Comments by "Harry Mills" (@harrymills2770) on "m o d e r n i t y" channel.

  1. 14
  2. 9
  3. 8
  4. 7
  5. French history of 'people rising up' is spotty, at best. They throw out the old rascals and generally bring in WORSE rascals. Louis XVI was out of touch. Bonaparte was a megalomaniac, who basically invented total war, with HUGE conscript armies. He had 3 main innovations as far as I can tell: The realization that really BIG guns can kill more people than small guns, that you can build a huge army if you institute the draft, and you can invade without worrying about supply lines if your 'citizen army' specializes in pillage. Maybe a 4th innovation was the simple idea that if your drummers beat a faster tempo, your army would march faster! Woo-Hoo! Unlike the American revolution, the French had no real idea of what self-rule should look like. They just rejected the decadent monarchy, with no clear plan for civilian rule. So they went from a traditional autocrat, king by birthright, anointed by the Church, to an Emperor who grabbed more real power than the Bourbons ever had. They weren't against being ruled by a dictator. They just wanted the dictator to be a god-like figure who made all the RIGHT decisions. Similar situation in China, where the people don't really have any understanding of self rule, and the ONLY way they turn over their government is when the current one's incompetence can no longer be denied. Sadly, this is human nature. It took some pretty unique conditions for the U.S. Constitution to be created. Self-rule. Explicit limitations on the exercise of power, before our government ever CAME to power. Every other time in history, limitations were only ever instituted AFTER severe abuses took place. I think the USA is the only country whose government was more or less a scientific application of the lessons of history. What made us exceptional is that we didn't kid ourselves that we were exceptional, and somehow immune to the same corruption and decay that caused us to revolt against the monarchy in the first place. Very rare in a bunch of revolutionaries. That's the exceptional part. That George Washington would serve his 2 terms and refuse to run, again. That no president (until a power-hungry Democrat in the 20th Century came along) ever sought more than 2 terms and that we'd even write it into law. Would that the Congress would write such laws governing themSELVES!
    6
  6. 3
  7. 2
  8. 1
  9. 1
  10. 1
  11. 1
  12. 1
  13. 1
  14. 1
  15. 1
  16. 1
  17. 1
  18. 1