Comments by "antonyjh1234" (@antonyjh1234) on "Ukraine. Military Summary And Analysis 2023.02.12" video.

@daffyduck780 the Israeli intelligence came out with a figure that was close to what Scott Ritter and Col Macgregor has mentioned, if Ukraine won't tell the figures and Russia is very good at announcing what they have lost, we can have a fairly good idea that might be very close to reality. The reality is something to consider moving forward, even if it were equal which I find hugely optimistic as all russians have a year of by law, military service under their belts and Ukraine hasn't had this for a decade before this, but even if deaths were equal, Ru has 30-50 million they can put into this if it becomes a world war.
4
The west spent 8 years putting trenches in that Ru has rolled over, the issue is western weapons in Ukraine and the people prepared to use them, the best they can hope for is Russia stops here or at the Dnieper and that will only occur if Ukraine gets rid of all weapons , Kiev could be on the border but only if they are prepared to be neutral.
3
@yuriylevchenko6667 It won't or at least might not, that is the issue people seem to ignore but a reason US is continuing in this losing war, lose the Petro dollar and the US dollar could halve in value, BRICS, the SCO, Russia taking payments in other forms than US dollars, along with 80% of the worlds population possibly ignoring it. They are 4.2% of the worlds population but use 25% of the worlds energy, no one needs USA as a trading partner in the future though. Africa will be almost half the worlds population by 2100, India and China next, huge populations of poor people that are seeing an increase in spending power, one that China will provide the goods for and Russia providing the energy. USA could become a failed state if it doesn't stop its warmongering that most of the world see's.
3
@yuriylevchenko6667 They have a country of 150 million, roughly half these are male, that have all had a years military service, fighting age is between 18 and 55 but if you think men above 55 aren't going to get involved then you are mistaken, again, nevertheless, does it matter if it's 40 million, 30 million, 20 million, as far as the army of Nato, even if they include USA, is concerned. Next if Nato and all its constituents are treated like the males are in Ukraine are, India, Africa, China is on Russia's side in this, do you really think they will stand by when they know that what's happening in Ukraine will happen to them, if they do nothing? I mean your logic is illogical if you think otherwise.
2
@christophersmith8316 Good point, as long as Ukraine disarms and loses control of being able to cut supply there's no real need to cross it as a river makes a great border, militarily.
1
@daffyduck780 But it does have an incentive to tell the truth, it tells its citizens the truth to let them honestly know what is happening, because it might mean an enlistment drive that is unexpected. If these deaths the Russians are experiencing are found to be false, then the population of Russia will lose faith in their military/Putin and that's not what they are about, lying to their population. The opposite is true of Ukrainians and the western media as the truth would mean people in western countries might rise up, much like the Rage against the war machine meeting on Feb 19th. Keeping the truth from the west and admitting the possibility of 160,000 dead and 350,000 injured would shock a lot of people who are told that and believe Ukraine is winning. I would put it to you that dismissing people who know war better than me and probably you, is suiting a narrative of its own.
1
@daffyduck780 I could claim russians have men on Mars, what you have to work out is if those "some" have a narrative or not and why they might also claim these things, but logically, do you really believe that Russians who have had a year of military service against people that don't, are going to be equal in numbers pf deaths, ordinary civilians who have had no military training until they got forced to fight at gunpoint or die, or even going against people who might have had the last 9 years experience this has been going on, do you really believe there isn't a mismatch or do you believe the fairy story that Ukrainians are super soldiers? I don't speak Russian so I wouldn't know of what their media says, it's the general who comes on who gives the read outs of what is happening, it is the telegram channels of Ukrainians that show how they are losing, remember Ru has gone over the defences that USA has put in over the previous 8 years. Beside all that, moving forward, the narrative of Ukraine not losing these numbers does suit a narrative, can you see that?
1
@daffyduck780 PS: You can't lie to your public in this, not with the media we have these days, not anymore. Russians wouldn't take it and it would be very soon found out and they would want a faster destruction of Ukraine, this attrition war saves men on the Russian side, there is still a lot of weaponry ready in Russia that is being held back because there is probably a fear NATO/USA will put official boots on the ground. In Ukraine no man is allowed to leave the country, 16 year olds are being registered, all of Ukraine knows this truth of what is happening, we just don't report any of the truth, the both of us are as good as the information we have been given, I, in a western country don't believe our own media because none of the last 9 years has been reported honestly, so I am very doubtful of what some say in the west.
1
@yuriylevchenko6667 You think the NATO army is more than the 50 million men Russia will put into this? If you think it gets to the stage of NATO countries putting their citizens into world war then it will be RIP world.
1
@yuriylevchenko6667 100%, I have a friend who has one grandson in Russia, and one in Ukraine, and in no way does she think RIP Russia, she thinks Russia will go all the way to the border of Poland. I am outside of Russia, Ukraine/USA, I am in a western country, but I really think USA is signing its own death warrant with its actions here.
1
@jonathontyynismaa5310 Any action will always get a reaction, force is another name for violence, it just depends on which side you are, a civil war doesn't help anybody because most would be fighting against something and not for something. If for something is correctly identified, then what would it be? Peace and non-violence? How would you get that if you had to kill people to get it? USA as a system does need to change, doing everything for money and making money the ultimate goal of everything has its drawbacks, for example there are huge amounts of good land that is in what are now called slums, huge area's are devastated by poverty and the houses are gone, what would be better, giving these area's more money or planting apple tree's? I would go with tree's, put fruit tree's into these area's and teach them that they can work the land again, people have lost the ability/desire to grow their own food when the land is sitting there empty, let that land be bought by the govt and if not used for housing let vege's get grown. I get that has issues for farmers and profit down the line but that is the issue, how much money is needed to maintain the system and how much money govt receives all up and down this line. Councils/governments should only do the jobs we tell them too, not them trying to squeeze every cent they can out of us and them telling us what to do. I agree a revolution does need to happen but the longer we have corrupted, self-interested councils/govts that don't really care about the people at heart but maintaining the system as is then either the harder or easier to change it will be I am not sure... One thing I know we could possibly be seeing the end of US hegemony in our lifetimes, in the next few years even and for people within USA it would be far better to spread vegetables gardens far and wide than rifles.
1
@jonathontyynismaa5310 Interesting you mention a civil war and then this comes up in my feed : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r06F-Auyx3U
1