Comments by "Bob" (@Bob-nd2mr) on "HistoryLegends" channel.

  1. The frontline means nothing if the Occupied Territories become active and targetted. Crimea and the whole of Eastern Ukraine has become hostile to Russian Occupation and will be so for ...ever.... Putin has re-opened a conflict that was active ever since the HOLODOMOR of 1932 - 1933. The ORC ARMY has been labeled as such and shelling CIVILIANS and executing and torturing POW's will never be forgiven or forgotten. Ukraine will not be suppressed by COERCION>>>>>those days are gone.
    3
  2. Even if your summary is correct and that the Ukrainians are losing, Russia is still "bleeding out". The Russian Federation must continue to send men and money to Ukraine to continue the conflict and for a total (and declining population) of 146 million this conflict spells the end of Russia as it was defined from 1991 - present. Poland, Czeck Republics , Romania, Finland, Sweden & Norway are prepared to take on any aggression so that just leaves Ukraine as a gaping wound. Russian Federation will "bleed out" or Putin dies. Is the end game. Ukrainians will not stop fighting for their homes & family. They will be OK in the long run but the Russians are facing a very troubled future unless someone can stop Putin. And soon.
    2
  3. Даже если ваш вывод верен и украинцы проигрывают, Россия все равно "кровоточит". Российская Федерация должна продолжать посылать людей и деньги в Украину для продолжения конфликта, и для всего (и сокращающегося населения) всего 146 миллион человек этот конфликт означает конец России, как она определялась с 1991 года по настоящее время. Польша, Чехия, Румыния, Финляндия, Швеция и Норвегия готовы противостоять любой агрессии, оставив Украину зияющей раной. Российская Федерация "истечет кровью" или Путин умрет. Это конец игры. Украинцы не перестанут бороться за свои дома и семьи. В долгосрочной перспективе у них все будет хорошо, но у русских очень неопределенное будущее, если кто-то не сможет остановить Путина.
    2
  4. I worked with Russians as a contractor in the oilfields in Northern Iraq. Better be paid upfront and be prepared to be their bitch and any contract is a joke. Only mad people work for Prighozin, dont even think about it. Putin is definietly going to be run out of Ukraine , just a matter of time.
    2
  5. Линия фронта ничего не значит, если оккупированные территории становятся активными и становятся целью. Крым и вся Восточная Украина стали враждебными российской оккупации и останутся таковыми навсегда... Путин возобновил конфликт, который был активен со времен ГОЛОДОМОРА 1932 - 1933 годов. АРМИЯ ОРЧ была никогда не будут прощены и забыты. Украина не будет подавлена ПРИНУЖДЕНИЕМ>>>>>те времена прошли.
    2
  6.  @AndRei-yc3ti  not true. even saudis need 40$ also no pipeline oil and shipped oil is minimal vol. so ...fecked
    2
  7. The invasion of Ukraine is indeed like June 1941 and even the propaganda of WW2 is similar but all mixed up in the now. The Ukrainians are waiting on Western advanced weapons "Wonder weapons" ...Wunder waffen of 1944.....thinking it will save them. BUT at the same time....In world politics ....the concept of a "war crime" and a "war criminal" will be made ridiculous if Putin goes Free of Charges. ??? The Democracies now have ample excuse to justify "war crimes" on their part (as when in 1941-45 Allies relentlessly carpet bombed German cities). If Putin gets away with it in Ukraine, then the gloves are off. (Like Hitlers invasion of Poland 1939). In 1945, It was the Democracies that invented and used the atomic bomb. But perhaps Putin took his chances at the right time. or did he ? because another recent developement is the ARISE OF CITIZEN ARMIES Check out : Long Shot by Azad Cudi ...certain defeat to final victory 2014, Kurdish victory against islamist (Orcs).
    2
  8. Путин отправляет зерно с оккупированных территорий в Россию, повторяя Голодомор 1932-33 годов. Нефть и газ для финансирования его войны, голод и запугивание для ведения войны. Президент США - дурак (если вы не заметили) и проиграет и в войне и на выборах, но ДЕМОКРАТИЯ всегда в итоге ПОБЕДИТ, и в долгосрочной перспективе.....(пока это "ЛЕГЕНДЫ" еще можно транслировать например). Гитлер пришел к власти, когда РАДИО впервые стало использоваться как средство массовой информации. Сначала люди верили радиопередачам Гитлера, но в конце концов ДЕМОКРАТИЯ победила, и РАДИО повернулось против него, когда ПРАВДА транслировалась... повсюду. ИНТЕРНЕТ ЗДЕСЬ. Путин плывет под водой против течения.
    2
  9. The retreat from Lysychansk and the efforts made to fight in Severodonetsk were countered by the Russians but the initiative shown by the Ukrainians getting out of this difficult situation, especially if it was initiated by the soldiers themselves as stated here on History Legends, proves to me that this war is being fought by Civilians who are fighting for their lives. The rigid and paid for Russians and their seperatist canon fodder will not last the Winter let alone 2.... where as the Ukrainians will fight for as long as it takes. with what ever it takes. to get their country back. Russian occupation seems as far off as ever.
    2
  10. Russian invading forces are pinned on the present front line with a very low chance of advancing. The whole of Eastern Ukraine is in a stalemate but that is playing to Ukraine's advantage. Germany has completed an incredible feat of Engineering and replaced all of Russian Gas with LNG and the Russian Oil price is holding at $60 or less which stops it being commercial. India and China encouraged to buy more and relieve demand on world oil but their storage is full as well. Discontent, Unemployment and Personal debt in Moscow and St Petersburg is spiralling out of control. The demonstrations in Tbilisi are bound to be repeated all over Russia this Summer. Putin and his regime and his invasion are going no where. This time next year all this may well be over as Social Unrest in Russia and a collapse in the Russian Army looks highly likely.
    2
  11. Вторжение в Украину действительно похоже на пропаганду 2-й мировой войны, но все перепутано..... После того, что произошло на Украине, у демократий теперь есть достаточно оправданий, чтобы оправдать «военные преступления» с их стороны. это случалось и раньше, когда в 1941-45 годах союзники неустанно бомбили немецкие города после того, как Гитлер бомбил наши. Если Путину это сойдет с рук на Украине, перчатки будут сняты. Именно демократии изобрели и использовали атомную бомбу в 1945 году. Научные исследования в демократических странах продвигаются с необычайной скоростью, и последствия того, как использовать квантовую физику, столь же экстраординарны, как изобретение атомной бомбы в 1945 году. Добро пожаловать в 21 век и прощание с мощью нефти и газа. Время идет... Россия застряла в прошлом
    1
  12. Байден избран. Талибы пользуются своим шансом и побеждают. Путин использует свой шанс и побеждает. Си Цзиньпин смотрит на это пока. Lame Stream Media делает вид, что Украина побеждает, а талибы в итоге в порядке. Но это все просто пропаганда или невежество, или и то, и другое. Украина проигрывает и не может победить без массивной поддержки со стороны Запада СЕЙЧАС. Рано или поздно Запад должен противостоять Путину. Лучше сейчас на востоке Украины и в Одессе.... чем позже. Невилл Чемберлен и Джо Байден, Чехословакия в 1938 году и гражданская война в Испании в 1936 году. приходит на ум.
    1
  13.  @mindbodyinstitute2652  No matter the actual war. Occupation in the 21st Century by an invader has not been possible. The Peshmerga in Northern Iraq is the model Citizen Army, using both men and women as soldiers and commanders. Read Long Shot by Azad Curdy. They threw off their invaders. And the internet and the Intel (that we are using right now) changed the outcome. Invasion & Occupation . Things of the past. And to live long enough to see Putin, Lavrov, Peskov, Dvornikov fail & fall ..... just like Saddam Hussein and the DA'ESH.
    1
  14. Украина победит, потому что Демократии сохранили поток оружия и боеприпасов ВО, и нет причин останавливаться. Однако поток оружия и боеприпасов, поступающих из России, сдерживается. Наступление и отступление — это то, как поглощается этот военный материал. Многие на Западе выиграют от увеличения продаж своего оружия и вооружений, но это не относится к России, которая будет все больше и больше приходить в упадок по мере того, как материалы отправляются на фронт. Сейчас люди гадают, какой будет эта «загнившая Россия». Военные лорды с ядерным оружием в отколовшихся республиках и массовое вторжение ханьских и монгольских торговцев с Востока, даже революция. ? . Россия, какой мы ее знаем, проиграла войну, но что получится, теперь большой вопрос???? 2024 г. и далее
    1
  15. seen him . also check out : youtube Russia's Catastrophic Oil & Gas Problem
    1
  16. The artillary and rockets can be countered. Israels Iron Dome , Soth Koreans' Air and Missile Defense (KAMD)and US and NATO technology is and will advance as Dvornikov adopts his 1 strategy of bombard and kettle. This new echnology now has the perfect testing ground. The game is on. DEMOCRACIES against BOMBARDMENT. We will win. Becaue "we" are the PEOPLE that the Dictators want to bombard. Bombing will not break us...History is my witness. SLAVA UKRAINI
    1
  17. I have followed History legend from february and his analysis has been correct in predicting many of the Russian moves. Death being dealt out in debatable proportions but the evil logic is that the Russians can withstand more losses than the Ukrainians because a lot of the Russians are used as cannon fodder. This neutralises the advantage of being a defender.
    1
  18. The pictures of the "amateur army" now being rounded up in Russia look terrible. Meanwhile, the Ukrainian motivation to push out the Russians has increased greatly over the first 8 months of this conflict. It will not decrease. Come January 2023 it will be 80 years since Stalingrad. ....a lot of lessons there about the Ukrainian weather (Volgograd..same city as Stalingrad... is same lattitude as Zaphorizhizhia). Attacks on the civilian population has rebounded on Putin . The British Army are watching their "students" . An ambitious teacher alwys enjoys seeing his studenst do better than himself ...
    1
  19. "Spotters" in the Peshmerga counter offensive (2014) against the hated DAESH (jihadists) were highly effective in that conflict. The Kurds won against all odds. All the way from Kobani to Raqqa. Like wise.....The Ukrainian counter offensive can rely on their Civilian population to combat Russian forces from the rear. A very painful and life changing experience they will find.
    1
  20. @Unknown Alien check out LONG SHOT by Azad Cudi and see what I mean about winning against the odds
    1
  21. 02:16 View of Hill 190 is for the album . And 03:17 the road running beneath it A land mark in this ongoing battle in Bakhmut.
    1
  22. The Russians are beginning to take note of POLITICS as they are rounded up and sent to Ukraine. Before they did not care but now the truth is dawning on them. Check out >>> 1420 Russia<<<<<<< brave kid interviewing random punters in Russia ...chilling and blek AF ... must be a better life ELSEWHERE surely ????
    1
  23. Курдское население на оккупированных территориях в своем контрнаступлении (2014 г.) против ненавистного ДАИШ (джихадистов) было очень эффективным в этом конфликте. Курды победили вопреки всему. Весь путь от Кобани до Ракки. Украинское контрнаступление может рассчитывать на свое гражданское население для борьбы с российскими войсками с тыла. Очень болезненный и изменяющий жизнь опыт. Мне сказали.
    1
  24. IF
    1
  25. No war or battle is ever the same but the Battle of Imphal and Kohima, when the British Indian Army defeated the Imperial Japanese Army and stopped the invasion of India in March to July 1944, is remarkably similar to the battles presently going on in Ukraine. General Slim fought a fighting retreat from Burma wearing down General Mutaguchi's invading army and lured him to a place called Imphal where the Japs were duly slaughtered and destroyed. The British Indian Army started WW2 with 200,000 men and in 1945 had 2.5 MILLION ...all volunteers. The biggest volunteer Army in History. "For Your Tomorrow We Gave Our Today".
    1
  26. What u write applies to both sides. The pictures of the "amateur army" being rounded up in Russia do not look promising. The Ukrainian motivation to push out the Russians has increased greatly over the first 8 months of this conflict. It will not decrease. Come January 2023 it will be 80 years since Stalingrad. ....a lot of lessons there about the Ukrainian weather (Volgograd..same city as Stalingrad... is same lattitude as Zaphorizhizhia(. Attacks on civilian population has rebounded on Putin The British Army are watching their "students" and an ambitious teacher likes to see his students do well
    1
  27. As this "Historian" states. The Fall of Mariupol is now in Wiki and "fixed". The internet has had weird effects on the course of this war. Surely Russia and Russians will increasingly come into the fold of internet and wikipedia etc..."connected"....countries ?? or it will fail. My reasoning is that having Free Speech increases the bulk VOLUME of DATA TRANSFER. Even in reading my littel missive >>>> you are taking in billions and billions of "qubitts" of information. Many brains linked together creates a vast neural net. Maximise data transfer through Free Speech and the future looks as weird as the History that preceeded it. A QUANTA REALM with massive amounts of data transfer. If Lavrov wants a tri polar world he will be dissapointed. The world is becoming QUANTUM . Carry on History Legends you are part of the war . Free Speech + Internet ? (Ref: Quantum Evolution by Johnjoe McFadden)
    1
  28. whotever historical similarities are drawn the fact is that this Ukrainian war is studied in detail that I have never seen before in History..? . The internet has changed the political situation and access to channels like YT and Telegram have helped to change the positions of China and India for example. Japan too. A lot hangs on the next move in Ukraine. Plenty people around the world are watching. Bullet or Ballot Box ? UN resolution European Council motion passed with only Guatemala, Syria and Belarus on the Russian side ? o missed one....NORTH KOREA.... with friends like this ? really ?
    1
  29. Артиллерии и ракетам можно противостоять. Израильский «Железный купол», противовоздушная и противоракетная оборона Южной Кореи (KAMD), а также технологии США и НАТО будут развиваться по мере того, как Дворников примет свою стратегию бомбардировок. Эта новая технология теперь имеет идеальный полигон для испытаний. Игра включена. Мы выиграем. Потому что «мы» — это НАРОД, которого диктаторы хотят бомбардировать. Бомбардировка нас не сломит... История тому свидетель. СЛАВА УКРАИНА
    1
  30. If Ukraine loses we all lose. An X on a piece of paper in a free & fair election is the worst of all Government systems ... except for all the rest.
    1
  31. both sides depend on trains ? in winter trains and railways seem easy to sabotage and put out of action. AFU would be more able to do this.... it is their counrty . Russians who want to stop all this can do it too ... STOP THE WAGONS
    1
  32. Article 2-4 United Nations All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any (member) state. Russia /Belarus attacking Ukraine (a sovereign member of the UN since 1991) is in direct contravention of this founding Article and justifies Western Democracies using their AIRPOWER to defend Ukraine...... a decision along these lines has to be made sooner or later or Ukraine will, sooner or later, be occupied by Russia. Just providing the UAF with guns is not working. In My Opinion
    1
  33. Если Украина проиграет, мы все проиграем. X на листе бумаги на свободных и честных выборах - худшая из всех государственных систем... кроме остальных. (Winston Churchill)
    1
  34.  @AndRei-yc3ti  The prediction is that nuclear war is about to start. Putin cannot lose. Ukrainians will not stop fighting for home & family. Good bye everyone. i am prepared. Russia is big but so is the sahara
    1
  35. UAF has survived because of their Fabian Strategy. The "Rope-a-Dope" strategy is what people have called the Fabian Strategy UAF have pulled off. Looks like Zalensky could actually remove RuF from Ukraine. Amazing ! War is always one thing ... unpredictable.
    1
  36. Democracy arrives in all kinds of ways. Because the Ukrainians have resisted Russian occupation with their Civilian Army then the Oil is being disrupted. The disruption that this war has created has stalled that flow but not the price. Oil @ $40 to 50 per bbl. would sink Putin. TRUMP had the price down to that. He knew all about Putins game but Biden can hardly find his way to the toilet. A puppet of some sort. Putin knows he has to sell Oil or Russia is over. Oil is their ONLY game. The rest is a mess.
    1
  37. Well done 1:26... seeing the Russian line weakness as long ago as 18 may.... south of Balaklia ..... respect. Heard that the foreign contractors will only fight out their contract in their present locations, in Luhansk for example, and will not move to any new posting as the say it is out of the scope of their contract ..... imagine they are splitting Putins money with the Ukrainians provided they go at present snails pace and give a bit of a show. They have Putin over a barrel. Why die for the fecker, just keep milking him like a cow
    1
  38. gettin famous fella . Slava Ukraini and Biji Kurdistan. 2014 Peshmerga won . 2023 Ukraine win. When men AND women fight they are protecting their families. The she bear is more dangerous than evn the Russian bear.....or Allah.
    1
  39. If this conflict runs into Winter 2022-23 and if this Summer is over hot. Then those battle lines look rough for the changing weather. Better jaw jaw than war war. A wise man once said, Depressing to see Flanders fields again. And after the First world War the Kaizer remarked "Well, I did not mean all that". If the Ukrainians can hold out surely some one in Russia will call it quits before it all gets dusty, then muddy, then freezing. Please God have mercy on all those soldiers who will surely perish on both sides. If they do not declare a cease fire and work to end this useless conflict. Slav against Slav
    1
  40. Putin is shipping grain from the Occupied Territories to Russia in a repeat of the HOLODOMOR of 1932-33. Oil & Gas to fund his war, Starvation & Intimidation to prosecute his war. The President of the USA is a fool (in case you have not noticed) and will be defeated in war and at the ballot box but DEMOCRACY will always WIN in the end, and over the long term ..... (as long as "History Legends" can still broadcast, for example). Hitler came into power when the RADIO was first used as mass communication. At first people believed Hitlers braodcasts but DEMOCRACY won in the end and the RADIO turned against him as the TRUTH was broadcast.... far and wide. The INTERNET cannot be undiscovered. Putin is swimming underwater against the tide.
    1
  41. This war is just beginning. You can take a break for as long as you like. Russians and Ukrainians are both brother Slavs and will be fighting just as fiercely this time next year. One side is small but determined the other is big but cannot be beaten. A generationsal war of Slav against Slav . I lived through the Troubles in ireland from 1969 - 99. After a while it just becomes normal.
    1
  42. Эта война только начинается. Вы можете сделать перерыв столько, сколько захотите. Война все еще будет там, когда вы вернетесь. Одна сторона маленькая, но никогда не сдастся. Другой большой, но не будет побежден. Это поколенческая война славян против славян. Я пережил Смуту в Ирландии с 1969 по 99 год. Через некоторое время это просто становится нормальным.
    1
  43. The Ukrainians are rotated between front line and training/leave and the margins are getting finer. Holding back the RuF and rotating troops is becoming harder as KIA reduces men available and combat effectiveness What a brutal feckin war. Ukrainians will never back down now. Too much blood.
    1
  44. Ukraine will win because the Democracies have maintained the IN flow of weapons and munitions and there is no reason to stop. However , the IN flow of weapons and munitions coming from Russia is being stemmed. Advances and Retreats are the way this war material is being absorbed. Many in the west will profit from the increased sale of their arms and weaponery but the same does not apply to Russia which will just get more and more run down as the material is shipped to the front. People are now speculating what this "run down Russia" will be like. Nuclear armed War Lords in break away Republics and massive incursion by Han and Mongolian Traders from the East even a Revolution . ? . Russia as we know it has lost the war but what will emerge is now the big question ???? 2024 onwards
    1
  45. noticed that too
    1
  46. PRIVATE ARMIES are a plague on Governments or anyone who is tempted to hire them. They are mercenaries. Its a business. The client is the one who pays the best and risks the least. Putin is losing. Prigozhin has made his money. Africa has often lured white men into the darkness in search of treasure. Check out: COLTAN MINNG , CONFLICT MINERALS & AFRICAN SLAVES Beware beware the bight of Benin , 1 comes out for 20 that go in.
    1
  47. You can easily equate Stalinism with Hitlerism. Adolf Hitler's fellow soldiers in the squad of runners in WW1 reported how Hitler followed the Russian Revolution avidly and he clearly copied the Soviets in everything he did. The Deutche Arbeiter Partie was the precursor of the Nazi Party, which was then called the National Socialist German Workers. Read Babi Yar by Anatoly Kuznetsov and you will never support TOTALITARIANISM again
    1
  48.  @CA-jz9bm  people vote with their feet. scorched earth is hot on the foot
    1
  49. No war or battle is ever the same but the Battle of Imphal and Kohima, when the British Indian Army defeated the Imperial Japanese Army and stopped the invasion of India in March to July 1944, is remarkably similar to the battles presently going on in Ukraine. General Slim fought a fighting retreat from Burma wearing down General Mutaguchi's invading army and lured him to a place called Imphal where the Japs were duly slaughtered and destroyed. The British Indian Army started WW2 with 200,000 men and in 1945 had 2.5 MILLION ...all volunteers. The biggest volunteer Army in History. "For Your Tomorrow We Gave Our Today".
    1
  50. The Centre on the Donetsk. Heard that the russian contractors in dispute with Putin on terms of contract ... specifically the deployment options. Looks like they do not want to go where told and certainly will not fight for no money. Problems brewing here I believe.
    1