Comments by "" (@diadetediotedio6918) on "Brian Cox debunked the Big Bang! Wait, what?" video.

And then you just assume everything just existed acritically
1
 @StevXtreme Oh the famous god complex, "humans are so dumb, but I'm the smart guy that can foresee them all".
1
Yes, so everything "just existed" without any reason hahahahaha love this conclusion to the explanation. It is a hard problem and saying "uh time not existed" is not a response, it is a convenient metaphysical assumption to the problem.
1
@user-gs4oi1fm4l Nah, the distinction is more abstract than concrete, we know for sure that they are intrinsically connected because macro objects can have what we call quantum phenomena (like superfluids or superconductors).
1
@h14hc124 Because time is a fundamental measure, if you cannot talk about what came before the spacetime then you are just assuming everything just exists without any reason (which is dogmatic), and worst, you are assuming that everything ever existed AND that we are in a continuous moving and expanding space-time at this exact moment (implying that the ever existing space-time suddenly existend AND started to expand at a specific moment without reason as well). It is dogmatism from start to the end, and it is not better than any religious explanation that are even more reasonable than that.
1
@skorpiongod It is impossible for the question 'What was there before the creation of universe' to be proven or discovered by science in any ways, this is literally a extremely hard limitation. It is a hard limitation simply because even if we HAD the data about what came before the big bang (for example), the question "and what came before that" would still be open, and we know that we don't have any ways to have <infinite data> so any response to these questions would turn to be metaphysical, either by God or by some god scientists believe in (like "eternal existence" or "the static universe").
1
@skorpiongod Bro, I literally argued to you why information is not the problem, it is literally an impossible problem that requires <infinite information>, and this also turns to be a metaphysical problem.
1