Comments by "BHARATH CHANDRAN, JUST REMVER THAT" (@Your-god150) on "Pak Army commandos fail to rescue hostage personnel, all killed by Taliban in Bannu | Top Updates" video.

  1. 5
  2. 4
  3. 3
  4. 3
  5. 3
  6. 2
  7. 2
  8. 2
  9. 1
  10. 1
  11. 1
  12. 1
  13. 1
  14. 1
  15.  @Luclfer819  9:2 " you polytheist may travel freely through the land for 4 months" How can you impose restrictions to polytheist like travel not more than 4 months? "9: 3 A declaration from Allah and his messenger is made to all people on day of the greater pilgrimage 1 that Allah and his messengers are free of the polytheist. So if you pagans repent it will be better for you" If Allah and his messengers declare to the pagans/ polytheist that they are free of the pagans and polytheists means why would any pagan repent? If you want to be free of pagan worship means why should pagans repent for you what kind of harsh rule is this? Explain verse 9 : 4. why would a pagan support an enemy against Islamic believers? Seems like basically islam invaded that land and Islam is putting rules to that alien territory yes? If that's the case why dont yall give free speech and democracy to non Islamic people of Islamic states first before demanding all sort of freedom from the invaded land? "Surah 9 : 5 but once the sacred months have passed kill the polytheist which violated this treaty..." This is explicit terrorism. Ie if they dont allow you practice your rules in their land then you kill them if they do not pay you tax? This is like making the indigenous people of that land to listen to the foreign culture rules that you impose into their land alien to you? "Verse 9 : 6 And if anyone from the polytheist asks for your protection o Prophet grant it to them so they may hear the word of Allah..." This sounds like forceful conversion into Islam after you invade their land. "How can such a polytheist have a treaty with Allah and his messengers, except those you have made a treaty with at the sacred mosque? So as long as they were true to you be true to them..." Define truth according to this passage first.
    1
  16.  @Luclfer819  "first Muhammad and his companion were kicked out from their homeland makkah and Muhammad pbuh remained in madina and there all people accepted Islam" Why would all ( without any exception) the people of makkah kick out Muhammad without any reason? Are you saying all people of makkah were bad except Muhammad? And how come all people of madina accept Islam without any single exception? Or are you telling that only those pagans who accept Islam are good and those not are bad? "People of madina were allowed to do hajj in madina....When Muhammad and his companions left to makkah for hajj the pagans of makkah left their city for 2 days and makkah was free of pagans and Allah told them it should be better if you repent but nothing happened there after 3 days when Muhammad left all pagans were back" So according to the treaty are you saying that the pagans of makkah were supposed leave their own home ie makkah to some other place whenever Muhammad went to makkah to do hajj? You told that people of makkah already revolted against Muhammad and were not keen to accept Islam but at the same time people of medina accepted Islam and Muhammad then why is Muhammad again to makkah for hajj if medina is allowing hajj? And why exactly are the indigenous people of makkah supposed to leave makkah whenever Muhammad went to do hajj in makkah was it because of the treaty demanded by Allah or what else? "Why would pagans help enemies of muslims" mopla riots also happened because the pagans in India helped British because the converted muslims here wanted to establish Islamic state and help the enemies of pagans is an glimpse of circumstances from history. Else why would the pagans help enemies of Islam without any reason? "KAHLID BIN WALEED accepted islam and went to makkah" so this behaviour of Islam is seen since history. They want to genocide and convert the local culture into Islam. This drama is seen since birth of islam.
    1
  17. 1
  18. 1
  19. 1
  20. 1
  21. 1
  22. 1
  23.  @Luclfer819  See. You tried to prove "Islam do not promotes terrorism after I point out terror quote number from Quran ie surah 9 At-tawbah. You replied : makkah war was done because the pagans and Jews persecuted Muhammad and gave him lots of troubles and hindrance in his way. etc. My reply after analysing your comment about makkah war and with all the sources you gave, my analysis = Muhammad tried to promote monotheism ie islam but that will certainly destroy all other religion so the locals tried to put resistance in makkah against Muhammad that's natural. Your reply = Muhammad gathered 10,000 soldiers and went into makkah and the people of makkah looking at the 10,000 troops of Muhammad they all "peacefully accepted Islam" My reply = it looks like the people of makkah were afraid of Muhammad's huge army so they converted to Islam. I studied the source you asked me to read "makkah war" in wikipedia there it states that Muhammad and his men of medina destroyed all statues of pagan worshipers in makkah in the end after Muhammad told "you are all free" . So it clearly looks like the pagans of Arabia were converted to Islam through a kind of psychological threat/ suppression of convert or die status👉 "Muhammad: you know very well what I'm going to do, Pagans of makkah looking at the 10,000 army of Muhammad ( naturally they are scared of huge army of Muhammad) said : you can kill us all....etc Muhammad: no you are all free" Then he breaks all the pagan idols yes? In your reply = you brought in hindu scriptures wrong quote from zakir naiks website as your defense to prove Hinduism promoted killing of infidels and non pagan worshipers to justify the cause of pagan genocide and forceful conversion in Quran. My reply = i gave you the exact translation and rectified your wrong translations and showed you scholarly correct translations that there is no verses in hindu text that supports persecution of non Hindus/ non pagans" now you are jumping to new blame ie trying to find falt with manu smrithies with your next excuse/ blame ""I have nothing for you know, it's not there eyes that are blind, their hearts are blind" = nothing but your mental projection. You are not blind but you pretend to be like blind. You are not asleep but you pretend like you are asleep. My question = so are you done with your argument about "persecution of non Hindus in vedas"? Now do you agree that there is no persecution of non Hindus in vedas? First you solve this then let's go to manusmrithi. Manusmrithi also the text is rewritten by different people during the 1000 plus years of foreign invasion in India. We don't know who all rewrote manusmrithi. Wikipedia manusmrithi and read the subtopic "authenticity of the manuscript" you will know that the text manusmrithi is distorted off of its originality. Below that subtopic you will find commentaries of Gandhi and other famous personalities of that contemporary period who admits that the original version of manusmrithi is lost in the course of time. You will also find British scholars who argued before the house of the lords of British India that the original text manusmrithi is lost. You will also find scholars agreeing that original manusmrithi is distorted. Reality = there is no caste system in hindu religion. Caste system is a medieval aged concept that crept into India after 5th century AD and it became stronger under the British rule. The author of ramayana was born to brahmin became a shudra before he write hindu epic ramayana. Vyasa maharishi was born to obc caste. Krishna was born to obc "yadavas caste" The Tamil brahmin scholars "alwar" belonged to all caste of the society ie from upper caste till lowest caste shudras, how did they all become brahmin? Etc etc are circumstantial historical evidence that proves that the different caste = depends upon qualities of a person. For eg a rapist will become a shudra ; a drug addict will become a shudra. A shudra through sacrifice can become a brahmin. A brahmin can become a shudra based on his qualities in life.
    1
  24. 1
  25. 1
  26. 1
  27. 1