General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Maria F.
Anders Puck Nielsen
comments

Comments by "Maria F." (@mariaf.6601) on "Bad assumptions and the belief in Russian victory" video.

...but Afghanistan happens (we're talking Soviet Union, to be exact)
6
What are you going to do ?
5
What's your experience , please?
5
@chrishoff402 When did they vote ? I haven't heard about that.
5
It cannot be true it mustn't be true Because Russia will have to win? Anders 1 : 0 getreal155
4
@getreal155 To say one-sided would be an understatement .
4
@getreal155 I wasn't sure whether it was the case when Poe's law applied, was it to be meant as sarcasm ...
4
@getreal155 What questions were you about to ask ?
4
Do you know at all what Nazi means?
4
@chrishoff402 OK, thank you, So we can see S.Bandera wasn't Nazi, although you use the terms out of their historical meaning (to your convenience? because now I don't know what you mean by 'socialism'), Anyway, I think you cannot mantain that "Anyone in the west who stands with Ukraine supports Nazis".
4
@chrishoff402 You put everybody in Ukraine into one basket - isn't it kind of racist? What is the basis of your claim ? Have you been to Ukraine and anybody tried to recruit you ? To what exactly?
4
@chrishoff402 Have you got any data to support the opinion ?
4
@chrishoff402 Please, let's be serious, "voting" in time and area of war in presence of special / secret service of RF ... Why the citizens of RF haven't been asked to vote about it ?
4
What's your opinion on voting eg in North Korea ?
4
@chrishoff402 Russian hasn't been banned, please double check.
4
In many countries there are different languages and/or various nationalities , this fact only is no indicator that eg English speaking persons would belong to England ? Great Britain? United Kingdom ?
4
Joann 0 : 1 Anders . 😄
4
If you said "No, Kharkiv, Kherson, Kiyv"... but, wait, 🙄
4
True 😀
4
@vbite2685 I understand if you cross the boarder with forces that less numerous than the force of the defensor, you count for a walk (easy and quick victory), not fight (then you'd need 2:1 , or even more advantage, according to the military doctrine of RF)
4
@vbite2685 The other one, I think all 3 of us speak about the same, more or less Russia like Ukraine ofcourse have more servicemen, but cannot deploy them to the front of fighting: policemen have to in their cities/towns/oblast, board guard - at the boarders, also of friendly EU countries, 24/7, some soldiers at the boarders of BY or Transnistria, although there's no fighting there. The same for RF (conscripts are excluded)
4
@vbite2685 Territorial gains are not all - yes, an example of Germany that took great defeat in the outcome of Grand War fighting all the time on the territory of France.
4
Poe's law applies 🤕
4
I think Anders believes it is possible (or probable, as things are going)
3
@chrishoff402 1. Russian language hasn't been banned in Ukraine. 2. Idk, I don't think Québécois would accept foreign intervention.
3
This is what A P N refers to: the myth, 1. Soviet Union was a-national , although there were people of many nationalities fighting within its troops. 2. S. U. didn't win the war (alone) - it's the Allies that won the war.
3
What are your sources of information ? Didn't you know that before the war 20-30% of Ukraine's army were women? Any idea why this difference 10-15% to 100%?
3
I think Anders' definition relies on achieving (or not) the goal(s). He made a video about that, in case you want to check it out.
3
Dutch ... No comment
3
Why ? 😂
3
1 Russians army acted like this, attacking without superiority - you bring the numbers yourself. 2 I think APN talkes about examples of treating the information eg 4 cities of which the biggest is of 280 thousand population, of 30+ , in half a year time , is actually not the greatest achievement. 3 What is a lie? I understand APN is talking about impression that Russia is a giant (perhaps in surface, but not in population etc)
3
@vbite2685 I don't know who thought that, but it is not consistent with the military doctrine of Russian Federation , no kidding. Then the result is the withdrawal from Kiyv/northern area because of losses. In my 2nd reply I noticed that if you have a number of the soldiers, you do not deploy 100% of them on the front. In case of Ukraine, there are troops at Belarus and every other boarder , there are troops in training, being re-formed etc etc. You write "they try not to kill civilians" - it is in very contrast with 100.000 civilian victims in one city only.
3
Great arguments 🤣
3
@karsaorlong3761 Do you know what I think /thought ? But stil no arguments ...
3
1.Idk, but Russian army definitely first days of invasion acted like they expected soon a victory, even bringing parade uniforms etc with them. Until Hostomel. 2. Anybody who wants to get first general idea, I suppose 3. Perhaps because Russia troops do not advance anymore (I think Anders mentioned sth before)
2
Perhaps you could share your investigations?
2
*Filatov
2
@chrishoff402 Could you provide a definition what 'nazi' means? Perhaps 'responsible' as well. Re: Odessa 2014 Trade Unions building you're confused.
2
@rosemarin4750 Are you saying after the professor that Europeans as well as president Putin are puppets ?
2
Anders' video proved.🙂
2
tenderizing you say ? By letting so the airplanes in Crimea, air defence, ammunition depots, command posts are being destroyed ?
2
A P N's idea proved right.
2
?
2
Capital letters make no argument 😂
2
Dutch ... 🤕
2
Who found it? How was it transported? 🤣
2
Anders actually is "selling" the story Russians "are melting" and don't know they're melting, what is worse for Russians 🤕
1
As long as it is not officially declared war, but a "special operation", conscripts cannot serve and fight abroad, only professional contract soldiers.
1
What will he do, according to you ?
1
@tellyboy17 Thank you.😊
1
@stankovicaleksandar8169 Well, may be it was proRussian , I don't think now they're pro-war that destroys their homes.
1
You're just proving Anders right 😀
1
@ballerblocks Anders is talking about the mindset, and you just repeat nobody would bet against Russia. The facts are more and more people would do and they do so on every level.
1
@ballerblocks If "Russia has more capacity" and do not use it, perhaps cannot use this potential? Also, for some reason the war isn't 100% total - you are proving again that 'although something appears it could be different/bigger/stronger/winning - but it isn't, it counts what it is'
1
@ballerblocks Yes. What about when Duma don't declare war?
1
@ballerblocks Thank you for your reply.
1
I'm not good at maths Could you help? Is it about sums? or division? What do you mean?
1
Putin doesn't believe in God, but in force power. God would accept his soul perhaps, however, but not his doing.
1
@alfredbooker393 Yes and no 😄 And what now ? What if yes ? What if no ?
1
@alfredbooker393 Who destroyed what exactly ? Finland ? Poland ? ...?
1
@alfredbooker393 Have you thought about living in Russia (for some time) to try the flavour of "the saviour" ?
1
Not suffering from any sanctions ? What's your say about Russia's car industry 90% fall ?
1
@Paris.Kalachnikov Now certainly. Cars with bad emissions/contamination levels wouldn't be permitted in other countries, I hear buyers have to sign they will not go abroad in their new car...
1
@lancerevo9747 Car industry is a visiging card of the country's industry (toutes proportions gardées) . Re: missiles - why do you think Russian army instead of those surface-to-surface restores to using anti-air S-300 ones , bringing the systems back from Syria?
1
Perhaps you'd like to check the '1940' statement for the beginning.
1
Another thing re: "Anyone in the west who stands with Ukraine supports Nazis" Anyone in the east , the north and the south doesn't ?
1
Any argument?
1
Do you know that Russia is not capable of producing modern cars, only last century standard ones: no ABS, no airbags, no aircondition, no radio/hi-fi, kathalysators, combustion (contamination) control?
1
@ovwieobie6126 You're wrong about hypersonic missile / weapons (easy to check) , Could you provide any information what makes you write about "destroyed economy" ? How much actually do the 15% produce ? and how it compares to Russia? If by the currency you mean Russian ruble, this aspect also isn't bright if you (instead of artificial official rate, gained by selling lots of reserves) look at real free-market prices in exchange offices in Turkey or Finland.
1
The very next post after yours is contradicting what you wrote about Russia's capacity to keep production. Then, there are data/ indicators about the economy shrinking (despite Russia limited access) , eg income tax revenues falling 30%. What you write about the official, artificial exchange rate of rubel is propaganda.
1
Ukraine's winning politically. APN has actually a video on win as achieve goal/s meaning.
1
P**ce of sheet ?
1
Could you give one example of MSM saying so on 24 Feb ?
1
@Well....1234 No example ? Territory... mind the example of France and Germany at the end of Grand War 1918.
1
Why not ? What are they, according to you?
1
@cnccarving Are you aware that Donetsk basin have been under Russian control for 8+ years ?
1
@cnccarving Another thing you may not know, Zelensky is Russian-speaking (russophone) himself, (you seem to suggest he wants to kill himself, too (??))
1
@cnccarving What is my interpretation pls? My interpretation of what ?
1
IF ... Attacked against US or EU satellites ??
1
@joannspumanti3385 OK, in Israel and other countries it has been for some time. Are there any sources ? Any idea why Russia is at 10-15% , trying desperately to contract 63 y.o. pilots or prisoners ?
1
@joannspumanti3385 Oh ... No sources 😭 (BTW, the worst possible answer)
1
@joannspumanti3385 The rest , no comment. Anders 1 : 0 Joann .
1
@joannspumanti3385 No results. Will you be able to paste the link?
1
Is this why their puppet Putin started this war ? 😂
1
No signs ? What about the withdrawal from Kiyv/northern area and no advance last month ?
1
@againsttheleftandright4065 1. It took them over one month to realize there's no quick end... or may be counted how many killed ? VDV paratroopers among them?... 2. Slow advance that stalled after gaining 400 sq. kms ... and the strategic initiative moved to Ukraine. The picture isn't all bright, not at all. You seem to confirm APN's thesis, saying "Russia will win because Russia has to win". Side note "Own territory" ? I hear echo of Brezhnyev or some ghost of the revoltion?
1
Anders explained why.
1
You just proved Anders right 😄
1
@Llewellyn2844 There's the explanation in the video - you repeat Russia is going to win , because Russia will win BIG, militarily, economically, geopolitically... Then stretch the facts to fit this view, "air superority" that doesn't work, "minimizing own losses" ... Voila!
1
What pipeline was banned ? None. They're not "banned" now. North Stream 2 building had been sanctioned by the USA some time, but J. Biden lifted the sanctions.
1
@caveman-zd5yv What are your sources, please? as you seem to repeat putin propaganda. (even *if it was the case*, it is no reason for this invasion, btw) During and the hybrid war - yes, there are casualties and victims on both sides. You can hear many Ukrainian soldiers fighting against Russian troops speak among them Russian, exclaime Russian, write Russian. President Zelensky's first language is Russian. It's not about the language nor ethnicity.
1
@caveman-zd5yv What are your sources, please? as you seem to repeat putin propaganda. (even *if it was the case*, it is no reason for this invasion, btw) During and the hybrid war - yes, there are casualties and victims on both sides. You can hear many Ukrainian soldiers fighting against Russian troops speak among them Russian, exclaime Russian, write Russian. President Zelensky's first language is Russian. It's not about the language nor ethnicity.
1
@caveman-zd5yv You are confusing cause and result, do you know who is Igor Girkin / Strelkov?
1
And what about the nukes ?
1
@micixduda Well, the use of nuclear weapon most probably means mutual destruction.
1
@micixduda At first Yes, (in the improbable case), but the second thought it wouldn't be escalation but 'exiting the game' instead, when you cannot win anything or you avoid defeat (whatever it'd mean). But it is easy to say/write...
1
Who replaced Stalin ?
1
You've just proved Anders' idea.
1
@Silver_Prussian You just repeat Russia will win, ignoring that political goals haven't been achieved, strategic initiative is now on Ukrainian side, tactical victories disappeared (after scratching?) ...
1
@Silver_Prussian The Russians captured the most important cities ? What are they, apart of Herson and Mariupol?
1
@Silver_Prussian The Russians captured the most important cities ? What are they, apart of Herson and Mariupol?
1
@Silver_Prussian SD - population 100 thousand, there are 10 other cities this size, and 20+ bigger , right?
1
@Silver_Prussian It was, right, because could be defended well and long, now it is in ruins. What I mean, many/most bigger and more important cities aren't and will not be captured (as all indicates), hence SD, despite of tactical imortance, is not a sign of victory.
1
I can't see how you prove wrong here APN's and how the examples you give would be wrong, except "any more shells" (instead of "more cruising missiles"?). Troops - Russia desperately trying to recruit prisoners to fill in the losses. Tanks - restoring to old T-62s, because more modern T-72s are lacking. Time - plays against Russia.
1
You just prove Anders' words right.
1
Actually Ukraine can and is lowering Russian pounding. What's your source of information, please?
1
The fact is Russian armies haven't advanced for last month, while have been taking losses in ammo depots etc
1
@Unknown_Web_User I mean the lack of advance last month (not before). I'm no strategist and do not pretend to be one, however I can correct your information - eg Russia haven't managed to conquer the sky, as Russian planes do not operate behind front line (sometimes launch their attack from Belarus airspace). Ukrainian planes were present yesterday in Herson area. w?here did you read all that above? because it's simply mostly not correct, I'm afraid. If your input info is not correct , the conclusions aren't going to be good, either.
1
@Unknown_Web_User I'm confused you don't care whether it's no planes or few planes here and there i.e. your information is correct or not, but each to his/her own.
1
@Unknown_Web_User Is it a fact that now you're writing 'few planes' and about 4 hrs ago you wrote 'no fighter jets or bombers to speak of' ?
1
@Unknown_Web_User Is a plane carrying HARM missile modern enough?
1
@Unknown_Web_User What is your opinion on hiring 60 yrs old pilot for combat operations ?
1
@Unknown_Web_User IF ... Don't you think it's a sign that something doesn't work ? eg the majority of (younger) pilots of better health, but lacking enough experience ?
1
@Unknown_Web_User What are your sources for Ukraine is "forcing just about everyone" to fight ? Ukraine is in difficult situation, but that above is what I've read and watched about the militias of the part of Ukraine called Donbas (Lughansk), while Ukrainians were coming from abroad to volunteer into Ukrainian Army or Territorial Defence, and many are in stan-by in reserve, because of there's not enough heavy equipment for them. Some thousands are being trained abroad. Coming back to general major pilot (retired) K. Botashev, that was shot down with his plane - for some reason old people do not work as civilian pilots (and for even more reasons do not serve in the army/ air force). Re: the population numbers, this is not all, APN commented just about it in this video.
1
@Unknown_Web_User I assume you're Russian and you love your country, as I mine - but I see and admit it is not perfect, when something doesn't work or goes badly.
1
@Unknown_Web_User just listened to D. McGregor - to say he's one-sided is an understatement. Of what I could hear, he doesn't react to circumstances, but repeats the same pattern in 6 months. Of course the heart of the matter isn't one plane down. The question is why to employ mercenaries at the age of retirement? Catalonia, btw
1
You can do it yourself , touch top right corner menu
1
Have you bought anything yet? 🤣
1
@paul mcdowell You can answer your question when you see why NATO just "moved north", when Finland and Sweden asked to access.
1
Anders is not talking about "all the West" I think 🙂
1
It is one of many differences between EU and Russia.
1
Nuclear strike is massive suicide. Putin amassed that much wealth (money to mansions) in Russia's corrupt system that most probably he is not to commit suicide.
1