Comments by "Roger Scott Cathey" (@rogerscottcathey) on "You Will Be Shocked When You Realise Where the Big Bang Happened" video.

  1. Heat without atoms? Hot space eh? If a tree falls . . .
    4
  2. Absurd. Heat without atoms, they must vibrate these imaginary massless, "hot" subatomic particles, yes? So space has to exist. What heats them? Why are they all in zero space, if that makes any sense. They heat themselves then did they start out cold? What do you know that is cold that can suddenly explode? What made these particles? Are these proto particles mutually attractive or repulsive? What experiments yield understanding of how these non-atomic items behave? The fantasy of all this is patently absurd.
    1
  3.  @life_archive7840  : Sure, we can fantasize all kinds of things. Experiment eliminates them as having any possibility of reality, to say nothing of pure reason. Big bang, dark matter, dark energy are all ptolemaic stratagems in attempts to save a model and defunct paradigm.
    1
  4. What I wrote is what it is. Going down that road has yielded nothing but rewrites and regrouping. And rather than seeing the fruit of a fallow field is nothing and turning to a better, they try one patch after another.
    1