General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
AlQaisar القيصر
The Ezra Klein Show
comments
Comments by "AlQaisar القيصر" (@hishamalaker491) on "The Ezra Klein Show" channel.
Previous
1
Next
...
All
Well one is being pushed into oblivion (Palestinians) and the other is scared of being pushed into oblivion (I guess Israelis).
2
@maltija1 No We are not. I am Palestinian-Syrian mix (Pal Father and Syrian mother) and my Palestinian side is fully Palestinian and from Nablus, my grandpa literally resembles the Samaritans and despite my father being religious, proudly Arab and a bit anti-semitic he acknowledges that we are Jews of the past in Palestine who converted and arabized. We know we used to be Samaritans (likely) or other Jews and even before them the cannanites. We are not foreigners to the land as we had been there for millenias even before the 7th century there had been Arabs moving in and out of Palestine and even before hand many Kingdoms like the Nabateans controlled much of the negev and the South and also the Midianites, Amalekites and other tribes that the Israelites fought are likely all Arabs of the past in the sense that they were arabized since all Arabs are arabized even those in Saudi.
1
@maltija1 You know much of what you said is BS, but propose that a few families in said village came from northern Iraq to Palestine 500 years ago, why should they be expelled now? Is 500 years not enough? I mean the Americans had been there for less than that and they are considered natives of the place now, would it also be moral to kick out 100's of millions of Americans outside the North American continent? Even though the reality is that most people had been there fore centuries upon centuries by now and saying that the land only belongs to Jews because your god which 1/3rd of your population doesent believe in said so is kinda BS as well. Now did some people move for trade or commerce to Palestine? Well given that the entire middle east was under one big empire and they were all Arabs yes, Many Palestinians went to the Syrian coast for work or settlement, some Egyptians moved to Damscus or Aleppo and vice versa for oppurtunities its like the US. How many millions of Americans native to certain states move to other states? yet still this movement of people due them all being in one big continious empire did occur however it did not compromise or change the population natavity to the area also you have to take in account to some people being mixed like from my Palestiniana side they are all Palestinians albeit from slighly diffrent cities or areas in palestine though one of the generations mixed with a Syrian other than that they are all from palestine and there is no strong case for absoloute expulsion at all.
1
Part of Historic Palestine and the proposed Arab state?
1
@guitarsandbongos What kind of sh*tty soverignty are we talking? The one where there is no military? Where we give all of jerusalem? The one where we are dependent on the zionists as some sort of dog protecting them from resistance militias? Its BS all of it and it has been hijacked by netanyahu and other goverment members many times over.
1
Previous
1
Next
...
All