Comments by "QWE RTY" (@QWERTY-gp8fd) on "Why was the Qing Dynasty so weak? History of China 1644-1839 Documentary 1/10" video.

@YizhouRong bruh it cant even build toilets
146
@jont2576 lol what? russian empire,spanish empire,mongol empire,abbasids,umayyads,Xiongnu Empire were all bigger than china
15
@jont2576 mongol empire at its height had 110 million people or more than 25% of world population. in comparison ming had 58 million population. only during late qing era chinese population exploded.
12
afghanistan also survived. that dont make them strong. its sign of weakness
5
@охотникТомпсона well because theyre british itself.
3
@kanding3369 romans are there currently know as italians. when han dynasty fell, jin dynasty came into power. its just change of name nothing else. as a example. mussolini's foreign policy aimed to restore the ancient glory of the roman empire by expanding Italian colonial possessions and the sphere of influence. if italians aint romans why would they try to revive the roman empire?
2
tell that to mongols who were defeated by ideology
1
@熊掌波清波 what does 清流 mean?
1
@kanding3369 if u cant deny my point then stop trying to change the topic. china civilization or mongol culture was tiny etc. how is that relevant to mongol empire being larger than any chinese state? i dont remember saying anything besides naming empires that are bigger than china.
1
@kanding3369 china being center or not totally irrelevant to my point. ur arguing me not that guy. if u agree with me then this argument is ended. he claimed china was big i denied his claim. nothing else. read this again. but slowly. >no other empire before the renaissance rivalled the size , scale and economic power of china except for Rome and persia and the british> yes lets look at bigger picture. china is one of the earliest civs but u know what they came from? africa. and u know what humans were before leaving africa? we were monkies. thats why there is reject humanity,embrace monke meme. see its absurd. stay on the topic otherwise the debate is endless. also i never said anything about mexico.
1
@kanding3369 mongol empire bigger,populous than any chinese dynasty. u agreed so fin.
1
 @kanding3369 i didnt fell to ur shitty whataboutism cuz of that im small man? LOGIC 100
1
@jiajohn2183 im mongolian m8. i consider myself different than chinese. our current government is not even similar let alone the culture,language. by ur logic usa is canada because they both briton. britions colonized india. that dont make british a indian empire. still a part of british empire same apply to yuan. its part of chinese history where china was occupied by foreign nation. also mongolia fought for its independence and won with outside support. that dont make mongolian independence any less legit just like america did it with french,spain,dutch help.
1
@jiajohn2183 i never said chinese were ashamed to admit sinicization. yuan dynasty is just mongol domination of china nothing else. its time were mongol was elite and chinese was lowest class citizen. i seriously dont know what cultural impact u talking about. everything about chinese culture seems very foreign to me.
1
@jiajohn2183 inner mongolian culture in minority culture, mongolian culture is separate. problem solved. u got one thing wrong. last mongol state the dzungar khanate fell to qing in 1755 not during ming dynasty. ming never occupied any of mongolia territory not even inner mongolia. it only paid tribute.
1
@kanding3369 fair enough whataboutist.
1
Nazi Germany largest contiguous empire
1
@history1077 what u talking about
1
@christianriddler5063 lol philippines is island m8 it dont border any country.
1
@christianriddler5063 >They didn't trade with China for thousands of years i thank ur poor english for further proving my point. tanzania also share oceans with india. that dont mean anything.
1
@christianriddler5063 so what did i lie about?
1
@ikengaspirit3063 mongolia once traded with hungary. so mongolia,hungary alliance confirmed? in essence this is ur argument. trade ultimately means nothing. every nation traded with each other at one point
1
@ikengaspirit3063 the name han comes from mongolian word "dweller" . china system of government and characteristics copied from yassa so technically speaking japan,vietnam,korea,philippine is poor man's mongol.
1
@xcutioner5411 yes only mongols can colonize china.
1
@buddhashaqtea2577 prove it
1
@milanvitu3963 so how many of them are actually speak sakhan and identify itself as different people?
1
@sephiroxicalcloud3771 mongols tried to sack beijing but failed.
1
@Brandonhayhew its still over the top brutality in ukraine. 100k dead russians, 150k dead ukranians just within 1 year
1