Comments by "Rutvik" (@rutvikrs) on "" video.

 @BharatThatIsIndia this should apply to taxes too. Ambanis should get a bigger vote than a beggar. Don't incentivise failure
4
Now the constitution is the enemy 😂
3
What about Badaga in Tamil Nadu?
3
 @EriOliyanVaenthi so why can't you understand old Tamil? Why does it need to be taught separately?
2
Written script does not mean an older language. Modern Tamilians can't read Tamil from 110 years ago let alone a thousand year old script. If you could read it tou would complain of Pali imposition 😂
2
When was the last time you measured the volume of a cylinder or categorised an adverb/adjective? 😂
2
@sivaganesh2630 you have basically lied about benefitting from freight equalization, misled on the Chennai port investment made by the center. You can google each annual budget and see how many thousand crores has been invested. Sometimes I feel like TN should go through its own Brexit and watch itself dismantle like the UK economy.
1
@Zak-qh5tb I am a Kannadiga genius. English is killing Kannada more than Hindi.
1
@sivaganesh2630 these are talking points from the pre internet era 😭. Tokyo receives infrastructure not investment into locals which South already gets. Baltic states did not secede over taxes and the Scots don't think in terms of taxes. I will make the best case on your behalf, Brexit had a tax component. What happened next? Britain had to invest into standardization with the EU which took away it's business competitiveness. Even your best case scenario is a trainwreck.
1
@sivaganesh2630 as for California and East coast, tell me the name of the president they have and who these coastal elites vote and fund?
1
@sivaganesh2630 then what about Freight equalization policy, the Madras port recieving more than Kolkata port year on year since independence, Bangalore receiving more central institutions than any other city? The lowest ratio isn't south to north, it's west to east. There is a representative map on google images for each 100 rupees earned. The more developed the nation, worse the ratio.
1
@sivaganesh2630 the US constitutional system is based on historical conquest not equity. The feds can and have taken over states subjects. Imagine if India did that. Taking over state subjects. South Indias problem was always Chennai's brand of politics. When Nehru instituted a metropolis based system, Kolkata gathered influence to NE India, Mumbai fow west coast/Rajputana, and Delhi gathered it over Pepsu, Oudh and J&K. Only Chennai did not do it. They did not expand its politics, keeping themselves insulated within TN while congress(O) gathered influence across the southern states. Today descendants feel the lack of influence.
1
@sivaganesh2630 still stuck in the pre internet answers and now blatantly lying. Tamil Nadu benefited from Bihar, Jharkhand and Orissa's mineral wealth. TN's cement industries are a cost impossible without those inputs. It took away business from the steel cities of India while octroi applied on the rest of the items. Tell me this is untrue. Show me the limestone, lignite and iron mines of the scale in Tamil Nadu.
1
@sivaganesh2630 if this is true why was dredging happened every year at Chennai port funded by the center? Doesn't Chennai also have a river? Why was Kolkata port denied this? Why were Chennai and Mumbai porta propped up at the cost of historical ports in Bengal, Orissa and Kerala?
1
@sivaganesh2630 your point on Bangalore is not true, I am a native of that city. The center investment happened because of land and defence. West Bengal had way more colleges and talent and colleges back in the day. ISRO should have been in Western India because it's major influencer Homi Bhabha and Vikram Sarabhai were from Western India. It's your political that creates this category error.
1
@santhoshc86 give the option to remove native languages too then. What is the utility of reading 30 year old poetry and prose?
1
@sivaganesh2630 you are saying these things like MKU limited does not exist. 😂 The one company that exports to the US army isn't in Bengaluru, Hyderabad or Mumbai. It is in Kanpur, UP. Now tell me how many institutions exist in Kanpur. They outproduce all the engineering talent in optronics of India.
1
@sivaganesh2630 you don't invest where the talent is, you invest where the capital and urban concentrations are. The entire Gulf region is a glaring example. Urban concentrations naturally produce competency and talent due to competition. UP and BIhar are not the problem, even now you can google 100 rupees tax map on Google images and see how East India(entire NE, Bengal Orissa and Bihar) is a bigger net burden to west(MH, GJ, Goa). If anything India has not invested enough per capita on cities like Kanpur, Kharagpur, Kolakata and Patna.
1
@sivaganesh2630 you are intentionally answering the wrong question. No one is saying TN stole the resources, the question is were these states not allowed to earn taxes in the era of octroi? Open Google maps and see the scale of those mines it is less than 3-20 sqKms. While Orissa has ones as large as 150 SqKms. How did a steel sector come up in TN without steel mines? How did the cement sector become the 1L cr industry without a large source of raw material? The answer is by saving taxes.
1
@sivaganesh2630 MKU doesn't need propping up. The ancillary investment by the government is missing. Bangalore and Chennai recieved it by opening parallel sectors while Kanpur doesn't. All the defence establishments you mentioned predate the founding of MKU. This is exactly the point I made. Now that the defence corridor is being built and investment by center is happening, you complain about taxes.
1
@sivaganesh2630 I said era of octroi, not octroi on transport. Mineral rich states were exploited by the center and TN, MH and KA were the biggest benefactors of the policy. How does Tamil Nadu have all those reserves when they were a major exporter all these years? Efficient transport networks is a nice euphemism for nationalised railway costs. And now that the cost cycle has borne out and TN is paying for the nationalised costs, the RR brigade has started.
1
@sivaganesh2630 you are saying quarter and 500 does not happen in south India? Kolkata and Kanpur were robbed of its sectors due to FEI. They couldn't be cost competitive because they were paying for the logistics to port for each product. Now the region has started to get the investment it badly needs in UP. Bihar and WB will follow suit. If you can supply that stats as a list, you have access to data. Work the numbers and see which developed nation and the tax ratios for federal/central investments. You have lived in a bubble by not traveling and it will cost TN particularly very badly. Kerala, AP and Karnataka has people who are comfortable in Hindi and have pre established network while Tamilians are geographically challenged to think Bihar as North India.
1
@crm135 we? Do you mean your family has documents from 5k years ago?
1
@EriOliyanVaenthi you wouldn't be able to read Tamil from 120 years ago let alone Sangam literature. The Tamil spoken today is completely different.
1
 @chandu25abc20 and what happened to the countries who had that access? Aka SEA tigers? Remind us again? 😂
1
@madesh4509 you are too late. Basic structure is now a doctrine. Paraphrasing Ambedkar's statement in the constituent assembly "a unitary federation of destructible states."
1
@tejeswar and give Adani more votes
1
@Aalampara lol. Richer the state, more likely it votes for the BJP. GJ, MH, KA, HR.
1
Plus south India can geographically move to the Atlantic Ocean when we become part of the North Atlantic Treaty organisation. 💪
1
Because English as an elite language destroys your native language faster than Hinthi imposition. A child with parents(particularly ambitious mothers) in the service sector will grow up reading and speaking in English more than the local language while a Hindi speaking elite like a Marwadi/migrant doctor/IAS/IPS will teach their children the local language to ensure a better future.
1
What history has shown this division doesn't work? It's literally the norm in the developed world from the two coasts funding midwest and Tokyo paying the taxes for the entire country. 😂
1