Comments by "guido toth" (@guidototh6091) on "The Consequences Of Overturning Roe v. Wade And How To Overhaul Women’s Healthcare" video.

9th Amendment "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." 14th Amendment "No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."
8
@samizdat113 She shouldn't have to drive to another state to assert her rights to her own body.
2
@samizdat113 There has always been abortion in this country, especially in the 1930s when it was even more common than today even though it wasn't legal. Roe v. Wade made it not only legal but safe.
2
The same arguments for NOT finding it in the 9th and 14th Amendments mean that states can outlaw birth control, which they use to do not many years ago.
1
@johngiannini697 Go read the 9th and the 14th Amendments and 60 years of court decisions about them. I did take Constitutional Law. Twice actually. Once in college, once in law school. I suggest you do the same.
1
@samizdat113 No. What the state is doing is criminalizing a personal choice of the woman. Nothing equal at all.
1
@ClockworkGearhead So how would you punish the women who take medications to induce abortions, which is the most common form of abortion?
1
@coveyssteve Might I suggest that you move to Afghanistan. You might be happier there.
1
@samizdat113 All Americans have the right to make their own reproductive decisions. Not the state. Not the government. These extremist right wing Christian laws will be ignored as they should be, except the poorest women in red states will suffer.
1
@samizdat113 The extremist right wing Catholics on the Court went outside of their authority by dumping 60 years of right of privacy decisions that they thought conflicted with their religion. Oh a lot of them would like to do away with decisions protecting a person's right to buy birth control too. As for you last comment, it shows what really is motivating you. Your hatred of women.
1
@DirtyRedMuzik Are you trying desperately to equate a woman's right to control her own uterus with commerce?
1
@DirtyRedMuzik News flash. Women who are prostitutes do it for money, not for pleasure. It is the men who are doing it for pleasure. Not that has anything to do with abortion. It is quite a tell that you equate the two. It tells me a lot where your head is at and how you think that women who get abortions are no better than prostitutes. You disgust me.
1
Or to the people. Roe recognized the right to an abortion was with the people. Not government.
1
@samizdat113 No. That is not what the text of the 10th Amendment says. Also the 9th Amendment says that the Bill of Rights as enumerated is not a complete list of all the rights that people have. Also the 14th Amendment states that life liberty and property may not be deprived without due process. Roe and a number of other cases recognized that the decision of whether to get an abortion rests with the people and not the federal government nor the states. It was a good decision in keeping with the constitution.
1
@samizdat113 Roe said that to a large degree the right to have an abortion rests with the people, not government. 9th Amend. says the Bill of Rights isn't an exclusive list and the 14th Amendment protects liberty life from the federal and state government under the due process clause.
1
@samizdat113 No. The 10th Amend. deals with the power of Congress v. the power of the states or the people of the states, it does not limit the powers of the people versus state control. Roe recognized the power of people is stronger than the states or the federal government.
1