Comments by "Jakob" (@kattihatt) on "Follow No One. Trust Your Own Thoughts. | The Philosophy of Immanuel Kant" video.

  1. Biblical rules? First proove that god exist and that the bible is the truth.
    13
  2. ​ @hippykiller2775  if were not our thoughts, then what are we?
    8
  3. @Henrik Bork Christensen i think were both.
    6
  4.  @syeedchowdhury2501  it is not rational. We have no idea what happened before big bang. But please tell me, if we were created by a god, then who created the god? Since the god exist and can create its only rational to think that the god was also created by something.
    4
  5.  @syeedchowdhury2501  thanks for that wall of text. I havent said my aim is to disproove god. I want you to proove that god exists.
    4
  6.  @syeedchowdhury2501  so youre certain who created us, but have no idea who created god. How convenient.
    4
  7.  @Ramadmurthy  can you control what food you like, what music you enjoy?
    3
  8.  @Dave_of_Mordor  have you ever heard of music torture? I dont think people that have been listening to the same music for months agree with you. But even if it was true youre not in control of your mind during those weeks. Your mind thinks you dont like the food and you try to tell it it does.
    3
  9.  @Dave_of_Mordor  no, cause then you dont decide to not like that thing. You associate it with something you dont like. You cant decide on the spot that you dont like icecream when you actually do. Youre not in control of your mind. And also there is something called stream of conciousness, which are all the random thoughts that just appear in your head. Those are not in your control.
    3
  10.  @someguy1098  how do you know that your god cannot be proven? How did you reach that conclusion?
    3
  11.  @illustratedquotes  when do thoughts not come because of body chemistry?
    2
  12.  @syeedchowdhury2501  faith is believing in something without reason. Like believing in santa or loch ness monster.
    2
  13.  @syeedchowdhury2501  you cant proove god exists, therefore its without reason. I dont believe in fairytales.
    2
  14.  @someguy1098  if i would have blind faith in her, i could have met her and married her without talking to her or know her. Thats not the case, i mean i cant know her fully i dont think we ever know a person fully, but i know her enough to say that the possibility that she would kill me in my sleep right out of the blue is perhaps 0.01 % or even less i dont know. But you have 100% blind faith in your god without ever meeting or talking to him.
    2
  15.  @someguy1098  youre just telling me the same thing with different words. How did you come to the conclusion that god is outside of our physical system?
    2
  16.  @someguy1098  dont be rude. Youre telling me that you think what god is, not HOW you come to this conclusion. WHY do you think he is outside our system?
    2
  17.  @Ramadmurthy  why didnt you answer my question?
    1
  18.  @Dave_of_Mordor  can i decide to not like something then?
    1
  19.  @bryanfoley71  how?
    1
  20.  @arindamadhikary1844  where is the soul? Where is it?
    1
  21.  @arindamadhikary1844  no, our conciousness is our conciousness. If the soul is energy that is undetectable, how can you know that it exists?
    1
  22.  @arindamadhikary1844  counciousness is the ability to be aware of whats happening around you. This happens in your brain, via a combination of impulses from our senses and the interpretations of these.
    1
  23.  @arindamadhikary1844  they are not concious. Youre being silly now.
    1
  24.  @arindamadhikary1844  i know they are alive. Alive doesnt mean they have conciousness. Only part of the animal kingdom have conciousness. Trees for example, do not.
    1
  25.  @arindamadhikary1844  i dont know, im not a physician. Whats your point? If you kill someone you cant bring that person back? Thats probably true, atleast for now. It might be possible in the future to bring a person back.
    1
  26.  @arindamadhikary1844  when you make a baby you create life. Saying "its a form of energy" is precisely spiritual mumbo jumbo. You want a soul to exist, but you have no way of showing it exists. You shouldnt believe in things that cannot be prooven to exist.
    1
  27.  @arindamadhikary1844  its impossible to proove that something doesnt exist. Of course there is a difference between what is alive and what isnt. Just look up the definition of life. Growth, reproduction etc.
    1
  28.  @arindamadhikary1844  what am i wrong about?
    1
  29.  @arindamadhikary1844  you dont understand. Youre making the claim that a soul exists, but you dont provide evidence for it. Its not possible to disproove your claim. If i tell you there is a pink horsegod living in the middle of the earth, that is impossible to see. How can you disproove that? Does it exist if you cant disproove it?
    1
  30.  @fabarebovictor3433  i dont think i can control my thoughts. They just appear in my brain.
    1
  31.  @hippykiller2775  the reason is to show that you can stop liking something. If you love chocolate, can you choose to not like it? No you cannot, and therefore youre not in control of your mind.
    1
  32.  @hippykiller2775  no. I meant if you like chocolate, can you decide today i don t like chocolate? And on the spot actually dont like it?
    1
  33.  @hippykiller2775  why?
    1
  34.  @syeedchowdhury2501  you didnt answer my question: who created god?
    1
  35.  @someguy1098  thats convinient. Now proove it.
    1
  36. Lol what.
    1