Comments by "Андрей Борцов" (@Mentol_) on "The Underhanded Betrayal That Would Cost Hitler WW2 | Warlords: Hitler vs Stalin | Timeline" video.

  1. You know your history very poorly. You don't even know that there is a log of visits to Stalin's office which denies his confusion at the beginning of the war. You don't know that Stalin also made the right decisions in military sphere. You don't even know that the soviet human potential was only 80-90% more than the german one. I think you are troll who fight vs own history for no reason.
    4
  2. 125k is only dead and missing, and 300k is plus wounded. The Finns want to get their score in this war like 10: 1 to gain moral superiority.
    3
  3. You know nothing about Stalin except that your historical books (demonization) tell you.
    1
  4. Yes, you were mistaken, but YouTube deletes my messages.
    1
  5. Nikita Khrushchev created the myth that Stalin did not believe that Germany would start a war.
    1
  6.  Luqman Osman  Religion is used to manipulate people's minds. For this reason, Stalin fought against religion. For national culture, such a struggle gives great success. But because of their stereotypes, people believe that this is harmful to the culture and the nation. In fact, God supports the rejection of silly religious prejudices.
    1
  7. Show me Stalin's order to create hunger.
    1
  8. The number of 26 million includes civilian casualties and emigration.
    1
  9. Socialism is the answer to the crisis of capitalism.
    1
  10.  @vladoserfel  Firstly, your data is incorrect. Secondly, ideology does not kill anyone - people do it.
    1
  11.  @vladoserfel  After the collapse of socialism, you did not become part of a free society - you became part of a capitalist society that has its own propaganda machine. Capitalism does not need an economic competitor, so it creates myths that "communism killed 100 million people" and so on. If you believe in these myths (which are not based on documents), then you have become a victim of massive propaganda. But if you think that there is no propaganda in a capitalist society, then you have been deceived twice.
    1
  12. The first Soviet government: Vladimir Lenin - Russian. Alexey Rykov - Russian. Vladimir Milyutin - Russian. Alexander Shlyapnikov - Russian. Vladimir Ovsienko - Ukrainian. Nikolay Krylenko - Ukrainian. Pavel Dybenko - Ukrainian. Victor Nogin - Russian. Anatoly Lunacharsky - Russian. Ivan Skvortsov - Russian. Georgy Oppokov - Russian. Ivan Teodorovich - Polish. Nikolay Vavilov - Russian. Iosif Stalin - Georgian. Leon Trotsky - Jew.
    1
  13. Putin (not historian) says the false information that was created by the right-wing Russian emigration after the civil war. They searched for the cause of their defeat and created the myth of the Jewish conspiracy to get a moral justification. But this information is not documented. This is a conspiracy theory.
    1
  14. The only thing that unites Bolshevism and Nazism (fascism) is radicalism. Otherwise, these are diametrically opposite systems: the ideology of universal equality of people against the ideas of national exclusivity; materialism versus idealism; collegial leadership against authoritarianism; the idea of the gradual withering away of the state against the idea of "the state above all else", and so on.
    1
  15. luke m > Barbarossa is colonisation of USSR. > Its started to protect women from bolsheviks. Are you idiot. Right-wing zombie.
    1
  16. Aggression is aggression.
    1
  17. 1. The operation of barbarossa was not defensive of Europe, but the colonization of the USSR. Agressive war. 2. There was a civil war in Russia. The White Army is a supporter of conservative values ​​(this is not skin color). The Red Army is a supporter of the revolution.
    1
  18. Read the Joseph Goebbels diary. It shows Hitler's attitude to Christianity.
    1
  19. Not. Germany attacked the USSR to deprive Britain of any hope of victory in war. Continental strategy.
    1
  20. Socialism is the answer to the crisis of capitalism. You cannot eradicate it while capitalism exists.
    1
  21. > Christians were persecuted and allot of them were executed. In the USSR, people were repressed by class logic, rather than religious. Stop repeating propaganda.
    1
  22. You do not know anything about inner life in the USSR. Just grab and study the books of Lenin and Stalin. This will give you the key.
    1
  23. You are an ignorant person who reads religious propaganda and does not want to learn the basic facts of history.
    1
  24. If you need to understand Stalin - you just take his work and read. You do not need to read religious propaganda about Christianity and other nonsense because it has nothing to do with Stalin. This is an element of primitive demonization against a strong leader.
    1
  25. Over the entire Soviet period, about 800 thousand people were sentenced to death. Famine is not intentional killing. Soviet camps also not killing Therefore, you cannot get millions of people killed by Stalin.
    1
  26. You are repeating propaganda.
    1
  27. Suvorov is not historian.
    1
  28. This is fake quote.
    1
  29. Stalin's activities are not limited to killing people. He made the USSR a great industrial power.
    1
  30. The Germans advanced so far east because their army had a new method of breaking through the front. Stalin's personality has nothing to do with this.
    1
  31. 1. The USSR did not invade Poland because Poland did not exist. 2. No one financed the revolution in Russia. Stop believing in conspiracy theory.
    1
  32. 1. Если человек путает цветные революции с настоящими, то это его проблемы. 2. Российская оппозиция проехала по Германии в обмен на интернированных из России немцев.
    1
  33. Противоречия нет - революция (социальные изменения) могут происходить в результате переворота.
    1
  34. Ленин публично отказался от сотрудничества с Парвусом. Давно известный факт.
    1
  35. 1. Ваша ошибка в том что вы постоянно пытаетесь проецировать современную политику на 1917 год. Принцип историзма нарушен. В то время не было такого понятия как цветная революция. 2. После февральской революции новая власть в России разрешила всей политической оппозиции вернуться на родину. Ленин искал способ как это сделать т.к. союзники запретили проходить по их территории. Оставался вариант с Германией и для этого он использовал свое влияние на швейцарскую социал-демократию и те договорились с Германией что они пропустят поезд в обмен на немцев интернированных из России.
    1
  36. В научном сообществе факт отсутствия сотрудничества Ленина с Германией давно установлен. Обратное пытаются доказать либо конспирологи, либо ангажированные публицисты типо Старикова. Если бы вы понимали масштаб октябрьской революции которая изменила жизнь не только в России, но и в мире, то никогда бы не сказали такой глупости мол революцию можно оплатить. И Ленин нигде не декларировал что он возвращается в Россию чтобы "устранить восточный фронт". Он выступал за мир без аннексий и контрибуций для всех сторон.
    1
  37. Дискуссия возможна только по вопросам где истина еще не установлена. В случае с Лениным все давно известно. Публицисты спекулируют на этой теме опираясь на современные охранительские идеи, мол любая внесистемная оппозиция это агенты запада и враги России.
    1
  38. USSR returned what Romania took from Russia in 1918.
    1
  39. Despite the division of Poland, the USSR declared its neutrality in 1939.
    1
  40.  @mrobserver474  I mean world war neutrality. Because a world war is a coalition conflict. The USSR did not join any of the coalitions in 1939 and its operations in Poland were bilateral.
    1
  41. 1. The losses you name are wrong. Soviet losses are estimated from Russian sources, not Finnish Wikipedia. 2. The Soviet government feared military intervention in the winter war of England and France. For this reason, a peace treaty was concluded. This has nothing to do with Soviet losses. In addition, if you count not the total number of losses, but their number in relation to the population, it turns out that the Finns have lost more soldiers. Thus, the conclusion of peace on their part was more logical.
    1
  42. You have repeated an old myth. Stalin knew already in mid-June 1941 that war was inevitable. He also had experience of the Russian Civil War.
    1
  43. Show me a soviet documents that has this purpose.
    1
  44.  @asir77777  Write here the name of the Soviet document that has the goal of exterminating the German nation and I will check the Russian original.
    1
  45.  @asir77777  If you do not have the original Soviet documents (individual excesses cannot be extrapolated to the entire army), where do you get your information from? Where do you get your stats from? The fact is that in April 1944 the German propaganda minister Goebbels ordered the creation of a virtual image of a Red Army soldier who had no morality and who wanted to destroy the German nation. For some unknown reason, you repeat this old propaganda as a neutral opinion.
    1
  46.  @asir77777  Это ссылка на нацистскую газету. То есть пропаганда. Какое отношение она имеет к ркка? Цитируйте советские документы (название, дата, автор). А если у вас доказательств нет, то извинитесь за дезинформацию и ведение информационной войны против собственной истории.
    1
  47.  @asir77777  ютуб блокирует адрес электронной почты как спам. Я уже писал, но он удалил сообщение. Тебе проще написать название самого документа (а также автора и дату) или название сборника документов где ты его взял и страницу, а я уже проверю. Хотя если ты с серьезным лицом цитируешь немецкую пропаганду, то ничего адекватного ждать не стоит.
    1
  48. I don't think you even know what evil is.
    1
  49. Find any information about the secret protocol between Britain and Poland.
    1
  50. In the secret protocol there is information that the Allies will help Poland only in the event of aggression from Germany. This treaty does not affect the USSR.
    1
  51. The only thing that unites Bolshevism and Nazism (fascism) is radicalism. Otherwise, these are diametrically opposite systems: the ideology of universal equality of people against the ideas of national exclusivity; materialism versus idealism; collegial leadership against authoritarianism; the idea of the gradual withering away of the state against the idea of "the state above all else", and so on.
    1