Comments by "Андрей Борцов" (@Mentol_) on "Estonian War of Independence animated" video.

Here is a brief list of the achievements of the two revolutions of 1917: - The peasants were given more land. - The working day is reduced from 10.5 hours to 8 hours. - Improvement of the health care system. - The policy of eliminating illiteracy of the population. - Equality of men and women is presented. - Elimination of class privileges. - Separation of church from state. - Cessation of economic exploitation of man by man.
1
@RutakoVon Plague = propaganda. You don't respect people if you use propaganda as an argument. - Stalin, May 4, 1935: “We must finally understand that of all the valuable capital available in the world, the most valuable and decisive capital are people, cadres. We must understand that under our current conditions, cadres decide everything. If we have good and numerous cadres in industry, agriculture, transport, and the army, our country will be invincible. If we do not have such personnel, we will limp on both legs". - The reason for the famine in 1933 was the exaggerated seizure of grain for export sale. Is industrialization meaningless? Hitler's fate will give you the answer. Of course, when the scale of the tragedy became apparent, grain exports were reduced and assistance was provided to the affected regions. - After the collapse of socialism in Europe, local nationalists rewrote history and said that in the socialist system people have no incentive to work. But this is just a projection of capitalism. - Members of the Bolshevik Party had many times fewer privileges than rich people in capitalist countries today. - Land in the 1930s was collectively owned, not state owned. - Human culture has progressive and regressive forms. Religion is a regressive form because it makes a person believe in a good life after death instead of making it so in real life. Fighting religion means improving critical thinking in society - popularizing the scientific worldview instead of idealism. - There are many documented cases when ordinary people in the USSR wrote letters to Stalin personally (including criticism) and he answered some. Today, the presidents of capitalist countries will rarely respond to letters from people because they position themselves as businessmen and not as comrades.
1
Full sovereignty contains the following factors: military, economic, political, ideological, worldview. How many of these Estonia had?
1
Cite a document in which the USSR is an ally of Germany. If this does not exist, then apologize.
1
You don’t know anything about real Russians.
1
In the first Soviet government there are 72 people. Of these: Slavs (Russian, Byelorussians, Ukrainians) - 48 (67%), Jews - 8 (11%), Poles - 5 (7%), plus 3 Latvians, 2 Germans, 2 Armenians, 2 Georgians, 1 Ossetian and 1 - not defined. National composition of the Red Army (1920). Russians - 79%, Ukrainians 5%, Tatars - 3.39%, Belarusians 2.19%. National composition of the Cheka. 77.3% of Russians, 9.1% of Jews, 3.5% of Latvians, 3.1% of Ukrainians, 0.5% of Belarusians, 0.5% of Muslims, 0.2% of Armenians, 0.1% of Georgians. The Chekist International was supplemented by 315 Germans, 46 Finns, 25 Czechs, 13 Chinese, 3 Swedes, 2 Englishmen and a Frenchman.
1
@Jake Johansson 1. In 1917 the Red Army had not yet been created - there was a Red Guard and its strength was about 410 thousand people. Of these, there were 25 thousand ethnic Latvians (6% of the total number). 2. The Politburo and the Council of People's Commissars are parallel organizations. In the Politburo, according to statistics, over the entire period of its existence, 70% of the Russians were. It looks like you were misled by information from the right-wing Russian emigration who believed that the majority in the Soviet government were non-Russians. But their information is not reliable.
1
@Jake Johansson ну ты ведь понимаешь по русски поэтому на нем и отвечу. В моем первом комменте указана статистика учитывающая политбюро и совнарком вместе в ленинский период. Во вторых численность красной гвардии 410 тыс дана на всей территории страны, а не только в петрограде.
1
@Jake Johansson It was a socialist revolution, not a nationalist one. It does not matter what nationality the people who made decisions of state importance had. People are guided by beliefs, not nationality.
1
Свобода означает политическую, военную, экономическую, идеологическую и мировоззренческую самостоятельность. Что из этого имеет Эстония? Является ли она независимой от США и Евросоюза?
1