Comments by "" (@Rav01508) on "The Armchair Historian"
channel.
-
581
-
19
-
8
-
@stayprepared2388
Indians love bragging about their military strength against China but ....
1) India lost the 1962 full scale WAR against China. Fact is, China defeated India despite India having the upper hand and having the support from Israeli weaponry and USA's military support. Do yourself a favor and enlighten yourself with some research on "Israel aid to India 1962 war" and "US aid to India 1962 war". Bear in mind that the Chinese were still recovering from their Great Chinese Famine from 1958 to 1962 which resulted in approximately 30+ MILLIONS people starving to death. From a logical and strategic point of view, would China start a war with India when they are lacking the ability to feed their people let alone their army? 🤭 They couldn't pick a better timing to start a war? Would they want to start a war when there was massive famine? Think, Indian, think !! 🤭
2) Because it was such an embarrassing defeat for the Indians, they had to resort to creating lies that they won the 1967 "war" against China. However, facts say that there is no "war" between China and India on year 1967 but only a small battle/skirmish which lasted merely 1-3 days. I ask you this question, would a "war" last merely for 3 days if both parties are really serious about defeating each other? 🤭 The desperation to win and salvage their over proud ego is real 🤭
3) China defeated India and took back Aksai Chin as war trophy on year 1962 and ever since then, India did not dare to make any claims to Aksai Chin.... and not even after the "victory" that they claimed to have won over the Chinese on 1967 could inspire them and gave them the morale to take the war to mainland China. This is because they have tasted and remembered thoroughly the humiliating defeat they suffered back on year 1962 and would not risk another full scale war with China. 🤭
4) India attacked China through forward policy on year 1962 when China was recovering from their Great Chinese Famine on year 1962. India saw it as a godsend once in a lifetime opportunity to steal more land from China when the Chinese was weak and helpless to even feed their army. Henderson Brooks and Neville Maxwell details what actually happened during the 1962 war between China and India. When their report was leaked momentarily on year 2014 in the internet, India wanted the report to be purged from the internet out of desperation because they were the aggressor yet shifting the blame to China.
5) The year now is 2023 and India is still unwilling to declassify the report even after 60+ years.... You got to wonder why lol... 🤭A guilty conscience? Something to hide? 🤭
6) China has the video proof of China's victory over India in the 1962 war, captured in black and white films, and have the war trophy (Aksai Chin) and the Indian prisoners of war to back up their historical victory whereas India has no video proof of India's victory over China in the 1967 "war" and no war trophy or Chinese prisoners of war to back up their "victory". 🤭
8) Since the dawn of time, India is always seen as being more inferior than China. Remember who is the British's 🐕🦺🦮🐕🐶? 🤭It took 8 countries ,including Britain, to invade and subdue China whereas it took merely 1 country, Britain, to invade and subdue India easily for 200+ years 🤭 Fact. This is the undeniable proof that China was way more powerful than India by at least 8 times. If China was as weak as India, the British would have China solely for themselves instead of giving others a share of the profit. China was invaded but was never colonized by Britain or else communism in China wouldn't exist and everyone will have to adopt English as their official language to communicate and serve their white masters, the British, unlike India 🤭
1
-
@stayprepared2388
Indians love bragging about their military strength against China but ....
1) India lost the 1962 full scale WAR against China. Fact is, China defeated India despite India having the upper hand and having the support from Israeli weaponry and USA's military support. Do yourself a favor and enlighten yourself with some research on "Israel aid to India 1962 war" and "US aid to India 1962 war". Bear in mind that the Chinese were still recovering from their Great Chinese Famine from 1958 to 1962 which resulted in approximately 30+ MILLIONS people starving to death. From a logical and strategic point of view, would China start a war with India when they are lacking the ability to feed their people let alone their army? 🤭 They couldn't pick a better timing to start a war? Would they want to start a war when there was massive famine? Think, Indian, think !! 🤭
2) Because it was such an embarrassing defeat for the Indians, they had to resort to creating lies that they won the 1967 "war" against China. However, facts say that there is no "war" between China and India on year 1967 but only a small battle/skirmish which lasted merely 1-3 days. I ask you this question, would a "war" last merely for 3 days if both parties are really serious about defeating each other? 🤭 The desperation to win and salvage their over proud ego is real 🤭
3) China defeated India and took back Aksai Chin as war trophy on year 1962 and ever since then, India did not dare to make any claims to Aksai Chin.... and not even after the "victory" that they claimed to have won over the Chinese on 1967 could inspire them and gave them the morale to take the war to mainland China. This is because they have tasted and remembered thoroughly the humiliating defeat they suffered back on year 1962 and would not risk another full scale war with China. 🤭
4) India attacked China through forward policy on year 1962 when China was recovering from their Great Chinese Famine on year 1962. India saw it as a godsend once in a lifetime opportunity to steal more land from China when the Chinese was weak and helpless to even feed their army. Henderson Brooks and Neville Maxwell details what actually happened during the 1962 war between China and India. When their report was leaked momentarily on year 2014 in the internet, India wanted the report to be purged from the internet out of desperation because they were the aggressor yet shifting the blame to China.
5) The year now is 2023 and India is still unwilling to declassify the report even after 60+ years.... You got to wonder why lol... 🤭A guilty conscience? Something to hide? 🤭
6) China has the video proof of China's victory over India in the 1962 war, captured in black and white films, and have the war trophy (Aksai Chin) and the Indian prisoners of war to back up their historical victory whereas India has no video proof of India's victory over China in the 1967 "war" and no war trophy or Chinese prisoners of war to back up their "victory". 🤭
8) Since the dawn of time, India is always seen as being more inferior than China. Remember who is the British's 🐕🦺🦮🐕🐶? 🤭It took 8 countries ,including Britain, to invade and subdue China whereas it took merely 1 country, Britain, to invade and subdue India easily for 200+ years 🤭 Fact. This is the undeniable proof that China was way more powerful than India by at least 8 times. If China was as weak as India, the British would have China solely for themselves instead of giving others a share of the profit. China was invaded but was never colonized by Britain or else communism in China wouldn't exist and everyone will have to adopt English as their official language to communicate and serve their white masters, the British, unlike India 🤭
1
-
1. Was Tibet an independent country before 1912?
Tibet was an independent country before 1246. From 1373 to 1578, Tibet rulers paid tribute to Chinese Ming dynasty government many times. In 1642, Dalai Lama invited a Mongol tribe’s troops to come into Tibet to fight other opposite Tibetan groups. Tibet was then controlled by this Mongol tribe. This Mongol tribe voluntarily submitted to the Chinese Qing dynasty in 1653 for Chinese support to defend against west Mongols. In 1705, Chinese emperor abolished the 6th Dalai Lama for his violation of Buddhist obligation, and ordered him to be arrested and sent to Beijing for punishment. He died on the way.
Since 18th century, Dalai Lama had kneed down towards Chinese emperor’s picture many times during ceremonies. China posted a garrison in Lhasa from 1751. Tibet respected Chinese government’s sovereignty, which is typically shown in the selection of the 10th Dalai Lama in 1822. Britain and Russia recognized Tibet as a part of China in 1906. China ruled Tibet directly from 1910 to 1911. Since Manchu are Chinese citizens and support China’s claim on Tibet, Chinese regarded China after Qing as a legal successor of Qing dynasty. (In fact, Western countries made sure China became the successor of Qing dynasty, so that China could continue to pay the huge ransom owed by Qing to the West countries after it was defeated in 1900.)
2. Was Tibet an independent country between 1912 and 1950?
After the collapse of China’s Qing dynasty in 1912, China witnessed a lot of civil wars and warlordism until 1949, but did not denounce its claim on Tibet. Tibet never declared independence towards China or other countries during this period. (The 13th Dalai Lama himself denied (to the British) that he had ever authorized the Russian subject--Agvan Dorjiev, to sign a treaty with Mongolians on behalf of Tibet. So, that 1913 treaty is not valid.) USA officially recognized Tibet as a part of China in 1943, way before communist China existed.
No country in the world recognizes Tibet as an independent country, or officially regard Tibet as not a part of china, or officially regard Tibet as occupied by China.
3. Did Tibet has opportunity to defeat Chinese invasion in 1950?
Tibet is huge and has very high altitude and very thin air which is difficult for Chinese to breathe, let alone climb mountains. The total length of road which a 4-wheel vehicle can drive in whole Tibet was only 4 kilometers in 1950. Chinese has to across many high mountains at very high altitude for 2000 kilometers to get to Lhasa. There was little sources of food or even water. In short, Tibet was a perfect place to wage guerilla war on Chinese troops, and that is exactly what CIA recommended to Tibetans. In 1950, Tibet had about 100,000 bolt rifles and many Tibetans were hunters and can shoot very accurately over long distance. If Tibetans used guerilla war to attack Chinese supply line, Chinese troops will starve to death and have not way to advance across 2000 kilometers of mountains (without road) into central Tibet. Instead, Tibetans choose to sign the peace liberation treaty after only two hundred Tibetan soldiers got killed in the Chamdo battle in 1950. In short, Tibetans had good chance to defeat Chinese in 1950 if they really want. But it is impossible in 1959 since China had built 3 roads (totally >4000 kilometers) and bridges into Tibet since 1950.
4. Why Tibetans rebelled in 1959?
Before 1956, most Tibetans were serfs, and most lands were owned by noblemen and monasteries. The part of Tibet (central) ruled by Dalai Lama enjoyed very high autonomy within China from 1950-1959. China launched land reforms in the Chinese directly ruled (east) Tibetan areas in 1956, taking land from noblemen and monasteries and distributing them to the serfs. Rebellion led by noblemen and monasteries broke out in east Tibet in 1956, with independence as the slogan to get support from serfs, and spread to Lhasa in 1959, encouraged and supported by the CIA.
5. Does China repress Tibetans and practice cultural genocide?
No. Besides, there is a long covered fact (by all parts involved) about China and communism. Chinese communism was created with the help of Soviet Union, and controlled by Stalin. After the Second World War, Soviet Union supplied Chinese communist troops with captured Japanese weapons including 2700 artilleries, and produced ammunitions and weapons for communists in Russia-occupied China’s north-east. USA organized an international arms embargo to the troops of Chinese anti-communist government. Chinese nationalist government troops were poorly equipped with little artilleries and ammunition. Communism caused at least 60million Chinese death. The truth is: communism was forced upon to Chinese by Soviet union with the help of U.S. So, China should not be blamed for the destruction of Tibetan culture in Cultural revolution in Tibet.
1