Comments by "Paul Aiello" (@paul1979uk2000) on "The breakup of the United Kingdom?" video.

  1. 4
  2. 3
  3. I think the real problem with the UK union is, what are the actually benefits for its members? I say that because if you look at Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales, they are all doing much worse than England is doing and even England, too much of the wealth is focused in the south of England, that is where the real problem is in the UK. If you look at GDP per capita of each of the member, Scotland and Wales are doing worse than almost all EU countries in the west of around the same size and in the case of Northern Ireland, their GDP per capita is almost 3 times lower than the Republic of Ireland. You get a sense that the south of England is bleeding the rest of the union dry, after all, this union has been around along time so this gap in wealth shouldn't be there any more and it's ironic when you look at the EU and how it develops members once in the EU, it seems they do a much better job of it. As for the UK union falling apart, well, I think with Brexit and now the poor handling of the pandemic from the UK government, I think the odds are quite high that Scotland could leave within 5 years and Northern Ireland to follow, the worry for the rest of the UK is if those two rejoin the EU and become more successful for it as then Wales might want to leave. I've always seen Brexit as an English vanity project that's mostly living in the past of the glory days and with a government that keeps getting things wrong time after time and them likely being in power with a majority for the next 5 years, the damage they can do the UK union is likely going to tip Scotland over the edge to leave and with that, a domino effect can happen. So yes, I do think the days are numbered for the UK union and this is mostly because as a country, the UK has changed a lot over the last few years and not for the better. On another note with the special relationship with the US, I have to ask, what does the UK gain out of that that France doesn't have? It seems to cause the UK more problems than it's worth, also on another note, Brexit weakens the UK in that we have no say in the EU and that matters to a lot of players around the world, especially the US because they want a big player in the EU that can get things done, now the UK isn't that player being outside the EU and that could change the balance in that the US might want to have a special relationship with France or Germany, any country that can help shape things in the EU as that is far more important to the US than the UK is as we are too small as a country.
    3
  4. 2
  5. 2
  6. 2
  7. 2
  8. 2
  9. 2
  10.  @roman648  The thing is, those 3 countries in the UK should be doing better being inside the UK then countries going it alone but clearly it's not working and for me that doesn't bold well for the UK with Brexit because there are many signs that Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales can go it alone without the UK and do better, especially inside the EU. As for the UK union, I think it depends on Brexit but we should remember that the cracks have been showing on the union well before Brexit, the UK leaving the EU just puts fuel on the fire and throw in the arrogance and poor handling of this pandemic from our government, many are starting to wonder if they can deal with it better themselves then having the UK government make a mess of things but even if it does happen, I doubt it will happen quickly and part of it could also be the message the EU gives out to them. I already think the UK is weaker on the world stage thanks to Brexit, a disunited union will be even weaker but I do have to wonder with the US, I've always sensed that their interest in the UK is in part with what the UK can get done in the EU, the UK being outside the EU makes the UK less useful for them now and the US will likely want some kind of special relationship with France or Germany, someone that can help shape policies in the EU, that I feel is a lot more important to the US than the UK is. Anyway, it will be interesting to watch the next 5 years on Brexit and the pandemic, it will be very interesting to also watch how closely the UK mirrors EU laws, rules and regulations to reduce red tape because ironically, it's in our interest to be as close to them in a lot of key areas to reduce cost and friction for businesses and the economy but that does fly in the way of what Brexit was supposed to be but the problem with diverging, it adds a lot more red tape.
    2
  11. 1
  12.  @canzuk6621  Scotland doesn't need permission from Boris on this, Scotland can simply have an advisor vote a bit like we did with Brexit and if the numbers are clearly in favour of leaving the UK, good luck to the UK government in trying to stop that. Beside, tactically speaking, it would be a bad move for the UK government to not give them that vote as that would likely get more Scots to vote to leave if they feel the UK is dictating things to them, best thing they can do is give them a vote and make a case on why they should stay but this government isn't that bright and will likely use hardline tactics on them which will likely backfire. Anyway, the reason Scotland deserves a vote is because they voted to stay in the EU whiles the England part of the union voted to leave, a lot has changed over the last few years that another vote is warranted, a lot was promised on Brexit that isn't being delivered and that is playing right into the hands of the Scots that want to leave the UK union. I suspect a vote will happen either late next year or early the year after depending on if we sort this virus out, Scotland will likely want to wait to allow the damage of Brexit to really kick in as that is likely going to make it easier to win the vote. Now normally I would agree with you in the once in a lifetime vote but Brexit was a right shit show with so many lies that it's not as clear cut as Brexiteers want, chances are, Brexit is going to rage on years after Brexit is done, especially if living standards take a hit, in other words, getting out of the EU is the easy part for the Brexiteers, the hard part is making a success of it and that doesn't look good so far.
    1
  13. 1
  14. 1
  15. 1
  16. 1
  17. 1
  18. 1
  19. 1
  20. 1
  21. 1
  22. 1
  23. 1
  24. 1
  25. 1
  26. 1
  27. 1
  28.  @JackTheSlayer-ok5eq  True Spain doesn't have nukes but that's by choice, they are advanced enough that if they wanted nukes, they would build them but for now, there's little to no reason to do so. What we should remember about Gibraltar and Spain is that Spain is an EU member and it's the task for the EU to do the bidding of it's members and protect the interest of it's members, whiles the UK was an EU member, the EU stayed out of it and was neutral on that, now the UK has Brexit, that changes the dynamics in favour of Spain. That doesn't mean they'll attack of anything like that, they don't have too, they can put a lot of political and economic pressure, knowing the EU will likely have their backs, sooner or later that could push the UK into either giving it up or more likely, joint ownership of Gibraltar. That's not the only ones that could be at risk, the Falkland Island could be as Argentina might fancy their chances on that as now the UK doesn't have the EU backing, the US likely doesn't care either way and the UK isn't on good terms with the likes of Russia which could help Argentina out. When the UK was an EU member, we was untouchable, no country was really going to mess with an EU member knowing what that could mean but now the UK out of the EU is in a much weaker and more vulnerable position that many around the world will take advantage of in time but most will likely wait till the UK declines some more, some at least a decade off before anything major happens.
    1
  29. 1
  30. 1
  31. 1
  32. 1
  33. 1
  34. 1
  35. 1
  36. 1
  37. 1
  38. 1