Comments by "Rita Gameiro" (@puraLusa) on "NewsNation" channel.

@socialroi2673 what u describe is a projection of ur own prespective but not reality. Majority of palest don't want a israeli passport, they consider that 1. Israel can't exist (river to the sea), 2. Lack of self-criticism (there would be an automatic civil war as soon as israel stoped existing), 3 their migrants (yes, a portion of palest are migrant descent and not descendants of folks who have been there for milenia as publicized) are legitimate but israel one's are ilegitimate. As u can see, israel wouldn't be normal, it would be a territory without definite borders (a big chunk of palest consider a portion of lebanon, the whole of jordan, a portion of syria and a chunk of egipt to be palestine the country) and extremely violent under civil war and war with neighbours, a very deadly combination. The more u know.
14
@socialroi2673 if it was that black and white, it would be that easy. Palestinians aren't a monolith, and there are about zero polls of what the actually think (culturally censorship is the norm not the exception). Best way to go into analising is the political leadership not ur average palestinians (that would be anedoctal evidence). But 2 can play ur game: there is a conection of the soviets and palest (along other arabs) who atempted a general arab socialist revolution where palest were used as cannon folder, so it isn't secretly support, it's a well known fact that anti-monarchist in jordan and kwait or anti-republicans in lebanon are politically align with factions of plaestinian resistance (notice that countries with a baath dictatorship didn't get palest interferance) and it's also easy to conect the soviets with south africa politics - there's ur cold war conection that goes beyond ur familly. Are u by any chance a soviet friendly socialist? Also, son of hamas can be counted as anedoctal evidence as much as ur familly prespective. I could go on and on and on- cause it isn't black and white but a very stupid conflict full of fake ass narratives and projections and false equivalence. In conclusion, all bad, both wrong etc.
7
@zakout007 religion is an individual choice, any other position is a fascist one (no different from nazism or inquisition). As for putting money on his head, it's no different than organized crime or any dictatorship in history, and also no different from nazism. It's just ugly overall.
4
It's 20 century and by now should be common knowlege that ethnicity and language doesn't equate to national feeling. And there isn't much of ethnic identity in europe, it's all admixture for the most part.
4
One of many manipulation techniques is exactly the introduction of a picture to provoke an emotion to the viewer, thus removing any objectivity and controling the narrative. Well spot 👍
3
The problem is that when we look into history that line doesn't exist. An example is french revolution where we accept the narrative that it was a fight for freedom but if u dig deeper the revolutionaries were terrorists. There are many more examples of this. As painful as is that value ur issuing is a line that historically never existed.
2
First u need to pass geography class.
2
@RabindraAdhikari-nepal have I made a personal moral judgment? No, I have exclusively criticize the position terrorism bad and freedom fighting good. Freedom fighting, revolution and all those on the surfice nice values makes us see the world as colectives as opose of a gathering of individuals as equals, aka, I criticized nationalism due to its toxicity. Nepal was a civil war which makes it a false equivalent. A bunch of foreigners were hurt thru time by papuans who are fighting indonesia, cause that's the only thing they have to manipulate countries who cooperate and trade with indonesia and make it ok for papua to be divided in half which by their prespective is colonialism and a freedom fighting movement. Maybe this is all due to the fact that intern comunity is compromised by economic interests of big companies (wether state-capitalist ones or just simple private lobby groups).
1
because homeless and hopeless don't survive russian winter and die. 🤦‍♀️
1
@Sunshine-n1n yup, either a troll or a usa centric murican.
1
@bernardinodasilva8571 that would be a conspiracy theory, something very used to manipulate the masses present time. False flags exist (iraq wmd) but this one isn't it. Why? A war at this stage doesn't suit israel interests (agreements with the saudis) but it does suit hamas and it's allies.
1
@alexugur do u think number of deaths equals to right and wrong? Shall we look into other conflict thru that lense like sudan, ethiopia, tigray, myanmar etc? Number of victims shows how much suffering there is: 1 victim is enough tragedy whatever it's identity group is.
1
No, but a whole bunch of countries aswell people around the world protested Iraq invasion - and look, they were right, there were no wmd and in the end it made iran stronger. As for the false equivalence - all other wars had their condemnation of equivalentes countries which israel isn't. Usa is kind of too big for anyone to trully say no to, hence why peeps resort to calling usa the biggest bully. That being said, yes israel is way too criticized when compared to other countries in similar situations (and I would argue worst situations).
1
And with this u just sum up the beginning of the century isra-palet conflict and why the suicide bombings were less than the 90s.
1
@MABeniowski u must be a genious of culture studies...
1
@MABeniowski u are confusing ethnicity, national identity, cultural identity and making it into 1 thing. It is not, and all these change over time and none are isolated. I recommend susan bassnet as a light reading about this topic.
1
@MABeniowski no, I meant that it's a perception that changes over time and feeling of identity is more relare to nationality as in a relation to the society around the individual than a fisical identity or a cultural (diferent cultures can and do share national identity). Again, susan bassnet is a great starter on the subject.
1
Yes cause vikings and germanic tribes are afraid of the cold. There was no europe before russian gas. The problem isn't industry energy needs its average citizens that can't use a sweater indoors. 😂😂😂
1
@sebastiancalderon3273 nope, in the past u are correct but present time, there would be a civil war and at the same time a war with neighbours. Why? There is the internal fighting and there is the prespective that palestine the country is the same as palestine the territory who encompass a chunck of the neighbours and the whole of jordan (basicly the mandate palestine plus some more). If hamas gets away with this it can also start considering the territory of the ummayads, the empire. That's why these wakos (like isis) are so dangerous beyond their own borders.
1