General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Austin Kole Carlisle
Yes Theory
comments

Comments by "Austin Kole Carlisle" (@AustinKoleCarlisle) on "This Place Re-Writes Human History: Göbekli Tepe" video.

@reddimus11 why are you all so threatened by someone asking questions? it's honestly bizarre because Hancock has brought more awareness to archeology than anyone else in recent history.
93
real archeologists are a joke. Flint Dibble couldn't even admit that a rock looked manmade.
32
@Rhartman22 there are different types of evidence, though. Graham Hancock provides a lot of evidence that you completely disregard because it's circumstantial, but it still shouldn't be ignored.
20
@reddimus11 last time i checked, Graham never wrote a scientific paper on the subject, so i don't see how you're claiming he's trying to say he's pushing theory and myth as fact.
19
@psychomikeo123 yet the implication from you all is that normal people cannot talk about things and ask questions unless they have a degree. that's also known as an appeal to authority.
14
@poolfrog911 Graham would literally be the first person to admit he was wrong, can archeologists say the same?
13
please pin your comment!
11
@psychomikeo123 he's an author but he doesn't pretend to be a scientist and you shouldn't hold him to a scientific standard.
11
@Jason-rp3mk Hancock has literally done more to get people interested in archeology than anyone else in recent memory.
8
why believe in something without proof? that's called religion.
7
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, it would 100% be called civilization. anyone saying otherwise is being disingenuous.
6
@samuelchampagne-guenette4344 funny how the archeologist who originally excavated GT agreed with Hancock.
6
kinda funny how the definition of civilization was pretty much set in stone until the discovery of Gobekli Tepe, now y'all are backpeddling and trying to shift those goalposts. what's the problem with admitting you were wrong?
5
has he ever publicly posted his credentials and diploma?
5
why are there so many people telling us to reject imagination? it's quite scary, like it's an orchestrated campaign.
4
@Rhartman22 polygonal masonry with a similar style that spans the globe from Easter Island, to Giza, to Baalbek, to India, to Angor Wat, to South America. it all perfectly interlocks together so tightly you can't fit a sheet of paper in the joint, and not just at the exterior. in places where the walls have separated due to earthquakes, you can see that the blocks curve three-dimensionally and still perfectly touch the entire depth of the stone. and wherever these walls are found, they're never located on top of another style. and yet supposedly isolated cultures all over the world decided to just stop building walls in this way, and we can't even recreate them today using the known methods of the time.
4
@Rhartman22 how would all of these supposedly isolated cultures know it's the best way to build a wall if they never built and tested other styles?
4
@Rhartman22 yeah but why wouldn't ALL of these cultures continue to build walls in the older superior style? not one of them anywhere on earth decided to continue building walls in this way, despite all of them supposedly deciding to build walls in this way BECAUSE it was the "superior" method of stone wall construction?
4
@spulwasser if GT was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, archeologists would have no problem calling this "evidence of civilization".
3
@rok8031 why would GH include irrelevant information in his own documentary?
3
@noahpauley those aren't his claims though, he merely presents evidence that other cultures allude to.
3
@Nattyboi555 stop misrepresenting. GH has always prefaced by saying he doesn't make claims, he just offers another viewpoint.
3
@arak5502 so the fuck what? you have the choice to not watch instead of just complain.
3
@kerolokerokerolo prove GH isn't informed. is it because he doesn't have an archeology degree? that's an appeal to authority which is an argument fallacy.
3
@wumbel5249 if he claims are baseless, then they shouldn't be a threat, right?
3
@Southpaw128 you all are gonna have to try a little harder. too many supposedly unrelated people saying "real archeologist" makes it way too obvious this is orchestrated. have a nice day ;)
3
@DanielGT_93 i agree we need to keep an open mind about all of this. clearly the existence of GT upsets a lot of people in the field because they're realizing what they've been taught is based on assumptions and lies.
3
@nuffsaid6229 if Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, it wouldnt' even be a debate among archeologists whether it was evidence of a civilization.
3
@Rhartman22 wouldn't we see evidence of older stone working techniques at these sites? yet most of the time, the oldest parts are centrally located, with newer construction surrounding this older hub. this is most apparent at Machu Picchu. the large megalithic center is surrounded by structures built with smaller stones loosely stacked like modern day building techniques.
3
y'all need to get better talking points, and you make it way too obvious that you're colluding together using the same terms like "real archeologist", etc.
2
@unit4735 i'm just saying you all are using the same talking points and speech patterns. might wanna get a new supervisor or update your group brainstorming sessions or something.
2
if he's anything like Flint Dibble, then why should we pay attention to people who merely regurgitate what's already known? science advances by challenging what's already known, not by enforcing it.
2
@_MikeJon_ i don't like Bright Insight. totally different category than the others.
2
@joeymedina7115 where else on earth are hundreds of 20+ ton stone monuments being constructed and carved by hunter/gatherers?
2
@joeymedina7115 why can't you answer my question though? it's a legitimate point that no one seems capable of answering. "oh that's just what hunter gatherers do"...okay, where? please point to a current group of hunter gatherers making something similar to GT.
2
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, it would be called civilization and everyone knows it. Don't try to tell me otherwise.
2
it's quite telling when so many people believe a "conspiracy theorist" more than the actual "experts" isn't it? you all believe in consensus of opinion dictating reality, well, how's that logic taste?
2
@robertmckinney1898 who are you to say it can't be proven? what are your credentials?
2
how dare you try to tell a channel how to operate.
2
who cares about respect in the scientific community? people literally refused to look through Galileo's telescope because they were afraid of what they would see, lol.
2
@Nigochen "more than likely" isn't science.
2
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
2
@ErraticAim that's an appeal to authority fallacy.
2
@Nattyboi555 you honestly don't think Flint was cherry-picking what he considered "evidence"? i mean he couldn't even concede that a plow shaped rock could have been manmade. nope, it was 100% not possible according to Flint. how is that not cherry picking?
2
@wumbel5249 drawing inferences is not the same as making a claim.
2
@Nigochen all he's saying is to keep an open mind, yet the point falls on deaf eyes and ears, apparently.
2
@Nigochen who are you to say who shouldn't be popular?
2
@Southpaw128 yeah and he agreed with Graham. i was talking about modern archeologists.
2
@Rhartman22 i never said it was defining evidence, but it definitely points toward more investigation and data needed to conclusively rule out the correlations and similarities across supposedly isolated ancient cultures.
2
@Rhartman22 nobody claimed it was direct evidence though, merely that the overwhelming circumstantial evidence warrants further investigation.
2
@Rhartman22 yeah but they never once decided to build these walls overtop of another building style? they all just decided to start building walls in this way? you realize how big of a coincidence that is, right?
2
actually, they lived there 5 months and 29 days. if they lived there 6 or more months, it would've flagged them as a "civilization". they were smart and savvy hunter gatherers, weren't they?
2
just Marxists being paid to promote the official narrative, what's new?
1
you have the choice to not watch.
1
@usderia1679 do you want a surgeon with 40 years performing your heart surgery or someone right out of residency?
1
@noahpauley show me the timestamp where Graham makes a claim
1
are you implying we know everything there is to know about GT?
1
no, just erect
1
it's pathetic how they act.
1
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
1
@_MikeJon_ why do you care so much?
1
he's never claimed to be an author. you all need new talking points.
1
you sound envious.
1
@reddimus11 has minuteman ever posted proof of his diploma or academic credentials?
1
nah, we already have enough Marxism
1
"really disappointing, "not a real archeologist", etc etc. you realize your video is being inundated with bots, right?
1
@YurikRoss according to who?
1
christ, could you all make it a little bit less obvious this is an orchestrated attack on Graham?
1
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
1
umm, white people were in Europe 40,000 years ago. they mixed with this new population around 11,000 years ago.
1
has he ever shown proof of his degree or credentials?
1
yawn...you all need new talking points.
1
@rok8031 so just ignore all of the stones that are neatly arranged on their side like a retaining wall, huh?
1
@yngviifromspace nah, he's even less credible that GH.
1
@wumbel5249 remind me again where he made claims?
1
@wumbel5249 he's allowed to speculate as he's not writing a scientific paper.
1
@jonathanangieri153 they don't want the masses self-educated. they want you in perpetual debt in order to be "educated" on what they determine the truth to be. anyone challenging this system is practically a heretic according to them.
1
why would they bring in an "expert" who denies reality like Flint Dibble?
1
@bigpapa2195 you and your Marxist horde need to get new talking points.
1
@DopeSauceBenevolence and yet most medical professionals got COVID wrong. regardless, good thing we're not talking about surgery, huh?
1
seconding this!
1
@averyc.8447 has he ever showed proof of his degree or credentials?
1
@MoonBoomChannel If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
1
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization. academics are going out of their way to not call this civilization because the people who created it were white, and there is without a doubt a strong anti-white bias in Marxist academia.
1
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
1
@YurikRoss it took civilization to create this site and all of the other Tas Tepelar sites. if this was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, you don't think it would be called civilization? get real.
1