Comments by "AlQaisar القيصر" (@hishamalaker491) on "Jabzy" channel.

As an Arab, gotta say your being too nice to us the problem is with our mentality the only thing that had actually unified us is Islam (look at history, countless times we were only united under the banner of religion) hence why the caliphate is the only solution for the Arab world at least now about Christians well historically there were alright in the caliphate, operating as merchants and even scholars since they were of the civilized portions of the middle east back in 7th century and them being a minority mostly in cities meant they would be great catalysts for the economy and jews as well however the only must is tax, the jiziyah tax imposed on those who can pay (excluding women, children and elderly) and those who cant pay as in men who are poor or sick wouldnt. This to some parallels the zakat tax imposed on muslims also the caliph can at will impose more taxes on Muslims and christians alike (I am talking about taxes that arent Jiziyah or Zakat related). My Jordanian Arab friend is christian and his family had been for (statistically) a millenia living side by side with Muslims and the way he acts, dresses, even talks its all Arab but more specifically Jordanian I couldnt differentiate him from the other 99% Jordanian Muslims Ironically I would relate to him as a Arab Muslim more than a circassian Jordanian Muslim or a Syrian Kurd in terms of ethnicity since to me religion is most important thing and ethnicity comes number two not sayng it isnt important, it is but religion is more important. Hope my point is clear.
84
Except that Brooklyn is a place within a city while Palestine is a name for a whole region, sure they werent Palestinians and I as a Palestinian can say that but they were Arabs that made 90% of the regions population thats just the Muslims btw with the christian arabs its 95% or more, the problem is excess migration from European Jews who monopolized the economy and werent even in favour of the Belfourd declaration that had promised Local Arabs rights, the zionists wanted to kick us out that was their intention they didnt care who would help them do it be it the Kaiser, The crown or even the Sultan. Also the Jews themselfs are by technicality also colonizers do you really think they are the first inhabitants? Didnt they talk the land from cannanites according to your bible and historical records? Also so what if they had the land 2000 years ago. The Romans conquered England and lightly settled it centuries before the Anglo-Saxons and Scandinavians (who make up the majority of the english population) ever came in that doesent mean that a Italian whom ancestors took the region can just go back to england claim they have been here before and kick out the local english.
6
@SethTheOrigin It sucked but where didnt it suck? Syria sucked as well so did the Balkans that doesent mean you cann transform the demographics and create a colony at the expense of the locals. There was even a Plan for a Jewish state in Albania. The zionists were merciless they didnt care be it Palestine or Albania or even Kenya they were going to get their ''homeland'' even if it was at the expense of someone else didnt the nazis want to depopulate Eastern Europe and settle it with German? Isnt zionism just a Jewish version of Lebensraum?
5
12:27 That one slave for some f*cking reason: NO 🗿🤫🧏🏻‍♂
4
i know that they suffered from ww2 but you dont have to give them a already inhabited land and displace the local population like what was done with palestinians after ww2.
2
@gnarlantlers70 Because Cannanite as a concept well mostly as a ethnicity that includes language and culure just doesent exist anymore the people got assimilated thats a normal thing just like Many Turks especially in western Anatolia are actually assimilated Greeks and minority Assimilated Slavs they cant just go speak Greek now can they? They have offically assimilated into a different culture with a identity for centuries in the Palestinians case its been Millenials since the Cannanites stopped being a thing and also Palestinians are mix Jewish-cannanites I am Palestinian Arab with some Jewish ancestors me and most Palestinians have some Jewish ancestry which makes sense.
2
you dont even speak coptic.
2
so glad the abyssians were not displaced after all, i am not saying i dont want them (Gypsies) to have a land for them i do i just dont want to see Palestinians 2.0 (Abyssians) or maybe even (Egyptians) i mean dont they know that these lands are already inabited.
2
This is unrelated if your talking about current migration but generally yeah you can see how diversity in the middle east is/isnt a strength, it was a great strength during the umayyad, Abbasid and Ottoman caliphates but was a weakness when nationalism became a thing.
2
even if they did, displacement a local population is still not good unless it was natural/peaceful assimilation sure but a violent one like with what Zionists did is not cool.
1
As a Palestinian well youre wrong just because jews lived in Palestine a millenia ago and were eventually assimilated and also they flee the lands when they were under the hands of the Romans but when the arabs came they assimilated with them by accepting Islam, learning arabic, intermarrying arab settlers and traders and also migrating to the rest of the empire then a Millenia later you would see far-right Zionist Militais destroying entire villages and you would see that the jewish re-assimilation wasnt to peaceful as they had fought wars both defensive and offensive and there were anual raids by far-right zionist milita's as well as unfair treatment and apartheid? damn i thought South Africa was the last, guess I am wrong.
1
just out of the blue? no reason? at all, we arabs are just rtards to hate the mighty glorious free westerner. right?
1
@gnarlantlers70 Not really the Arabs arent really colonizers well they were but not in the technical sense of kicking people out and settling themselfs only which they never really did and ''Palestinians'' like me have Mixed heritage which includes cannanite and Jewish no kidding I actually have Jewish ancestry and also how do the light skinned European jews, Dark skinned Mizahri Jews and Black Ethiopian jews all share common ancestry in Palestine also many Jews in Europe are of Khazar convert origins and many had actually mixed in. No sending them to Arabia wouldnt be fair play at all would it be fair to send the Turks to central Asia? Or the English back to Germany for the Celts to take it? Or the 200m + white Americans to go away and give the land to the natives? What if we just deport all white South Africans now is that fair play? The average Palestinian barely has any ''Arabian'' DNA and the truth is that Arabs were never a genome they are just semites of Nomadic origin and being a Arab is about Language, culture and shared georaphical boundaries I am a light skinned (white looking) Palestinian-Syrian (Levantine) Arab and I am just as Arab as a Black or dark skinned Sudanese see. Its not DNA that binds us but shared culture and language and possibly religion though even with Christian Arabs from Syria and Jordan share many commanlities with us same culture and language Its like they are not even different with an exception to religion. What If I told you that many Slavs near the Adriatic are of Illyrian origin or that many Germans in Eastern Germany and even in Bavaria have Slavic origin see? Many English people are of celtic origin but most retain Anglo-Saxon and Scandinavian Germanic origin. See how at times the language and culture is what shapes said ethnicity instead of DNA Also settlement had pretty much shaped history its a never ending human phenomenon for us to move and settle but the way zionists did it wasnt very moral and again with the Arabs they assimilated the people in a process which took centuries where the Arabic culture and language became established in the Levant, Egypt and Iraq.
1
@yaldabaoth2 A thousand years ago, werent the west massacring jews every now and then? lets go deeper 2000 years, the roman empire with its genocides against Germanic and celtic people.
1
@CantHandleThisCanYa yes we are radicalized against you, because we just so happen to hate the American invasion of Iraq, their support for I*rael, their involvement in Syria and their overthrowing of Libya.
1