Comments by "guido toth" (@guidototh6091) on "" video.

  1. Most bigots think their god is on their side.
    5
  2. The term Palestine predates the Romans. And the indigenous population of the region is long lost to history, having lived there many millenia prior to the Jews.
    5
  3. ​ @edvinar3770 One of Oren's talking points is that the Palestinians are an "invented people." The same argument could be used against Israelis.
    4
  4. Totally one sided
    4
  5. ​@elijahFree2000 Netanyahu better step up his game and give Trump one of the airplanes that we Americans gave Israel.
    4
  6. ​@dogbert52 The conflict started in 1917 when the British occupiers announced a Jewish immigration scheme and the 85% Arab majority said no.
    4
  7. Palestine actually has 7 medical schools, far more per capita than the USA
    3
  8. Britain promised their Arab allies self-determination. They lied. They got a 30 year occupation and a scheme for Jewish immigration. The 85% Arab majority objected. They were suppressed.
    3
  9.  @ThomasVWorm  1 million people is 1 million more than nothing.
    3
  10. ​ @nonnymoose6260 It was called Palestine by the Greeks 400 years before that.
    3
  11. ​@huyucoding Arabs have been there for 1300 years and before. They didn't kick out Jews when they took Jerusalem from the Christians.
    3
  12. @Alex3Mythical  I've said nothing about dialect. Identity is an abstract concept. English settlers in what is now the USA saw themselves as English. Then later Americans. The Arabs in Palestine have been there for many many centuries. Their identity is now Palestinian. And so be it.
    3
  13. Dearborn, Michigan is among the most Muslim cities in America. It also has a very, very low murder rate.
    3
  14. I'm not leftist or a Muslim. But ask yourself this: Oren sets up a straw man question, challenging people to prove that Jews stole land prior to 1948 when the theft actually occurred in 1948 and thereafter through the present day.
    3
  15. So you are a bigot
    3
  16.  @Unimatrix69  So do you think all Muslims lie?
    3
  17. The 2.7 million Palestinians in the West Bank include families forced out of Israel in 1947-1949 and families who have long lived in the West Bank. Those two groups are the vast majority of the Arab population in that region.
    3
  18. ​ @HabaneroTi  Oren has made bigoted remarks about Arabs. His drum beat is continuous: Arabs and Muslims are bad.
    3
  19. @nimgub1  Manufacturing in the West Bank is severely limited because Israel contols the borders. This limitation on their economy is by design.
    3
  20. Israel stole 3000 acres in the West Bank last year...in just one land grab
    3
  21. ​ @petarprasevic How about them not killing each other.
    3
  22. And several hundred thousand Palestinians live under Israeli martial law on the West Bank
    3
  23. Does Israel treat Jewish settlers the same as Palestinians in the occupied West Bank?
    3
  24. ​ @proronen The names of the more than 400 Arab villages ethnically cleansed by Israel in 1947-1949 are readily available.
    3
  25. ​ @DenisKO-c8d Have you seen the documentary?
    3
  26. ​ @yeshuaiscomingbackrepent2357 Show me the Chapter and verse....
    3
  27. ​ @colonol1239  West Bank or just Palestine
    3
  28. Ethnic cleansing is bad no matter who does it.
    3
  29. ​@ryanlewis490 Oren poses the question as theft pre 1948 knowing full well that the theft occurred from 1948 through 2025.
    3
  30. ​@colonol1239 There have been 20 attacks by settlers so far this year. They happen constantly.
    3
  31. ​@E_politolog I'm well aware of Israel's ethnic cleansing of 750,000 Arabs in 1947-1949 and well aware of Israel's ongoing land theft in the West Bank, which continues to this day.
    3
  32. Ancient Israelites colonized the Levant if you believe the Bible
    3
  33. She is a lobbyist for Israel and hasn't convinced any court with her pro Israeli arguments
    3
  34. Oren posed his question as pre-1948. That way he doesn't have to admit the land theft occurs all the time in Israel and the West Bank.
    3
  35.  @shaik-cd7lu  The guy in the video didn't look like he was joking.
    3
  36. ​@ef2718Actually the US government estimates that the Palestinian population in the West Bank is 3 million
    3
  37. @ef2718  Show me your sources. Obviously Palestine and CIA's numbers differ..lol
    3
  38. ​ @petarprasevic  That attack was in revenge for Deir Yassim. The cycle of violence between Jews and Arabs from 1920s to 2025.
    3
  39. ​ @wicher2462 Both sides do it. Oren loves to keep repeating the same mantra that there are no such people as Palestinians. There are about 7 million Jews in Israel/Palestine and about 7 million Arabs. Deligitimizing the other side is a regional sport.
    3
  40. ​ @soakupthesunman  Arabs in Palestine can call themselves anything they want. Just like Jews started calling themselves Israelis in 1948.
    3
  41. ​@makeroftoys Simply untrue. Before 1948 there were no Israelis...lol
    3
  42. @y0abl0  No. The name is at least 2,400 years old. Perhaps older.
    2
  43. Arabs were the majority population in Palestine from 1000 AD until 1948. Not just the majority but the overwhelming majority.
    2
  44. Jordan gave up any claim to the West Bank in 1988. Israeli military occupation is in its 58th year.
    2
  45. ​@Disciple-ofChrist Most Jews called themselves Jews or the Yishuv. Most Arabs called themselves Arabs. Over the course of the 20th Century, Jews called themselves Israelis and Arabs called themselves Palestinians...mostly.
    2
  46. The irony of Oren's argument is that before 1948, Jews in Palestine generally referred to themselves as Jews or the Yishuv. Not Israelis.
    2
  47. Yet there are 7 million Arabs/Palestinians there.
    2
  48. To the West Bank? Where they continually seize Palestinian land? No.
    2
  49. Arabs were the overwhelming majority population in Palestine from around 1000 AD through 1948. When the Balfour Declaration was made they were at least 85% of the population of Palestine. They dont need to justify their existence to you.
    2
  50. Israel continues to steal Arab land in the West Bank. Should the Palestinian civilians just lay down and take it like sheep?
    2
  51.  @ofrikalif4938  Israel frequently closes the borders. It's very difficult to export if you can't get goods across borders.
    2
  52. ​ @sunshine6522  The PLO recognized Israel's right to exist many years ago. The occupation and martial law haven't ended.
    2
  53.  @dhaninel7902  Israel passed laws after they drove out most of the Arabs from territory controlled by them in 1949 to make it very hard to return. And to make sure they destroyed many houses in Arab villages.
    2
  54. @dhaninel7902  I'm well aware of him. Pro-Isrealis never tire of him because he supports their anti-Palestinian agenda. I'm also well aware of the many Israeli Jews who are fierce critics of Netanyahu and his policies in the West Bank and Gaza. Let Jews and Arabs solve their own 100 year conflict. The USA needs to pull back from this never-ending cluster f**k.
    2
  55. Actually everyone has a right to self determination. The 7 million Jews in Israel and the 7 million Arabs in Israel and Palestine.
    2
  56. ​ @user-pj3ic6qw2p  Ethnic cleansing is wrong no matter who does it
    2
  57. ​ @Unimatrix69  300,000 Palestinians live under Israeli martial law in Area C of the occupied West Bank. Do research before you reply to my comments.
    2
  58. Don't remember seeing the USA mentioned in the Bible
    2
  59. ​ @GB-es4qz The Arab civilians were expelled in many areas even if they were peaceful.
    2
  60. ​ @yedidyapopper9631 Then why does Israel evict Arabs from East Jerusalem? Seize Arab land in the West Bank? Allows illegal Jewish settlements to become legal and look the other way while Jewish settlers attack Arabs?
    2
  61. ​@DenisKO-c8d What is now Israel/Palestine has been settled for about 12,000 years. It was a predominantly Jewish land for about 1,000 years and most of that time was not an independent kingdom but part of other, larger non Jewish kingdoms.
    2
  62. Non Jewish people who come to Israel don't get to vote. Nor do the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who live under martial law in parts of the West Bank
    2
  63. ​​ @colonol1239 Non Jewish immigrants can't vote nor can the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians under martial law in the West Bank. If you think that's a lie, prove me wrong.
    2
  64. ​ @soakupthesunman 2.7 million Palestinians aren't going to leave the West Bank
    2
  65. THE issue is the theft of Arab land from 1948 to the present
    2
  66.  @ilfyf  I have no antisemitic friends. You assume too much. Never assume. Oren poses the question of land theft as one before 1948 when the ethnic cleansing and land theft occurred in 1948 and after. That's what propagandists do.
    2
  67. Muslims didn't slaughter the Jews in the 600s. The European Christian Crusaders did.
    2
  68. ​@tribalman9668 I never said Christian Crusaders slaughtered Jews in the 600s. I said Muslims didn't when they conquered Jerusalem. But Christian Crusaders DID slaughter Jews when they conquered Jerusalem and adjacent areas in 1099.
    2
  69. ​@eladweissman9184 Jews didn't steal Arab land until they started stealing Arab land.
    2
  70. ​​ @abraham4961 Actually the Palestinians who live there call it Palestine.
    2
  71. ​@nicbahtin4774 Oren only criticizes Palestinians, Arabs, Muslims and those who support them. He never posts videos criticizing his own country or culture. That is a propaganda. And yes he makes money off it. I've spent time in the region. Read a lot. Talked to many. I make up my own mind. Oren's one sided channel isn't history.
    2
  72. It's plain old theft
    2
  73. @ef2718  The CIA doesn't use anyone else's numbers. Palestine says 3.19. The CIA says 3.0 million.
    2
  74. @TomasFunes-rt8rd  800,000 Israeli Jewish settlers live in Palestine. They are protected by the Israeli military and are immune from Palestinian law.
    2
  75. ​ @sunshine6522  The USA has the largest refinery capacity on Earth. Netanyahu wants to annex parts of Syria and even Lebanon. He wants war with Iran. He desperately wants us with him. No thanks.v
    2
  76. 😂 no
    2
  77.  @wicher2462  The region has been settled for over 10,000 years. About 1,000 years under ancient Jewsish rule. According to their traditions, they took it from the Canaanites. Palestine was majority Arab from before 1000 AD through 1948 when it was about 66% Arab. The Palestinians can call themselves anything they want just like Jews started calling themselves Israelis in 1948.
    2
  78. ​@wicher2462 There is no such thing as ancient claims of land. It's all BS. The population who lives in a place now have the rights of self determination. The Palestinians don't have to justify their existence to anyone.
    2
  79. ​ @AkivaB  It's called ethnic cleansing. It's a war crime.
    2
  80. ​ @DenisKO-c8d  Ethnic cleansing of civilians is a war crime. Why is that difficult for you to grasp?
    2
  81. ​ @DenisKO-c8d 2.7 to 3 million Palestinians in the West Bank aren't leaving
    2
  82. @ThomasVWorm  There were 1 million people in Palestine, 100 years ago
    1
  83. Israelis have been stealing Arab land since 1948 through today.
    1
  84. ​@Redeemer44 This proves you know nothing about the US or its Arab and Moslem population which is overwhelmingly non violent.
    1
  85.  @skwarubwa7083  Palestinians in the West Bank don't call it that. They call it Palestine. Israel's borders are not settled either.
    1
  86.  @skwarubwa7083  Not with Lebanon. Not with Palestine.
    1
  87. @skwarubwa7083  Like I said, the Israeli-Lebanese border isn't settled. Palestine declared its independence 37 years ago. Over 140 countries recognize it.
    1
  88. @skwarubwa7083  It's a state. It has a capital. A Government. A population. A flag. And the recognition of 147 other countries including Spain, Mexico, Ireland, Iceland, Sweden, Norway etc. To say their recognition is because they hate Israel and Jews is ludicrous.
    1
  89. @skwarubwa7083  Israel's borders aren't fully defined. Are you saying South Korea isn't a country? Are you saying Ukraine isn't a country? Moldova. Under your definition, Israel wasn't a country in May 1948.
    1
  90. @skwarubwa7083  Israel's complete borders aren't defined. Every time I'd travel to the West Bank there were border guards.
    1
  91.  @skwarubwa7083  Palestine is a country.
    1
  92. @sunshine6522  Israel doesn't recognize Palestine and Netanyahu says he won't support a two state solution. And most Israelis support the scorched earth policy in Gaza. So there you go.
    1
  93. @sunshine6522  Most Israelis aren't objecting to the huge numbers of civilians killed in Gaza. Why would Israelis expect Palestinians to care about Israeli civilian deaths? The PLO recognized Israel's right to exist but Israel didn't reciprocate. The Palestinians wouldn't have gotten the limited control they have without violence. Israel is not in the habit of giving rights to Palestinians.
    1
  94. ​@sunshine6522 Neither side say they target civilians but both sides kill civilians. Except Israel has killed far far many more. Without violence Israel wouldn't exist. Without violence neither would Palestine. Now Netanyahu's government is vowing to destroy what's left of Gaza and run its people out. The 100 year war continues. The USA should stay out of it. Let the Jews and Arabs deal with their own problems.
    1
  95. @sunshine6522  Netanyahu cabinet members are calling for the complete destruction of Gaza, the cleansing of its population and the justification for killing tens of thousands of women, children and elderly. So spare me the BS that Israelis don't support violence against civilians. Theyve killed tens of thousands of civilians. I've studied the region for decades. Traveled there. Spent time in the West Bank. My uncle was in the region for the US government during the 1947-1949 war. I used to believe the US could bring the parties together. I no longer think that. In fact, I believe the US engagement in the region makes it worse. Netanyahu wants all of the West Bank. The 100 year old war is only going to get much worse.
    1
  96. ​@sunshine6522 Israeli officials calling for the total devastation of Gaza is ok with you?. The killing of tens of thousands of civilians. The destruction of the vast majority of hospitals and schools in Gaza. The blockade of food to civilians. I don't want my country associated with the Netanyahu regime and it's goals for a Greater Isreal. Perhaps you should learn about the history of the region and how this is playing out in places like Jenin, East Jerusalem and Givat Hamatos and many other places. How many Palestinians have you ever talked to?
    1
  97. In 1890 Palestine had 532,000 people. Only 8% were Jews. Most of the remaining 92% were Arabs and most had lived in Palestine for many, many, many generations and most did not have Egyptian roots.
    1
  98. I see lots of darkness on both sides. The conflict is over 100 years old.
    1
  99. ​Can you answer his question? You avoid talking about the 5 million Palestinians who live in Gaza and the West Bank which are NOT part of Israel.
    1
  100. ​ @GB-es4qz The 2.7 million Palestinians who live there call it Palestine
    1
  101. And like too many Israelis, blind in one eye
    1
  102. @dhaninel7902  In 1993 the PLO recognized srael's right to exist. Israel has never recognized Palestine's right to exist.
    1
  103.  @dhaninel7902  "There is no one place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population." Moshe Dayan.
    1
  104. @dhaninel7902  There were only 608,000 Jews in all of Palestine in 1946 so no. And there was no wide scale expulsion of Jews from Arab countries prior to 1948.
    1
  105. @dhaninel7902  Yes Arab villagers were dispossesed by Jews who were then planning a Jewish state with no room for these Arabs. Imagine that. The Arab majority were angry. Who could have guessed? Hilarious 😂
    1
  106. @dhaninel7902  And Israel ethnically cleansed again similar number. Which shows that governments in Israel and some Arab countries shared similar values. That's one reason why my American tax dollars shouldn't not fund this 100 year old conflict anymore.
    1
  107. Yet according to the Bible, Isrealites invaded Canaan.
    1
  108. ​@Redeemer44 The conflict didnt start in 1948. It started when the British occupiers announced a Jewish immigration scheme that, not surprisingly, the 85% Arab majority objected to.
    1
  109. ​ @solvingpolitics3172 Palestinians say the same thing about Israel so there you go
    1
  110.  @solvingpolitics3172  Israelis can choose their government. So can Palestinians.
    1
  111.  @solvingpolitics3172  Arabs have been in Palestine for 1300 years plus.
    1
  112. @solvingpolitics3172  Keep stealing land from 5 million Palestinians and you don't get peace.
    1
  113. Palestinians are not leaving Palestine.
    1
  114. Why are Israelis so upset with this slogan? The map in Netanyahu's office shows that the West Bank is "part" of Israel.
    1
  115. ​@colonol1239 None of those 20 attacks since January 1 2025 were self defense. Settler thugs.
    1
  116. ​@colonol1239 Your comment shows your desperation and inability to refute my factual statements.
    1
  117.  @colonol1239  I state facts. You just make juvenile insults.
    1
  118. ​ @Redeemer44 When Britain came up with this scheme, Palestine was 85% Arab. They objected. Britain didn't listen.
    1
  119. ​ @sunshine6522 Is Israel going to give back the land in Israel that some of these East Jerusalem Palestinians were driven from in 1947-1949?
    1
  120. ​ @sunshine6522  Jacob is from the USA. Do you have any evidence that these Arab civilians ethnically cleansed by Israel ever raised a hand to any Israeli? Of course you don't. By the way, the conflict started in 1917 when the 85% Arab majority in Palestine realized that not only were they not getting seldlf determination but we're getting a British immigration scheme for Jews.
    1
  121. ​​ @sunshine6522 Who are the rightful owners? Name? Ethnic cleansing is bad no matter who does it. If you think that Israel treats Arabs and Jews equally when it comes to land possession, you are very mistaken. As for history, the Arabs were determined for decades not to allow the division of Palestine. It's hardly surprising that as the 85% majority when the British occupation began, that they would get the promised self determination. Instead they got a 30 year occupation and a British scheme for Jewish immigration. I can't think of any majority population on earth that would have accepted that.
    1
  122. ​@colonol1239 and there are hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in the West Bank under martial law.
    1
  123.  @colonol1239  Prove me wrong. I'll wait.
    1
  124.  @colonol1239  Do you have a reading comprehension issue? I said there are hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in the West Bank who live under Israeli martial law. This is a fact. Prove me wrong or move along.
    1
  125. How exactly do civilians, old men, women, children "lose" their homes in a war in a way that is justifiable?
    1
  126. ​ @yedidyapopper9631 When you seize land and install 800,000 settlers, maybe the Palestinians get angry
    1
  127. He's a propagandist
    1
  128. ​@zaharabardavid And now you want erase the millions of Palestinians who live in the West Bank
    1
  129. @ef2718  Show me one court that has accepted this Israeli argument.
    1
  130. @ef2718 The West Bank is home to 2.7 million Palestinians. They've lived there for many centuries. They aren't leaving.
    1
  131. ​@ef2718All erhnic cleansing is bad. Including the 750,000 Arabs ethnicity cleansed from Israel.
    1
  132. Palestine has been overwhelmingly majority Arab for over 1000 years. They arent leaving.
    1
  133. ​ @sallymacmillan The 2.7 million Palestinians who live there call it Palestine
    1
  134. ​ @simonshirzad9996 The Palestinians aren't leaving
    1
  135. Oren: Jews never stole land before they started stealing land.
    1
  136. @wathoo3944  All 400 plus? Here are 5: Ajjur, al-Tira, Samakh, Air, Al-Qubab. Read about them. When you have, I'll send the names of 5 more. It wasn't empty land. Several thousand people lived in just the 5 I mentioned.
    1
  137. ​​@wathoo3944 YouTube takes down links. Benny Morris, Naseer Aruri and others have published much on this subject.
    1