Comments by "soundscape26" (@soundscape26) on "Debunking claims that Kate Middleton's cancer reveal video is AI-generated • FRANCE 24 English" video.

She debunked the sweater and the ring.
8
Well, you just have to prove it then
5
@crystalawen So, after watching the original HD video with the ring not disappearing you still think it's "pure nonsense"? Well ok. The shirt was proven to be different so, claiming it was edited is a bit of a cop-out. The bench panels? The closer things are to the camera will the bigger they will appear of course... everything normal here, you only need basic notions of perspective to get that. The video is too perfect to be AI. We're not there yet.
4
@Ckawauchi35 Perfect in what sense? What are the imperfections you have noticed?
4
@missbettyboop2509 You are the one making an accusation so the burden of proof falls on you.
4
@crystalawen I think you are wrong, but in any case this is not a subject I care for at all... being a photographer I just felt like dropping one or two remarks.
3
Of course we will... some people have too much time on their hands.
3
@baristaTam Honestly, the video looks too perfect to have been AI. I don't know that lights they are using behind the cameras so I cannot comment on any shadows other than not seeing anything really unusual. If you apply your super detailed scrutiny to all videos you see you'll find plenty of those supposed inconsistencies as well. Also, the press was all up in arms when a minimally doctored photo of the royal family was published some weeks ago but all of a sudden would go silent over an AI video? The tabloids would have a field day with this one if true. When AI will reach a point capable of producing a video like this one then we may well start questioning every video we see.
2
@dimitrabouzalas3090 I did. Not convinced.
2