Comments by "Grubby bum" (@grubbybum3614) on "Monsieur Z" channel.

  1.  @norml.hugh-mann  Photosynthesis wouldn't break down. There'd be enough plant life in the southern hemisphere that goes unscathed, along with the Congo and Amazon.
    40
  2.  @ThatDragonGuy  Romantias, by Sophia McDougall
    24
  3.  @abyssstrider2547 . No, they'll just fight proxy wars like the previous 5 proxy wars between nuclear powers.
    13
  4. I think you all have it wrong. The greatest resource in Germania was manpower. Germans were taller and stronger than Romans. The greatest assets for Rome would be the legion's worth of soldiers picked from Germania every year, and sending them to other frontiers - making Rome even stronger.
    8
  5. 'This' is how you do an alternate history! Super laser focus on the "how" it happens, rather than spinning off into why the rest of the world changes.
    4
  6. Meh, this video doesn't understand the economic potential Germany had. Would have easily been the leading industrial power if it avoided WW1... Too much geography in this video. 6/10
    4
  7. If the Boers won, and became such a thorn in Britain's side, would Britain even declare war on Germany in WW1, knowing that the Boers could easily Annex Southern Africa? The real question.
    3
  8.  @Newbmann  a HRE which somehow managed to centralise power, and create organic patriotism, would be a very hard challenge.
    2
  9.  @EscanV  >No consequences How about the loss of Rhodesia and Botswana? The loss of safe access around the Cape?
    1
  10. One of your best videos so far.
    1
  11. But those things ARE an issue, you need to focus more on the HOW, or else your alternative history is weak as a sand castle.
    1
  12. You need to focus more on the "why" and "how", rather than "...then this happens". The steam vehicle invented to travel the roads is a very weak link.
    1
  13. These are better than the usual "what if Zimbabwe took over the world"-randomesque scenarios you usually do
    1
  14. I can't believe there's no "what if Spain joined the axis" video. There's like one, on the entire YouTube. And they could have helped win North Africa I think.
    1