Comments by "seneca983" (@seneca983) on "How JLOTS Won't Work in Gaza, but the Sons of Palestine Might" video.

@AyamanAmusic "the hard pushback of the people in Israel by the notion that you don't feed your enemy" I think starving the enemy population probably amounts to a war crime.
13
@AyamanAmusic "Do you wanna start to count the war crimes that Hamas did?" It's certainly more than 0 but that hardly means that preventing food shipments from coming in wouldn't also be a war crime. "And what are the rights of terrorists groups by those war rules?" I'm not sure about the terrorist groups themselves but you need to remember that the enemy civilian population does have rights under the laws of war, even if they support the aforementioned terrorist groups.
10
@CedarHunt Where would they all go? What country would receive them?
4
"there can't be an autonomous gaza" What's the alternative? Israel permanently annexing Gaza? That would seem rather problematic because it would bring about 2 million Arab Muslims into Israel proper. Israel might deny them citizenship rights and only give them the right to reside in the area of the (former) Gaza Strip and maybe some other restricted parts of Israel but I think that would be hard to sustain in the long term. It would probably carry enough risk of a significant demographic shift in Israel in the long term to make many Israelis uneasy with it (even though it wouldn't be enough to make Jews a minority).
3
@CedarHunt What about the current Gazan population?
2
@thinguyetpham6661 I can't think of a single country that would be ready to receive 2 million Gazans.
2
@lurmieei So the UAE would be in control of the Gaza Strip and not Israel? That sounds a bit far fetched. In any case, your "followed by autonomous rule" would contradict OP's statement that autonomous Gaza Strip wouldn't be acceptable.
2
@CedarHunt Is your plan making those Israeli families live among them? Would that really work?
1