General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Factchekka
WION
comments
Comments by "Factchekka" (@Factchekka) on "Taliban: Afghan women will be stoned to death for adultery | Latest News | WION" video.
Imagine being a young woman living your whole life knowing a degree of freedom and inclusion in society then literally overnight you have to live under this ridiculous medieval ideology. I feel so sorry for them.
15
@Jaekh-gf9wl What?
5
@@Jaekh-gf9wl Taliban bot in the conversation. 😒
4
@Jaekh-gf9wl You have probably never lived in a free society, that's why you have difficulty imagining what it is like.
4
@musfiqurrahmanarnab182 I don't understand your question. Who mentioned reparation?
4
@@Jaekh-gf9wl I wouldn't call them simpletons, but certainly backwards and barbaric, yes.
3
@Jaekh-gf9wl I never said I had a "solution". I don't think adultery is something that is anyone's business except the people involved. The authorities and legal system should stay out of peoples private lives.
3
@@Jaekh-gf9wl Who says she should be punished? She wouldn't seek the comfort of another man if everything was good in the marriage. Maybe the husband is an uncaring or abusive person or he can't function in a sexual capacity. Why should the woman have to be miserable in a marriage she doesn't want to be in? (Which is a good chance considering a lot of Muslims are in forced or arranged marriages).
3
@musfiqurrahmanarnab182 Who is spreading hate? I am expressing concern for the repressed women of Afghanistan.
3
@indiankid8601 I don't have a religion. 😉
2
@Jaekh-gf9wl Yeah, right! So many western women are applying for visas to go and live in Afghanistan, huh? 🙄
2
What's wrong with India? 😥
2
Jesus removed the behavioural trait of men having sex outside of their marriage did he? Where does it say that in the Bible?
2
@tamarackmi9195 I'm not sure that Jesus is forbidding stoning in that story but rather he is talking about being judgemental.
2
You have obviously never lived in a western country! 😂😂😂
1
@@Jaekh-gf9wl There is no "gotcha". Just because a woman is committing adultery doesn't mean she is getting pregnant from it. The scenario you are proposing is highly unlikely. Regardless, the idea that a person should be stoned to death for engaging in sexual activity outside of marriage is extreme and barbaric. What about the male participant in the adultery? What happens to him in your idealogical world? I also notice you are not addressing any of the other points I am raising in regards to the husband.
1
@@Jaekh-gf9wl Furthermore...yes, I do think if a woman is forced into a marriage (often as a teenager or even younger to a much older man) she should be able to do whatever she wants including cheating and getting pregnant to another man. Why should women have someone else choose what they do with their own life? Which again goes back to the Islamic idea that woman are the property of men and under their control.
1
@@Jaekh-gf9wl The only reason a man has to be responsible for all of it is because in Islamic countries like Afghanistan women have all their rights to work, study, run a business and be independent in every way stripped from them by archaic, backwards thinking men who think they have an inherent right to suppress women and make them subordinate to them.
1
@@Jaekh-gf9wl My reply to this was censored.
1
@@Jaekh-gf9wl Because he has forced her into a relationship for life she doesn't want to be in. Of course she will seek love and companionship elsewhere. You reap what you sow.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl You are going off topic. The discussion is about stoning women to death for committing adultery.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Because men have intentionally made it impossible for a woman to do that independently in their society.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Not everyone lives on a farm. What about all the women who were working or running businesses that have been told they can't do it any more? Men who enforce sharia know that the more rights women are allowed the less control they can maintain over them...that's why they do it.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl I've done the research for you. It took me about 30 seconds to find out that women make up almost 50% of the agricultural workforce in Afghanistan.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl I am very curious to know where you live to hold these views?
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Empires have come and gone throughout human history. This will not change. Of course, at some time in the future, the current power structures of geopolitics will change. What will not happen is people of western countries giving up their freedoms to live under sharia. There is a reason why migration is almost entirely one-way from third-world countries. They want the freedom, safety and prosperity that comes from living in a western liberal democracy. Do you see the world (even the Muslim world) rushing to get citizenship in Afghanistan?
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl I wasn't referring to Afghanistan. Afghanistan is not an empire. You asked me if the west will survive. So, it is safe to say you are Afghani. Are you actually proud your country and way of life has hardly progressed in thousands of years? 🤔
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Bacha Bazi will still be practised in 5000 years also. 😂😂😂
1
Jaekh-gf9wl Great! Afghanis will look back into the past and say "He was right...now bring me my dancing-boy!" 😂😂😂
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl I apologise if you were someones dancing-boy when you were younger...it must have been painful. 😳
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Nice try. Bacha Bazi is part of your tribal culture. Nothing to do with the West. We send people to prison for that kind of behaviour. Disgusting! 🤮
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl The Taliban banned it, but it is still practised because Afghan men like it too much to stop. 😆
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl This is all about you trying to justify killing women by throwing rocks at them.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Not my practice. I don't live in a mud house in the Afghan countryside.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Bacha Bazi was there before any western country invaded Aghanistan and is still there now. Old habits die hard.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Apparently not, that's why the Taliban has to threaten to stone women who commit adultery. Also, they claim this is sharia so I guess that means adultery was a problem in Muhammad's time too. Again, nothing to do with western countries.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl You don't even know the history of your own country...sad.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl If the problem of adultery left with the West, why does the Taliban feel the need to threaten women with stoning for committing it?
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl The punishment of stoning is sharia, so adultery must have been an issue while Muhammad was alive. Nothing to do with western countries.
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Oooh...The Taliban is coming to get me!👳♂️ I'm sooo scared! 😱
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Ooooh...I'm sooo scared! The Taliban are coming to get me! 😱
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl Where is it going?
1
Fairytales...🙄
1
🚀 👉 🕋 👉 💥 👉 🌍 👉 🙂
1
@Jaekh-gf9wl 😂😂😂
1
@tamarackmi9195 So you could say that Jesus was not actually against the practice of stoning because he didn't specifically say it was wrong.
1
@tamarackmi9195 Well, that idea hasn't even been taken up in the places where Jesus lived, let alone the rest of the world.
1
@caroll3309 That's not forbidding stoning, is it?
1
@caroll3309 It was more a case of being embarrassed because Jesus was writing their sins in the sand for the crowd to see.
1
@A.s.k008 Every society has accepted norms of behaviour, otherwise there is no cohesion and anarchy reigns. The societies in the world that have relative freedom are well known, as opposed to those that are restrictive and try to inhibit human rights with draconian laws. My country, Australia, is one of the countries where people enjoy relative freedom in their day to day lives. ❤🇦🇺❤
1