Comments by "WALTERBROADDUS" (@WALTERBROADDUS) on "But Does it Take 1911 Mags? Prototype Winchester 1905SL in .45 ACP" video.

  1.  @randomidiot8142  This is Circa 1920. This is hi capacity in a mostly revolver World. And rather than military, this more commerical to LEO gun. Alternative to the typical 1892 or riot gun.
    3
  2.  @ScottKenny1978  That might be why this gun was not made? Winchester was still selling tons of 1892's to the same users. And the 1911 was still second place to the revolver.
    3
  3. It serves as a practical replacement for the model 1892.
    3
  4. Of course you have to think of the time. It's still the time of the model 1892 and still the time of the police revolver.
    3
  5.  @randomidiot8142  In 1920? Even a cop car was a new thing. Even the FBI took years to even carry guns. But for guys like the Texas Rangers? This might go well with a 1911 on the hip... 🤔
    2
  6. I think you'd want a Marlin Camp Carbine more.
    1
  7. It would have been an interesting alternative to the 12 gauge Riot shotgun. Commercially, it would have been an interesting competition to the model 1892.
    1
  8. Nice idea, but I doubt it.
    1
  9. No...... too big.
    1
  10. Different time. And a revolver world.
    1
  11. The 1907 is not in a matching pistol caliber.
    1
  12. The Marlin Camp Carbine was available over 20 years ago.
    1
  13. No chance...
    1
  14. Marlin did..... the Camp Carbine in .45ACP and used 1911 mags.
    1