Comments by "Steve Watson" (@stevewatson6839) on "Paulus HAD to take Stalingrad (he couldn't bypass it)" video.

  1.  @jpjpjp453  57 men? It almost looks as though someone didn't want the Nazis to win. :-) This op calls for Student, ALL the Fallschirmjaeger, ALL the Transportgeschwaden and AL the Italian equivalent . "A Genius for War" .... Yeah, right. ^-^
    2
  2.  @kevinbrown4073  He wouldn't be able to ask "But is that actually the case?" if it wasn't. :-)
    2
  3.  @TheImperatorKnight  That'll be grand when you publish it but in the mean time it is something folk can investigate for themselves in preparation. They might not get an answer, however it should result in better questions and even questions that it might not have occurred to them (or others?) to ask in the 1st place..
    1
  4.  @TheBrianp1  "...there are plenty of people who know their stuff... " You inadvertently put your finger on it. The pomo narrative would be rumbled by people "people who know their stuff" and the narrative is THE point of university education.
    1
  5.  @Morristown337  Air power v tanks is over-rated. Air power clocks infantry and supply. Without which you are done for, super tanks or no super tanks. I agree going beyond air cover is not a good idea; a similar thing happened to the Egyptian army when it it ventured beyond SAMs in '73. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. All the Nazi's had was a choice of poor options based off poor thinking.
    1
  6. And the Transportgeschwaden and Falschirmjaeger are doing what? Capturing refineries intact would seem obvious. It also seems an obvious use for airborne/air-lfted troops. It is also obvious what happens if you get bogged down in a city, obvious THE German problem was reality check, obvious to ask what happens if things go tits-up, obvious etc. Or not. The level of stupid on all sides in this conflict beggars belief. It beggared belief to me me even BEFORE I discovered your channel and your forensic autopsy revealing things were even more mired in stupid than I had thought.
    1
  7.  @konstantinkelekhsaev302  When 'red' became beautiful because Reds.
    1
  8.  @randomnepali7772  THIS IS SPARTAHHH!!!
    1
  9.  @kevinbrown4073  You don't say. :-)
    1
  10. He is Satan, didn't you know?
    1