General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Bill B
Richard J Murphy
comments
Comments by "Bill B" (@billB101) on "Energy price rises are due to regulation that favours companies, not people" video.
@stevereilly It's her legacy, you can't look at the future without understanding the mistakes of the past.
9
@SlowhandGreg Sure, batteries. We're talking about the whole of the UK here, domestic, commercial and industrial. You're going to need one hell of a lot of plug and play batteries for that to be an efficient and scalable backup system. I mean, you do realise how much oil and gas we burn per day to keep the lights on or the sheer scale of the problem here?
4
How exactly do you nationlise our energy supply, how much would that cost? It's not about being brave it's about reality.
3
@Neokretai I watched that a while back and honestly I think it's nonsense when compared to energy, the bill for buying back our energy from companies like EDF would be absolutely enormous if indeed they wanted to sell in the first place (and why would they we're literally picking up the tab for their energy subsidies ) This not post WW2, there's not the sentiment for this. And then there's the blowback if it fails and our economy tanks. Saying it is one thing, doing it is entirely different.
3
If you have a pension then you are one of the shareholders.
2
@SlowhandGreg I didn't mention the cost, I mentioned the scale.
2
@SlowhandGreg There isn’t a mass storage solution anywhere near scalable enough to balance a 100% renewable grid in the UK.
2
@robertdewar1752 My point is that we don't have a net zero grid, and we're nowhere near having one because there isn't a mass storage scalable enough to balance a 100% renewable grid in the UK.
2
@Neokretai You do realise that what Murphy is saying is just an idea. It's not something that's ever guaranteed to work and hasn't been costed properly . I swear the disciples on this channel.
1
@Neokretai It is just an idea. We don't live in the 1940's either, the world has massively moved on. What worked then is not going to work now.
1
@lestrem11 It is, the Tories saw to that, along with people who voted for Brexit. Labour are picking up the pieces. I mean, you do know this right?
1
@lestrem11 Because it's not something that can be instantly or easily fixed. What exactly has he made worse that wasn't a mess already?
1
So how exactly do you nationalise the whole of the UK energy supply and what would that actually cost to the taxpayer. Let's see some actually accounting figures here. Easy to talk about, not so easy to implement.
1
@SlowhandGreg What kind of mass storage?
1
Ironically the largest electricity generation company in the UK is owned by the French ( EDF ) who use us to subsidise their energy cost. Go figure eh.
1
Ironical our biggest electricity generator is own by the French ( EDF ) who use us to subsidise their energy costs. Go figure eh.
1
@robertdewar1752 Well sure, if we had fusion that'd be nice too, but we don't.
1
@SlowhandGreg That's one hell of a lot of batteries you're going to need there.
1
@SlowhandGreg You're going to need one hell of a lot of batteries here.
1
@SlowhandGreg Lol. I know how the grid works bud.
1