Comments by "Mikko Rantalainen" (@MikkoRantalainen) on "4.3 million people quit their job in August" video.

  1. 2
  2. 1
  3. 1
  4.  @herrschaftg35  I guess the total additional cost of UBI really depends on the existing benefit system. Here in Finland you can already get many different benefits even if you don't work already. I think the unemployment benefit + housing benefit already total around 800-1000 EUR/month. However, if you get even a low pay job, you'll totally lose the unemployment benefit immediately and it's better to stay at home instead of accepting such a job. With full UBI accepting any job would always increase your total income over continuing as unemployed. In countries where existing benefits are much worse, sure, changing directly to full UBI is too hard to step to take in many cases. As for actually implementing UBI, at least here in Finland, the politics has been too complex problem to solve this far. Some people seem to understand UBI as a replacement for unemployment benefit only and when they then assume that all those people still need the housing benefit plus random additional benefits, the system immediately gets too expensive. The whole point of UBI is that it should replace all existing benefits systems so if existing benefit systems have total budget of X EUR per year, that's the budget you can use for full UBI. Also note that here in Finland we have heavy progression in the income tax, too. In practice people with high income will fully pay the UBI back in form of income tax so it doesn't actually increase the costs for those people. The tax receipt would just show higher total income and higher tax and the actual usable income would be about the same as today.
    1