competing in women's sports.
    1
  64. Don't worry. Soon men will overtake women's sport, because they are physically stronger, faster and better in every way, because women's bodies were built around have kids.
    1
  65. Exactly. Kehlif also has XY chromosomes and ingrown testes.
    1
  66. It's called being an XY male in women's sports. No talent or hard work needed.
    1
  67.  @jessiejamesferruolo  Exactly. Thank you. I'm so sick of the people calling men in women's sports "female humans".
    1
  68.  @jessiejamesferruolo  No, you are spreading misinformation. Kehlif has XY chromosomes and excessively high levels of testosterone, which is why he has been banned from the world championship.
    1
  69.  @jessiejamesferruolo  " trans people who respect other people absolutely deserve respect back": Good thing we're not talking about a trans person then. Trans women are bio males, also and they shouldn't be competing with women.
    1
  70.  @jessiejamesferruolo  " I said "if" ": There is no "if". He's been tested multiple times and disqualified, because he is biologically male.
    1
  71. "she doesn't not have XY chromosomes": What a weird way to say he is biologically male.
    1
  72. Men shouldn't be competing in any women's sport. E-sports are fine, because there is no physical contact by the players.
    1
  73. "by the rulebook definition of "woman" this competitor is indeed a woman": He has XY chromosomes, excessively high levels of testosterone and has failed previous gender tests and therefore been banned from other competitions. He is not a woman.
    1
  74. Exactly. Thank you. I can't believe that the inclusivity people are destroying women's sports by going against science and then claim that people like you and me are the irrational ones. smh
    1
  75.  @Zelorp  "both competitors are female": The Algerian has XY chromosomes and high levels of T. He has been disqualified from previous competition for failing a sx / gender test.
    1
  76.  @mikearchibald744  "She just has more testosterone and has XY chromosomes.": Aka the signs of a man. At best (s)he is intersx and shouldn't be competing with women. Everyone is free to participate with men, but that would be much harder for him than just beating up women in less than a minute.
    1
  77.  @WishQuitting  "Why don’t women go to men’s boxing? Weird": Exactly. Very few people even know that in theory everyone is free to participate in men's sports. Women were never officially excluded, they just couldn't keep up with men. (Exceptions are when women's sports was banned.)
    1
  78. Exactly! Thank you for being one of the few reasonable ones in this comment section.
    1
  79. The reason we started dividing gender is because women wanted to compete but had zero chances against men. Now, thanks to "inclusivity" we are going backwards and men are competing with women in women's categories.
    1
  80. Why? He's a male athlete trying to make money by competing against women.
    1
  81.  @freedomliberty83  "I feel bad for Angela Carini": Exactly Me too. Her tournament is over, whereas the male will go on to compete against other female athletes.
    1
  82. That's because Kehlif is a man, whether you like it or not: He's got XY chromosomes, high levels of T and has previously been disqualified from other competitions such as the 2023 world cup.
    1
  83. That's great, but intersex people aren't female, so they should not be competing with women.
    1