General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
peabase
DW News
comments
Comments by "peabase" (@peabase) on "Ukraine sentences Russian soldier to life in first war crimes trial | DW News" video.
You're suggesting that the victim was an unlawful combatant. That doesn't appear to be the case, and the Geneva Convention calls for a competent tribunal to rule on the matter. Therefore, it was an extrajudicial killing at the very least.
1
@francislau3393 You claim that something must be false because it contradicts your expectations or beliefs. That's called an "appeal to common sense" informal fallacy.
1
You're the one who's full of it. Speaking on the phone can't be equated to carrying arms openly -- one of the hallmarks of being an unlawful combatant. Even so, they should've arrested him and left it to a tribunal to decided his fate. Unless he was found guilty of genocide, he couldn't have legally been put to death either.
1
@urbansenicar81 Nope, being suspected of engaging in reconnaissance doesn't make you free game. So now you're trying extenuating circumstances. If you corner a murder suspect and decide to play judge, jury and executioner on the spot, you'll still be charged for murder.
1